My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 15, 2021
10:12
:17
am
BigYfan
All-American
That is the definition of hyperbole
Giving a guy a star rating based off what Nick Saban does? You do realize Alabama actually recruits and signs recruits that aren’t rated 5 stars right?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
BigYfan
New username
Big12Yfan
Bio page
BigYfan
Joined
Jul 13, 2001
Last login
Sep 10, 2021
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Brief thoughts on Hall v Romney v Conover.
Penske Material
6/14/21 5:01pm
I say take the 2-3 great games from Hall if you can, then adapt. Play the best guy now.
Turnpike Lane
6/14/21 5:06pm
I have the same concerns about Hall
2FarGone
6/14/21 5:09pm
We’d move to Romney who has already shown the ability to win games. We’d use that time to prep Conover just in case
YIsForBrigham
6/14/21 5:14pm
Probably, but I have heard that the plan was to bring in Conover this year at some point regardless
2FarGone
6/14/21 5:18pm
Heard from who?
BigYfan
6/14/21 5:25pm
IIRC; Wilson came in because Mangum was underperforming
Powerbait DPM
6/15/21 6:18am
I don't understand why Romney gets constantly downgraded for that win over BSU.
Lance71
6/14/21 5:17pm
Agreed, and I meant to stress that he did execute well. But to say, as some
Penske Material
6/14/21 5:30pm
So, a good game manager. Good it. I agree.
Turnpike Lane
6/14/21 5:34pm
Yes, which is more than BYU has had at QB before Wilson for a very long time.
Lance71
6/14/21 8:18pm
It could be argued Ty Detmer was a consummate game manager, mostly.
SinkingQuffa
6/14/21 9:52pm
RE: It could be argued Ty Detmer was a consummate game manager, mostly.
akbarishiwatsu
6/14/21 11:51pm
I think a lot of top programs roll their dice on the vice versa oftentimes.
SinkingQuffa
6/15/21 12:04am
<< Deleted >>
kudzucoug
6/15/21 7:30am
my quick (unpopular) thoughts
warp
6/14/21 5:30pm
The OL returns 6 guys have have started multiple games, so better than average.
Turnpike Lane
6/14/21 5:37pm
When you say Conover was “highly” recruited
BigYfan
6/14/21 9:43pm
You could say the same about Wilson
wildeone
6/14/21 11:49pm
He was a Four Star
2FarGone
6/15/21 12:04am
For sure he was higher rated than Hall and Romney
BigYfan
6/15/21 5:59am
That Saban flew out to Arizona to offer him makes him as good as a 5* in my mind
SinkingQuffa
6/15/21 8:31am
That is the definition of hyperbole
BigYfan
6/15/21 10:12am
Not more hyperbolic than the things said about Hall
2FarGone
6/15/21 11:07am
Hyperbole? I drew a comparison I meant to be taken literally.
SinkingQuffa
6/15/21 11:13am
You said he was a 5 star in your mind simply because Saban offered him
BigYfan
6/15/21 5:29pm
Yeah. The winniest college HC of the biggest program in the country.
SinkingQuffa
6/15/21 5:43pm
And here are his offers: he was highly recruited (notice the four stars)
2FarGone
6/15/21 12:10am
I don't think that's unpopular at all.
Eddie
6/15/21 1:28pm
You play the best player regardless
kimdaddy35
6/14/21 5:34pm
Right. That nonsense about possible re-injury would have unfairly cut short a
Forzaitalia
6/14/21 7:36pm
The thing about Hall is that he started 2 games, and got a concussion in each
Dan
6/14/21 7:58pm
Isn't it possible that Hall never recovered fully from concussion #1 and was
Forzaitalia
6/14/21 8:50pm
But what a college career Austin Colley had. I would call him a
84 natlchamps
6/14/21 9:11pm
Yes. And Austin was afforded several chances to play in the NFL after worse con-
Forzaitalia
6/14/21 9:28pm
What if the best player is a freshman without college game experience?
2FarGone
6/15/21 12:08am
If he can perform consistently better against our 1st team defense when they are
kimdaddy35
6/15/21 10:32am
I agree
2FarGone
6/15/21 11:06am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad