My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 5, 2012
4:49
:58
pm
PhillyYFan
In the current format a non BCS team is going nearly every..
... year. The current BCS format has only been around for just over a dozen years. Utah's feat would be fun but not remotely close to a National Championship.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
PhillyYFan
Bio page
PhillyYFan
Joined
Feb 10, 2002
Last login
Nov 19, 2013
Total posts
21,612 (6 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
We have out grown a team that has been ranked in the top25
Bluedomination
8/5/12 3:53pm
So the real question is, what would you rather have:
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 3:57pm
Neither, I want score board.
AFwingnut
8/5/12 3:58pm
Yeah, when comparing the two teams, that's really
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 3:59pm
LOL!
Bluedomination
8/5/12 4:01pm
Exactly....BYU has legacy and recent success
jrifkin48
8/5/12 5:38pm
Recent success?
DoseOfReality
8/6/12 9:48am
In that case recent success is only considered last 3 years
BYUFam1
8/6/12 9:57am
And most fans just use whatever standard fits their argument
DoseOfReality
8/6/12 11:03am
And then I saw your gifSig
DoseOfReality
8/6/12 11:07am
Well they are
Ragid1
8/6/12 11:21am
I am not even talking about on field performance, we are
Bluedomination
8/5/12 4:03pm
Actually, in your post you were talking about football and
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:06pm
Ok fair enough, I am talking about on field performance for
Bluedomination
8/5/12 4:09pm
If you wanna have yet another P12 inclusion argument, then
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:13pm
Yeah, who cares about on-field performance
Medute
8/5/12 4:07pm
We also have more titles in football, too.
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:10pm
Yes you do and that's a good point
Medute
8/5/12 4:15pm
It's really only the last 10 yrs...
icecougar
8/6/12 3:41am
Agreed, good summary
Medute
8/6/12 3:43am
In a weird way...
icecougar
8/6/12 4:44am
Agreed, and I have no problems with those guys
Medute
8/6/12 6:32am
LOL, you exagerate terribly and I'll put you in your place
Bluedomination
8/5/12 4:12pm
Here is what is sad
Medute
8/5/12 4:23pm
+1. As soon as this thread got fired up I remembered who
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:27pm
This is a hipocritical post after the complete exageration
Bluedomination
8/5/12 5:59pm
What's the head-to-head records over the last 20 years?
Medute
8/5/12 6:05pm
Utah 12, BYU 8 but why only 20 years
Bluedomination
8/5/12 6:18pm
ok, you win
Medute
8/5/12 6:19pm
that's why to me the only relevant h2h discussion is...
icecougar
8/6/12 4:48am
And BYU has more
byu1
8/5/12 5:37pm
If we were talking about on field performance BSU would be
Bluedomination
8/5/12 4:07pm
You're saying, that ALMOST finishing 1st, twice, ...
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:08pm
So you'd pick history. That's your opinion.
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:11pm
That's a lot of weight you put on TWO seasons.
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:12pm
I find it funny that you are trying to diminish the
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:14pm
Well, I can't speak for other CBers...
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:15pm
BCS wins has been the measure of success in CFB
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:18pm
No, National Championships are the common measure of success
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:21pm
Ok, I'll give you that.
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:25pm
Ok, I like that. We're agreed.
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:27pm
If Big time=programs like
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:29pm
Cool. Fair enough.
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:30pm
of course you wouldn't personally care for a WAC title
BYUFam1
8/5/12 4:25pm
it's ironic but it's only because they're sick of hearing...
icecougar
8/6/12 4:29am
It's been 2-3 decades
Medute
8/5/12 4:13pm
Yeah, and one National Champtionship is still more than...
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:15pm
I was 4
Medute
8/5/12 4:17pm
That's a good point.
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:31pm
By that argument, those games didn't happen...
BluePete
8/5/12 4:35pm
Right.
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 4:40pm
I certainly didn't mean that
Medute
8/5/12 4:49pm
All things equal, yes. But a National Championship isn't...
PhillyYFan
8/5/12 5:05pm
Yeah, but it's not like BYU did anything different than Utah
Medute
8/5/12 5:09pm
FAIRLY? Are you kidding me?
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 5:10pm
Tell me what BYU accomplished on the field that Utah didn't
Medute
8/5/12 5:16pm
You're grasping at straws.
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 5:37pm
You keep twisting my point
Medute
8/5/12 5:49pm
You said, and I quote,
WaHooWaCoug
8/5/12 6:18pm
Something BYU's team did...
BYUFam1
8/5/12 6:52pm
You make a really good point
Medute
8/5/12 8:29pm
Let me help you out...
macaroni
8/5/12 7:06pm
BYU spent 3 weeks at #1 before the bowls in both polls
BYUFam1
8/5/12 7:30pm
The whole Bama didn't want to be there thing is stupid
Medute
8/5/12 8:38pm
Well there is a playoff now
Ragid1
8/6/12 11:17am
Your post is possibly the worst post in this entire thread
macaroni
8/6/12 3:33pm
Colorado, Georgia Tech, Minnesota, Syracuse
Medute
8/6/12 3:43pm
That's crazy, but not surprising
macaroni
8/6/12 8:44pm
I was "college age"...it means lots, trust me.
BluePete
8/5/12 4:32pm
53 years...kind of a random number
Medute
8/5/12 4:51pm
I was 7 ... and there's no way I'd trade you.
PhillyYFan
8/5/12 4:41pm
Keep in mind it's a National Championship that no one said
BluePete
8/5/12 4:45pm
You won the CFB beauty pageant
Medute
8/5/12 4:54pm
Yep. The same beauty pageant
macaroni
8/5/12 6:01pm
Hold those games dear to you they are precious rare gems. ha
Oompabluepaw
8/5/12 4:43pm
In the current format a non BCS team is going nearly every..
PhillyYFan
8/5/12 4:49pm
Really?
ragid
8/5/12 9:41pm
Interesting question
Medute
8/5/12 10:47pm
LOL, in twenty years from now no one will ever mention your
Bluedomination
8/5/12 11:12pm
RE: Interesting question
BYUFam1
8/6/12 12:08am
Not at all what I said
Medute
8/6/12 2:50am
Timing does make a difference.
ragid
8/6/12 9:16am
Legacy for sure
Jeffacka
8/5/12 4:08pm
I can understand your opinion.
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:12pm
BYU has so much tradition and history
Jeffacka
8/5/12 4:15pm
Ok.
VirginiaUte
8/5/12 4:18pm
i remember Ute fans using
byukarl
8/5/12 4:40pm
The PAC 12 isn't hard for me
Jeffacka
8/5/12 4:43pm
See, we can have both, you can kind of have one.
Mr Blue
8/5/12 4:37pm
PS team, VirginiaUte is definitely a Ute and not a yewt
BYUCougarsFan
8/5/12 4:56pm
+1
icecougar
8/6/12 4:55am
Medute is cool too.
ragid
8/6/12 9:13am
Awww shucks. Although many would not agree :)
Medute
8/6/12 2:55pm
Will Your Answer Apply To Basketball?
TarheeledCoug
8/6/12 7:31am
Yes, I think it would.
VirginiaUte
8/6/12 3:51pm
That is a beautiful hold on #72 you have in your gif.
TBirdCougar
8/6/12 8:05pm
I've never taken my eyes off of JW IV long enough during
VirginiaUte
8/6/12 8:23pm
Ok, time for UOP category. 'Ute Obsession Post' They don't
MatthiasG
8/5/12 9:27pm
Yes, then I can ignore it. Would be wonderful
yfootball
8/6/12 8:26am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad