I thought HP had waaaaaaaaay better character development than SW

Report problem with this ad

Jul 15, 2018
10:02:35pm

Crazy Duck Walk-on

and that's just looking at the movies. (Obviously the books were better because, well, they are books)

Report problem with this ad

Crazy Duck

Previous username: -C9-
New username: -C9-
Bio page: Crazy Duck
Joined: Feb 26, 2011
Last login: May 17, 2019
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

When you compare the writing of star wars and Harry Potter,

johnnycarson

7/15/18 9:46pm

Why does no one want to direct it? and why do they want to quit?

Flyingdolphin

7/15/18 9:48pm

Apparently they are changing directors and Kennedy is

johnnycarson

7/15/18 9:56pm

She should have just let the director and creative teams do their thing

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:00pm

They already have a director. It’s jj abrams. They want to replace the head of Lucas film, Kathleen Kennedy, but no one

sgriff

7/15/18 10:04pm

But I don't think it was always Abrams. They fired someone.

johnnycarson

7/15/18 10:05pm

Kennedy fired Colin Trevorrow (Director of Jurassic World)

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:07pm

True. I bet he’s kinda relieved now.

sgriff

7/15/18 10:09pm

The problem with SW is that it’s been over 40 years since the beginning and fans put it on a pedestal

IceBlueCoug

7/15/18 9:49pm

History judges

TNT

7/15/18 9:51pm

The other problem is Lucas. He had a great idea

johnnycarson

7/15/18 9:52pm

Maybe the writing is tidy because it's from... books

Crush4

7/15/18 9:51pm

And the same person

Kerbouchard

7/15/18 10:00pm

This is the biggest reason all movies from books are generally better

Nat Gas Man

7/15/18 10:15pm

This is the most true statement on CB for ages.

UNHuskerCoug

7/15/18 10:40pm

SW is a Great universe with dumb stories

Mrs Featerbottom

7/15/18 9:53pm

That's kinda true.

johnnycarson

7/15/18 9:54pm

Kinda my point with my post below.

Mrs Featerbottom

7/15/18 9:56pm

Hero of a Thousand Faces

TNT

7/15/18 9:54pm

I don't like eigher much, but at least star wars doen't put me to sleep quite as

Plato

7/15/18 9:54pm

I thought HP had waaaaaaaaay better character development than SW

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:02pm

It does for sure. But the first 3 sw movies did a much better

johnnycarson

7/15/18 10:03pm

Oh I completely agree. This new series had so much potential too...

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:05pm

Problem with the newest SW characters is you dont care about them.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:01pm

TLJ really killed the character development for everyone

Crazy Duck

7/15/18 10:03pm

True....you got an idea in Force Awakens....then TLJ did nothing with it.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:06pm

Yep, you end up not caring at all if the new characters bite the dust

Crush4

7/15/18 10:03pm

I wouldn't have been sad if Finn died in that final scene of TLJ.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:08pm

And *spoiler alert A* turned into a real *spolier alert B*

Gil Buckman

7/15/18 10:17pm

No need for spoiler alerts with Star Wars.

WJCougar

7/15/18 10:23pm

Lucas had one of the greatest & absolutely

Downtown

7/15/18 10:24pm

Lucas didn't throw anything away, he sold it for over $4 Billion. Disney's going to come out in the black too.

Bert609

7/16/18 6:32am

I’m talking 1997 when he started “fixing” the originals

Downtown

7/16/18 9:21pm

I am a huge Harry Potter fan but the writing is anything but neat and tidy.

RalphWiggam

7/15/18 11:15pm

I think that's part of the point. Re-reading (listening?) to the HP audio-books with my kids and Rowlings

Bert609

7/16/18 6:33am

SW movies >>> HP movies

Gorum the Old

7/16/18 7:42am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad