To me, it seems clear that BYU extra-curricular activities are about what they bring to BYU, not what it provides the students.  I would prefer they look at what they provide the student. To give the coach (who by the way is a volunteer and received no compensation) and kids no explanation other than, "we don't want a wrestling club" is inconsiderate at best.  To make matters worse, they do allow a Quidditch club.