Grimes hasn't had a chance to put his offense up against cupcakes. Detmer did

Sep 19, 2018
8:46:02pm

califcougar All-American

And still could not score. I'm not ready to anoint Grimes as an amazing OC. But, I have already come to the conclusion that he is definitely better than Detmer.

Report problem with this ad

califcougar

Previous username: orhscougs
Bio page: califcougar
Joined: Nov 17, 2008
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 7,429 (49 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Detmer offense ranked 120. Grimes offense ranked 113.

idcougarfan

9/19/18 8:38pm

Grimes scored 28, 18, and 24 vs P5 teams.

Brigham

9/19/18 8:39pm

28, 11 (3 with the game in doubt) and 24.

smokymountainrain

9/19/18 8:41pm

Scoreboard!

Soy Celeste

9/19/18 8:43pm

No one argues Detmer is on the Rushmore of BYU football.

sidsie716

9/19/18 8:39pm

Makes sense. We're still not getting the passing yards. That's up to Tanner and the receivers

Grit for Brains

9/19/18 8:41pm

BYU and Notre Dame are tied at 104 for points/game. Stat doesn’t mean

Coach's Dad

9/19/18 8:45pm

And 45th in points scored if you only count games against Power 5 teams.

Coach's Dad

9/19/18 8:47pm

Does AZ count as P5 team?

Coogar2

9/19/18 9:29pm

Yep. They are even 50th in scoring offense.

Coach's Dad

9/19/18 9:55pm

Grimes hasn't had a chance to put his offense up against cupcakes. Detmer did

califcougar

9/19/18 8:46pm

I get what you're saying but Arizona, turns out, is a cupcake

Unibro

9/20/18 8:36am

RE: I get what you're saying but Arizona, turns out, is a cupcake

cmarrio

9/20/18 9:28am

Better than Portland State and UMass who Detmer struggled against

califcougar

9/20/18 10:59am

Have to factor how many P5s have played no one and padded stats

the_byu_flash

9/19/18 8:46pm

So, for the record, you're basically trolling by definition.

Lip Gallagher

9/19/18 8:51pm

Check the opposition played in compiling these stats. Will be more comparable at

chilango

9/19/18 8:51pm

TOP has to be way better. So many 3 and outs last year

Idahofallsblue

9/19/18 8:59pm

Too small of a sample size for a valid comparison.

BluesBrother

9/19/18 9:25pm

That means almost nothing at this point in the season.

GOR

9/19/18 9:37pm

Detmer had 2 seasons, while Grimes has had 3 games. There is a noticeable difference in just watching the team this year

Bleedblue84

9/19/18 9:40pm

BYU 2018 Offense Efficiency Ranked 72, 2017 Offense Efficiency ranked 121

Dr T-bone

9/19/18 9:42pm

We are running less plays than last year. Better performance per play.

scott715

9/19/18 10:49pm

Everyone loves Detmer but this was based on results not love

Bobmarleyjr

9/19/18 9:50pm

Who’s the common denominator in both of those rankings?

Gerald-DeGroot

9/19/18 9:52pm

Detmer was horrible

Josef K

9/19/18 10:11pm

We scored 10 points on UMASS... 10... Kalani retained Ty far longer than he needed to

monkeycowboy

9/19/18 10:41pm

It depends what stats you look at, and the ones you are referring to I wouldn't

cougarfan84

9/19/18 10:53pm

It's near impossible to compare Detmer and Grimes

bigjohn

9/19/18 11:29pm

Hot take alert. What other FBS team has played 3 P5 teams so far?

BigHouse Coug

9/20/18 12:17am

Only one. UTSA.

StalwartBraveTrue

9/20/18 7:01am

Detmers offense didn’t score it’s 9th TD till game 7. Grimes, game 3

SlantRoute

9/20/18 1:35am

^^^^^this^^^^^

Adrielle

9/20/18 6:19am

TM wil

blackshirts

9/20/18 7:13am

There seems to be a common denominator

beauso79

9/20/18 8:59am

This year through 3 games: 23.3. Last year through 3 games: 11.0

Mojojojo

9/20/18 9:20am

Grimes gave us the Cal game so we could remember what Detmer was like as an OC

Steven Koren

9/20/18 10:23am

The second half was remarkable similar to last years offense. Pretty scary! Glad

Posting on CougarBoard