Yes I agree my opinion is go G5

Jun 25, 2019
6:32:15pm

tatertot9 Walk-on

But I do get both sides of the argument, I just don’t think we will ever compete if we stay independent and I care more about winning than anything else

Report problem with this ad

tatertot9

Bio page: tatertot9
Joined: Dec 4, 2013
Last login: Jul 22, 2019
Total posts: 67 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU will not compete staying independent no matter how much you wish they could

tatertot9

6/25/19 5:38pm

FCS would be even better than AAC

Remigius

6/25/19 5:41pm

Lol

tatertot9

6/25/19 5:42pm

RE: FCS would be even better than AAC

Samurai Jack

6/25/19 7:21pm

Staup...this is such a silly counter argument.

Traveshamockery

6/25/19 9:41pm

Is it though?

Remigius

6/25/19 10:00pm

If we were in the AAC the past 6 years (since inception) I can only see one year

rcbyufan

6/25/19 5:44pm

Look what Boise state has done in the mountain west

tatertot9

6/25/19 5:52pm

Won 3 road P5 games in 20 years? For reference Kalani also has 3.

rcbyufan

6/25/19 5:55pm

Ok and they are a lot more nationally recognized than BYU at the moment

tatertot9

6/25/19 6:00pm

But they had to paint their field like it was a duck pond to do so.

rcbyufan

6/25/19 6:03pm

Well EWU has a red field and most people haven't heard of them

BYU Fan

6/25/19 6:05pm

They beat Oklahoma (check), TCU (check), and Arizona (check)

rcbyufan

6/25/19 6:15pm

We are P5 when it comes to fan base, attendance, resources, facilities, etc.

boscatar

6/25/19 6:28pm

Yes I agree my opinion is go G5

tatertot9

6/25/19 6:32pm

Maybe we should go JC then.

Q-grr

6/25/19 8:14pm

Good one

tatertot9

6/25/19 8:26pm

Compete for what?

a priori

6/25/19 6:38pm

Compete for conference championships and NY6 bowls

tatertot9

6/25/19 6:39pm

Anyone who said that BYU "quit" when they went Independent doesn't have a clue.

a priori

6/26/19 9:51am

I believe BYU went independent to try and keep up with the Utes

BYU Fan

6/26/19 10:07am

Nope — they went Independent to stop dealing w/ the MWC.

a priori

6/26/19 10:41am

I'd agree this was another factor - the MWC leadership & TV deal was a joke

BYU Fan

6/26/19 10:46am

With the high risk of independence, come bad consequences.

boscatar

6/26/19 9:09am

Sure — but watch what happens when BYU pulls off two 10 win season in a row.

a priori

6/26/19 9:52am

Is winning 10 games in back to back seasons a realistic hope w/ indy schedules?

BYU Fan

6/26/19 10:05am

No idea. I'd rather be Independent than win fake trophies in a G5 league.

a priori

6/26/19 10:42am

I'd rather win than play fancy exhibition games

BYU Fan

6/26/19 11:23am

So, you want BYU to have a schedule full of the UNLV, Wyomings, and New Mexicos

a priori

6/26/19 6:09pm

Highly unlikely scenario when we play 5 to 7 P5 opponents per year

boscatar

6/26/19 11:17am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad