If they are a good to great G5 team in their best years, then

Report problem with this ad

Oct 12, 2019
11:15:57pm

LiveCoug All-American

in their best years, Indy can be successful

Report problem with this ad

LiveCoug

Bio page: LiveCoug
Joined: Aug 26, 2001
Last login: May 7, 2024
Total posts: 112,428 (11,477 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

You can love independence all you want, but facts are facts. Indy is killing

TrueBlue67

10/12/19 10:34pm

It’s not Indy. It’s losing to bad to average G5 teams. Which are still there in a G5 conference.

Turnpike Lane

10/12/19 10:36pm

Bronco was beating G5’s as Indy and recruiting still was stagnant

franklyvulgar

10/12/19 10:38pm

October 2014 debunks your theory.

UberDeek

10/13/19 1:38am

We’re losing to bad G5 schools. Independence has nothing to do with that

YIsForBrigham

10/12/19 10:37pm

Competency trumps everything. You are looking at the wrong variable.

WizeGuise

10/12/19 10:38pm

Oh boy..now its Trumps fault 😂

whiteninja

10/12/19 11:30pm

This is the truth, but the problem is not Kalani. Its Independence and TH.

studmuffin85

10/12/19 10:38pm

Being in a conference does not solve recruiting unless that conference is P5

8-track

10/12/19 10:38pm

Not true. Playing regularly in Texas and Florida could help.

RealityCheck

10/13/19 12:23am

BYU should go back to the MWC, two rivals in that conference.

studmuffin85

10/12/19 10:38pm

Ugh, please stop making this argument

robin

10/12/19 10:38pm

Yep, that's the only variable. Case closed.

Byron McNertney

10/12/19 10:38pm

How does Utah going pac-12 at the same time factor in? What recruiting battles

SMITTY

10/12/19 10:39pm

Totally. I bet all the top athletes are dying to play in the AAC.

The Dude Abides

10/12/19 10:40pm

Yeah, the stadium, atmosphere, and support at USF were unreal. Eye roll.

dtownCoug

10/12/19 11:25pm

Longest period that BYU has gone unranked at the end of the season since prior to Lavell...

Coug

10/12/19 10:40pm

Joining a G5 conference WILL. NOT. SOLVE. THE. PROBLEMS

LiveCoug

10/12/19 10:40pm

WE HAVE BEEN TRENDING DOWN SINCE THEN bronco went from

franklyvulgar

10/12/19 11:09pm

You state that like I disagree with you. Obviously that's been the trend.

LiveCoug

10/12/19 11:11pm

fair Enough, BYU can play p5 as Indy if they want but they belong in a g5

franklyvulgar

10/12/19 11:12pm

If they are a good to great G5 team in their best years, then

LiveCoug

10/12/19 11:15pm

Successful to get to 8 wins and a bowl game

franklyvulgar

10/12/19 11:19pm

Our ceiling is well below our ceiling when we were in the MWC.

Coug

10/12/19 11:27pm

2-2 v P5 in 2019 but sure

Turnpike Lane

10/12/19 11:25pm

Demoralizing blowout loss and two field goals away from 0-4 but sure

franklyvulgar

10/12/19 11:27pm

Winless against G5. Hmmm...maybe there's more going on here than your simplistic analysis.

Byron McNertney

10/13/19 7:44am

How is Boise, USU, UCF and all these other G5’s who beat us and are above our level not only able to win and get ranked.

Coug

10/12/19 11:26pm

BYU built the program on beating g5 teams. Bsu stepped in and stole the BYU play

idcougarfan

10/12/19 11:35pm

Players get to walk past conference championship trophies and awards and see the success..

Coug

10/12/19 11:40pm

Too many BYU fans think BYU is better than they are.

idcougarfan

10/12/19 11:57pm

We became too cool for the g5 when we left to Indy like saying to Utah, see

franklyvulgar

10/13/19 12:01am

I do think we needed to go Independence for a time...

Coug

10/13/19 8:58am

Except that was not the justification for going independent.

RealityCheck

10/13/19 10:59pm

Dumb argument. BYU would have to spend millions buying out game contracts.

Richbyu

10/12/19 11:24pm

BYU gets out of independence or drops football.

ohiocougar

10/12/19 11:43pm

RE: You can love independence all you want, but facts are facts. Indy is killing

Posting on CougarBoard