My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 2, 2019
2:32
:49
pm
kimdaddy35
All-American
So we are a worse team than Toledo? Yikes
A 3 year sample size is bigger than a one game sample size.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
kimdaddy35
Bio page
kimdaddy35
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Last login
May 4, 2024
Total posts
46,453 (1,476 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
My last post: Sad reality. BYU is the 3rd best football program in Utah over
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 1:56pm
Bye bye, credibility.
All-American
12/2/19 1:58pm
Facts are tough
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:12pm
You should try using them sometime. Your take is nonsensical.
All-American
12/2/19 2:22pm
What about my take was not based in fact?
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:27pm
The ones you ignored.
All-American
12/2/19 3:09pm
And yet, Utah State's biggest win the last 3 years is probably over BYU.
Doogal McCougar
12/2/19 2:00pm
Well, you've included an outlier for each team in your calculations
mwcoug
12/2/19 2:00pm
For trends over 3 seasons you can't ignore 1/3 of the data
MikeDitka'sStache
12/2/19 2:02pm
You can if they are outliers
rggee
12/2/19 2:03pm
BYUs worst season ever and USUs best season ever just happened to happen in the
mwcoug
12/2/19 2:30pm
If there was only a way to figure out who was better on the field. That would be
Blueto
12/2/19 2:01pm
BYU over the last 3 years vs Utah, USU: 1-5
MikeDitka'sStache
12/2/19 2:02pm
You know we are 1-2 vs USU over the last 3 years. Right?
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:12pm
You know we beat them 42-14 this year. Right?
Blueto
12/2/19 2:30pm
So we are a worse team than Toledo? Yikes
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:32pm
Only because it proves your point of view. Why not 10 years? Why not 20?
Blueto
12/2/19 2:43pm
The reason I didn't do it is because I think our team next year will look
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:54pm
One season does not a program make (2017 for us, 2018 for USU)
rggee
12/2/19 2:01pm
I think Utah State has been the better team, but they don't have the better
checoug
12/2/19 2:02pm
um, what? No argument about the direction of BYU/Utah programs at the moment, but
Bob Vance
12/2/19 2:09pm
Over the past 3 years they have been better than BYU
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:17pm
3 years is hardly enough data to identify "program" success. It's enough to chart recent trajectory, and that's it.
Bob Vance
12/2/19 2:20pm
If you say so. 36+ football games from each side seems like a large
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:23pm
Not a single P5 win in three years and USU losses include NMSU, Wyoming
Doogal McCougar
12/2/19 3:01pm
You would have a decent argument if the Sagarin didn't say otherwise
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 3:03pm
It's how BYU established itself in rankings and prestige in pre-independence...
Doogal McCougar
12/2/19 3:11pm
We had one of our worst years in program history, they had their best
Doogal McCougar
12/2/19 2:25pm
Oh, by the way they have a much better coach than BYU does
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:21pm
don't know about that. prior history success, sure. Gary has not exactly got a hotly burning trajectory right now
Bob Vance
12/2/19 2:27pm
Remember when we beat them exactly 1 month ago? What was the score?
DieHarder
12/2/19 2:11pm
As I said, over the past 3 football seasons they have been the better team
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:19pm
Your post makes it sound like you’re saying we’re the 3rd best program, not the 3rd best program over the past 3 years
DieHarder
12/2/19 2:24pm
Good edit. Much better post
DieHarder
12/2/19 3:01pm
Thanks, it more accurately reflects my intent
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 3:05pm
Utah State is a program that is exactly the function of whatever HC they have. They are like aluminum foil. If there
Bob Vance
12/2/19 2:24pm
And yet despite the fact you gave, they have outperformed BYU and a coach
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:29pm
Both programs are going into heavy rebuilds in 2020
donnerstag
12/2/19 2:30pm
College football programs don't rebuild for 3 years
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:38pm
Utah State was 6-7, 3-9, and 6-7 prior to last season at 11-2
donnerstag
12/2/19 2:54pm
Yes, USU used to be a horrible program
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 3:00pm
Except that right before USU's 3 year fall they went 11-2, 9-5, 10-4
donnerstag
12/2/19 3:13pm
Your problem is that you only see a successful year in terms of wins/losses on
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 3:26pm
Virginia was 5-7 the 2nd year prior to Bronco taking over
donnerstag
12/2/19 3:49pm
I was on their boards after that season and they were pretty happy
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 5:40pm
Do 4 or 5 years. USU has a nice high and BYU has a nice low tucked into there
BrutustheBrash
12/2/19 2:31pm
I think as long as our current regime is coaching we are more likely to
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:35pm
But it also conveniently ignores a change in regime with USU
BrutustheBrash
12/2/19 2:41pm
Gary Andersen is a much more highly regarded coach than Kalani
kimdaddy35
12/2/19 2:56pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad