So what would you call NIU, Toledo, SDSU, and Hawaii then?

Report problem with this ad

Feb 19, 2020
4:18:01pm

ldssdl All-American

Report problem with this ad

ldssdl

Bio page: ldssdl
Joined: Mar 3, 2013
Last login: May 7, 2024
Total posts: 29,190 (3,824 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Zach is the best QB on the roster — objective analysis reveals this

Gotnotact

2/19/20 3:48pm

Again? Man...let's wait until fall camp.

Preppy

2/19/20 3:49pm

Yes. Again. And I'll post as much as I want. Especially when I'm right.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 3:53pm

RE: Yes. Again. And I'll post as much as I want. Especially when I'm right.

Preppy

2/19/20 3:59pm

I agree with you. 100%. I went and watched the Boise game again

BYURider

2/19/20 5:56pm

Zach may yet turn out to be the best QB of the 3, but you're not proven right

ldssdl

2/19/20 6:00pm

okay, can you tip us off when you plan to post about something that you're right

icecougar

2/19/20 7:20pm

We'll see in spring ball. Glad there is competition. All 3 deserve it.

Turnpike Lane

2/19/20 3:50pm

Totally agree.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 3:51pm

There is no competition. The staff already promised it to zach and his family

indocoug

2/19/20 4:11pm

Not anymore.

Mathew

2/19/20 4:13pm

Lip service/coach speak so guys won't transfer is all it was

indocoug

2/19/20 4:14pm

precisely my fear

icecougar

2/19/20 7:21pm

Was that before year one?

ColonelMustard

2/19/20 10:00pm

Hopefully there will be a real competition and not the coaches

dodgersjazzcougs

2/20/20 1:55pm

give it up. you already posted this morning....

idacoug

2/19/20 3:53pm

That was last night.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 3:54pm

You've convinced us....you certainly were up in the night.

StarMan

2/19/20 4:03pm

People are interested in what I have to say.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:39pm

I think we're more interested to see how long you're going to keep trolling this topic

Wingnut

2/19/20 4:41pm

I think people are interested in disagreeing with you.

pilot17

2/19/20 4:41pm

And they click.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:47pm

Oh brother...he was the worst of the three last year and struggles agonist G5

Dangerous

2/19/20 3:53pm

He'll be named the starter by the end of Spring Camp. Even at the end of 2019...

Gotnotact

2/19/20 3:56pm

Reason for that: Romney and Hall were injured

ataylor

2/19/20 6:22pm

Not for the Hawaii Bowl

Rat

2/19/20 7:14pm

For the Hawaii Bowl:

ataylor

2/19/20 7:26pm

Sure, but it stills proves my point since they were cleared to play.

Rat

2/19/20 9:37pm

Big difference between being cleared to play and being considered healthy enough

ataylor

2/19/20 9:59pm

BYU has 3 very average and interchangeable D1 QBs.

Backcountry

2/19/20 3:54pm

Hopefully someone will emerge. The returning stats from receivers are concerning

Gotnotact

2/19/20 3:56pm

Good QBs cover that weakness pretty well

puntersarepeople

2/19/20 3:59pm

He was the best QB for Utah that's for sure.

byubyu

2/19/20 3:55pm

He had the best performance against Utah of any BYU QB in a decade

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:00pm

I've got a 5' tall tool box with almost "all the tools imaginable, but it

Mountain Rat

2/19/20 5:46pm

I think the skill throws show his talent

puntersarepeople

2/19/20 3:57pm

He was bad against UW and Toledo before the injury.

Dangerous

2/19/20 3:57pm

Offensive line was Swiss cheese vs UW. ZW actually started strong

puntersarepeople

2/19/20 4:01pm

I think that's a fair point...

icecougar

2/20/20 11:57am

The thing with Wilson is that he has a bright future IMO if he can figure out

puntersarepeople

2/20/20 12:55pm

RE: Zach is the best QB on the roster — objective analysis reveals this

USMCdad

2/19/20 3:57pm

At least be transparent. Feel you’re one of these 3:

Soupie

2/19/20 3:58pm

None. Never met him or his mom.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:01pm

Shame, she’s pretty cool

USMCdad

2/19/20 4:04pm

I'm no QB coach, but there was a comfort I felt with Romney under center that I

hxmCougar2000

2/19/20 4:00pm

Because he was going against easier teams

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:01pm

Wasn't Boise State ranked at #14 when he played against them?

Wingnut

2/19/20 4:03pm

Paper tiger

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:06pm

So what would you call NIU, Toledo, SDSU, and Hawaii then?

ldssdl

2/19/20 4:18pm

Clearly the next 4 in when the P5 expands

USMCdad

2/19/20 4:19pm

Did BYU really play anyone who was great? Weren't they all paper tigers or paper

ochobeeguy

2/19/20 4:21pm

Hmm, I think Zach played during some of the ugly losses against "easy teams"

Preppy

2/19/20 4:05pm

This is also true. He's got work to do.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:38pm

bingo

BYURider

2/19/20 5:58pm

Romney is a better decision-maker, Zach has more physical gifts

inertiaman

2/19/20 4:15pm

This might be true.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:16pm

There is so much you don't know. You should try harder to be on certain FO's.

Mathew

2/19/20 4:04pm

Like the ones you and your cool friends are on?

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:15pm

You finally got-it-no-tact

Mathew

2/19/20 4:18pm

Sounds like you've got a lot of friends.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:39pm

One or two

Mathew

2/19/20 4:47pm

At this point, your posts are doing more to provoke criticism of each of the

gwalker

2/19/20 4:08pm

He’s not looking to be positive at all for BYU, he’s clearly trolling

USMCdad

2/19/20 4:10pm

Lifelong fan. Incredibly positive advocate of BYU. Just a realist.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:23pm

When it comes to Zach, it doesn't sound like you're a realist

Mountain Rat

2/19/20 5:51pm

We get it. A 14 year fan.

ochobeeguy

2/19/20 7:52pm

^This

ColonelMustard

2/19/20 9:04pm

I wish him the best

BYU Fan

2/19/20 4:14pm

What is your relation to Zach?

conetah

2/19/20 4:20pm

A valid question.

ochobeeguy

2/19/20 4:21pm

None. Zero. I've seen him in person twice, against Utah and USC.

Gotnotact

2/19/20 4:27pm

Where's the objective analysis part of the post?

fldnstrm

2/19/20 5:10pm

He might be. But his play last year has allowed the door of competition to justifiably be reopened.

SpiffCoug

2/19/20 5:55pm

That’s fair

Gotnotact

2/19/20 6:33pm

Agreed! Signed Zach's Mom

icecougar

2/19/20 6:18pm

Dude you’ve got to stop. You are embarrassing yourself and your friend Zach

ColonelMustard

2/19/20 6:19pm

Gotnotact

2/20/20 12:18am

PS Boardname checks out

ColonelMustard

2/19/20 6:21pm

If our QBs were cars....

Pretorian

2/19/20 6:59pm

RE: Zach is the best QB on the roster — objective analysis reveals this

icecougar

2/19/20 7:07pm

Offense sucks anyway, Defense has been the saving grace

XwhyZ

2/19/20 7:19pm

WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON

Michael McQuain

2/19/20 7:27pm

RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON

ataylor

2/19/20 7:30pm

RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON

ataylor

2/19/20 7:34pm

RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON

ataylor

2/19/20 7:36pm

RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON

ataylor

2/19/20 7:37pm

Okay, I’m done

ataylor

2/19/20 7:38pm

RE: Okay, I’m done

Cru Jones

2/19/20 9:10pm

RE: Okay, I’m done

Cru Jones

2/19/20 9:10pm

RE: Okay, I’m done

Cru Jones

2/19/20 9:10pm

RE: Okay, I’m done

Cru Jones

2/19/20 9:11pm

RE: Okay, I’m done

Cru Jones

2/19/20 9:12pm

Zach had Ty'Son and didn't do well. Baylor had Katoa and Finau and won a huge

Ash

2/19/20 7:37pm

2-2 against the meat of the schedule isn't doing well?

puntersarepeople

2/19/20 8:25pm

LOL, are you honestly comparing Finau to Ty'Son?

Ash

2/19/20 10:17pm

No. But I think there was a huge drop off without Finau as there was without

puntersarepeople

2/20/20 10:43am

Romney's worse game was better than ZW best game in 2019. Drop the mic 🎤

blackshirts

2/19/20 8:35pm

stats are more helpful in context

puntersarepeople

2/19/20 8:43pm

Simple, QBR

blackshirts

2/19/20 8:52pm

Zach Wilson is NOT undoubtedly the best QB on BYU's roster

CaliforniaCougar22

2/19/20 9:31pm

Yes he is

Gotnotact

2/20/20 12:23am

I’m not really sure how “objective” that analysis is.

CoachSpeak

2/19/20 11:19pm

There is nothing in your post that’s objective, at all.

akmewg

2/19/20 11:30pm

Will someone please agree with gotnotact so he can

coastcat

2/20/20 6:50am

Subjective reality reveals you don't know what objective reality is.

canofpicante

2/20/20 9:02am

Two examples (from source) of INTs not ZW's fault.

TailgateU

2/20/20 9:36am

The first one the wr fell down...

CoachSpeak

2/20/20 9:39am

Still went through his hands. A receiver needs to catch that ball.

TailgateU

2/20/20 9:58am

And Zach needs to make a better throw...

CoachSpeak

2/20/20 10:23am

The receiver must catch that.

Gotnotact

2/24/20 11:50am

That's a nice slogan

shakarocks

2/24/20 11:58am

And Zach must throw a better ball...

CoachSpeak

2/24/20 12:04pm

It was a crap throw high and behind the receiver.

shakarocks

2/20/20 10:39am

Who cares?

shakarocks

2/20/20 10:11am

not to mention the many dropped INTs that DBs could / should have caught

mcnasty

2/20/20 12:45pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad