I deal with actuaries all the time (30+ years)...
And most of the ones I know will laugh at your statement. You are risking $30-40k (per your post) because you want to save ~$80 a year.
I have hit both deer and elk...
I have been caught in a flash flood...
I have totaled a cars...
And i have 3 kids that all had cars damaged in High School parking lots.
I wish you the best of luck. (at least if you crash into me I know my insurance will cover it 🙂 )