He seemed relatively average in height, speed, and skill when watching BYU play, but he was so incredibly dominant in that game, faster, stronger, more athletic in every way, as if I'd been playing against some sixth graders. He was playing team ball, but could have just kept the ball and scored every single time. I'm 6'4", and could dunk at the time, but it was embarrassing how bad I was relative to this dude. I couldn't get a shot off unless he let me, and couldn't pass the ball without him stealing it. Same for attempting a dribble.
I'd mention his name, as I bet a bunch of people would remember him, but he was most definitely not supposed to be playing pickup basketball.