People are going to judge him on postseason accomplishments. That is the worst measuring stick for a QB out there. Plenty of great QBs never won a SB, and plenty of crappy ones did. A SB is a team accomplishment. The Chargers were never really all that good the entire time Rivers was there. They had some nice players from time to time. But they never had a chance at a SB with the rosters they built. I really don't like the Chargers at all. But, Rivers should absolutely be in the HOF.