1. He does not take into account the health of Wilson as a senior and the NFL goes to great lengths to protect QBs
2. He does not do any analysis of Wilson as a QB, just relies on 1 QB being good and 1 being a bust. Whereas Simms actually breaks down what he likes and does not about each QB
3. It seems that only Simms takes into account the quality of players around the QB, not that BYU's talent was bad, but when compared with Clemson or Ohio State it has less talent.