I hate this excuse.

Jun 13, 2021
9:40:53pm

Mises All-American

I hate this excuse.

It's a way to exclude non-P5 teams without it being obvious collusion. If a non-P5 team looks like it could be a contender, well, their schedule is weak, as it is every year by definition. Circular logic for the P5 win.

Report problem with this ad

Mises

Previous username: bastuta
Bio page: Mises
Joined: Jan 13, 2004
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 5,652 (142 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Joining the BigXII would be nice, but quite honestly, after what I saw last year

ColdFusion1989

6/12/21 3:25pm

Sked was weak last year

Iman23

6/12/21 3:31pm

1–Iowa St had 3 losses

Fifty Shades of Blue

6/12/21 3:38pm

Not only 3 losses but was criticized for the loss to Louisiana.

ColdFusion1989

6/12/21 3:53pm

Nevertheless, their final Sagarin SOS was #17;

Everyman

6/12/21 4:26pm

RE: Nevertheless, their final Sagarin SOS was #17;

akbarishiwatsu

6/12/21 10:42pm

Yeah, hard to overlook the schedule

Dr T-bone

6/12/21 3:40pm

I hate this excuse.

Mises

6/13/21 9:40pm

Using the 2020 schedule v B12 schedule that got Iowa State in is funny.

Turnpike Lane

6/12/21 3:36pm

If we had same success last year but with the big12 lable, very different post

viper

6/12/21 5:04pm

What prejudice?

cougssu

6/12/21 5:42pm

You must be new around these parts....

Michael McQuain

6/12/21 6:16pm

Maybe....just maybe...

cougssu

6/12/21 10:21pm

BCS championships??

BYUBandfan

6/13/21 9:35pm

Yes

cougssu

6/13/21 9:48pm

There's a very big difference between winning a BCS Championship and winning a

BYUBandfan

6/13/21 10:27pm

2-0

cougssu

6/13/21 11:46pm

1-0 National Championships

BYUBandfan

6/14/21 12:01am

From 1984

cougssu

6/14/21 7:20am

Still counts

BYUBandfan

6/14/21 8:16am

They didn't earn the championship for just winning 1 game

BYUBandfan

6/14/21 8:19am

I'm sure it played a role, but there definitely other factors as well

krindorr

6/14/21 6:14am

RE: Joining the BigXII would be nice, but quite honestly, after what I saw last

BYUgeezer

6/12/21 6:13pm

Bad take. Iowa State made it to the Fiesta Bowl last year

reddead

6/12/21 6:52pm

Glad you feel that way. I saw them conveniently climb in the rankings w/ 3 Ls

ColdFusion1989

6/12/21 7:06pm

And it has everything to do with conference affiliation, not BYU bias

reddead

6/12/21 7:16pm

Which leads us back to the original post. By every metric we should be P5.

ColdFusion1989

6/12/21 7:36pm

It sounds to me like you care a great deal about P5 membership...

reddead

6/12/21 8:52pm

BYU has long been worthy - attendance, academics, facilities, multiple sports

Cswilliam01

6/12/21 11:20pm

There’s no question that BYU has the resources of a low-mid P5 program. But

reddead

6/13/21 2:04am

There is no wat pay to translate your comment

Cswilliam01

6/13/21 9:38pm

See my post above. They played 6 teams that were in the CFP final ranking.

Everyman

6/12/21 10:42pm

Yeah sorry can’t go there. BYU needs to be in a P5 conference or we will forever

BlooCoog

6/12/21 10:35pm

Interesting.

Stev_ie

6/12/21 11:06pm

I totally agree. BYU has been discriminated against and it is an old song.

Cswilliam01

6/12/21 11:17pm

It’s amazing to me that the takeaway from BYU losing to to Coastal Carolina

Linescratcher

6/13/21 4:57am

You think BYU was left out and would continue to be left out because of religion

ordinary tri guy

6/13/21 6:38am

I don’t see where we disagree. You made my argument and placed a gif.

ColdFusion1989

6/13/21 7:47am

And why are they not a P5? Oh, could be because of

socorny

6/13/21 7:37pm

Talk about making playoffs a 12 team affair will help BYU’s chances. NYD Bowl

jpal1397

6/13/21 11:30am

Going G5->P5 isn't as easy as we seem to think; not sure why we play the victim

krindorr

6/13/21 1:34pm

Ridiculous post! The reason BYU didn't get a big bowl last year is because we

Posting on CougarBoard