Are you saying that, hypothetically, if BYU had an opportunity to join either

Report problem with this ad

Jun 15, 2021
6:52:39am

LiveCoug Intervention Needed

the Big 12 (or any P5) or the AAC, you'd pick the AAC?

Report problem with this ad

LiveCoug

Bio page: LiveCoug
Joined: Aug 26, 2001
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 112,405 (11,454 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Blog: BYU Football: The reality of being invited to each P5 View

[Lawless Republic] Adam Gibby

6/15/21 6:35am

The only thing a P5 has over the AAC in a 12 team playoff scenario is money.

Lieutenant America

6/15/21 6:50am

Are you saying that, hypothetically, if BYU had an opportunity to join either

LiveCoug

6/15/21 6:52am

No. I’m just saying conference affiliation will be greatly diluted in a 12 team

Lieutenant America

6/15/21 7:01am

It’s more than just money. It’s power.

Everyman

6/15/21 7:05am

<< Deleted >>

AZbronco

6/15/21 7:44am

Take a look at the composition of the committee that decides who gets in

Charles Darwin

6/15/21 7:07am

I understand. But the proposed scenario is still giving births to 6 conference

Lieutenant America

6/15/21 7:13am

Sextuplets? Wow. That’s a lotta kids.

TheWanderer

6/15/21 7:20am

Well not at the same time necessarily. There’s probably people on this board

Lieutenant America

6/15/21 7:26am

“The ONLY thing a P5 has over the AAC….is money”

Charles Darwin

6/15/21 7:31am

I still stand by that. Cincinnati would have been in a much better position than

Lieutenant America

6/15/21 7:38am

<< Deleted >>

byusage

6/15/21 7:42am

Which pays for better coaches, facilities, fans etc. That doesn’t count the NIL

Nat Gas Man

6/15/21 9:06am

Disagree. Power, perception/ prestige, influence (recruiting)

deliciousmocha

6/15/21 8:04am

Would all dissipate over time for conferences. Teams like Clemson and Alabama

Lieutenant America

6/15/21 8:19am

The change to 12 teams is not going to appreciably change the financial model

Nat Gas Man

6/15/21 8:28am

I think if Cincinnati or Boise State can tell recruits they have a legitimate

Lieutenant America

6/15/21 8:42am

Some of those % look high

gmoney7

6/15/21 6:54am

Several deserve a zero percent chance

Archaea

6/15/21 7:55am

they're all high

2FarGone

6/15/21 7:56am

ACC: 0%, SEC 0%, Big10 0%, PAC12 2%, Big12 8-10%

krindorr

6/15/21 9:10am

this looks right to me

Hill4Heisman

6/15/21 11:21am

"Wake Forest, Syracuse or NC State are the most likely to be dropped"? Sorry,

The Chelsea Dagger

6/15/21 10:15am

Saying BYU adds a “ historic aspect” to any conference is just silly especially

NotTokolosh

6/15/21 10:39am

once I saw that some existing teams would be dropped, I knew this was uninformed

Hill4Heisman

6/15/21 11:23am

The NIL and the transfer portal will drastically change everything including

RzrCoug

6/15/21 12:22pm

Dropping a team would result in massive lawsuits. These are college presidents

Nat Gas Man

6/15/21 12:26pm

Eh, it's not just about home markets

krindorr

6/15/21 12:35pm

Even accepting his tenuous reasoning Cincinnati > Evanston as a reason for the

Charles Darwin

6/15/21 12:47pm

Conferences don’t work that way.

Everyman

6/15/21 12:52pm

*Evanston. BYU is as likely to get into the B1G as Northwestern is to be booted.

The Chelsea Dagger

6/15/21 1:54pm

Tennessee probably has more fans in Memphis than Memphis

Nat Gas Man

6/15/21 2:03pm

Or A&M in Houston

The Chelsea Dagger

6/15/21 2:08pm

Or tOSU in Cincinnati

Nat Gas Man

6/15/21 2:10pm

Can we stay in the WCC for other sports and go football only to AAC

Srg

6/15/21 3:01pm

Yup, this is the best answer; but that's been the case for years already

krindorr

6/15/21 3:09pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad