Depends on the situation.

Jul 27, 2021
1:44:02pm

violetjazz All-American

If she stepped down because she knew she couldn't perform at a high level and it was better for the team I would say that fits.

Sacrificing an opportunity like that for the better of your team would be heroic in my mind.

Report problem with this ad

violetjazz

Previous username: grilledcheese
Bio page: violetjazz
Joined: Dec 26, 2015
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 5,328 (121 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If you are not fully mentally dialed in in Olympic gymnastics, you can break your neck.

Sandstone Cougar Overall Decent Guy

7/27/21 1:38pm

This assumes we can flip far enough over to actually land on our heads.

Sea Chicken

7/27/21 1:40pm

Odd that there isn’t more withdrawals or broken necks, then.

Corn Pop

7/27/21 1:41pm

Back when BYU had men's gymnastics, there was a guy in my dorm who was on the team

Indy Coug

7/27/21 1:42pm

I also knew a guy that that broke his neck at BYU

Turd Ferguson

7/27/21 1:47pm

It can and does happen. A neck injury ended a family members gymnastics career.

Sandstone Cougar

7/27/21 1:46pm

That’s not the argument. Severe injuries can happen in most sports.

Corn Pop

7/27/21 1:52pm

It is the core of the argument. I respect any athlete in any dangerous sport who makes that decision. To rip on an

Sandstone Cougar

7/27/21 2:06pm

Yeah its very interesting, if all she could think about was how she was going to

BYUFootballisBack

7/27/21 2:14pm

She is arguably the greatest gymnast of all time, doing tricks NO ONE has done

cougfan03

7/27/21 2:29pm

She is free to quit but shouldn't be lauded as a hero for it

BYU Fan

7/27/21 1:42pm

Depends on the situation.

violetjazz

7/27/21 1:44pm

But then, just two days prior she had the top over all score in preliminaries

Dan

7/27/21 1:46pm

You consider she could be in a worse mental state now than when she competed at preliminaries?

violetjazz

7/27/21 1:47pm

Sure she could be a bit more stressed mentally day to day

Dan

7/27/21 1:53pm

I'm not sure you or I can speak on how easy it would be for her to compete while not mentally all there.

violetjazz

7/27/21 1:57pm

Well that point is hard to argue

Dan

7/27/21 2:24pm

But it was in NO way better for the team. They drop the lowest score for

Adwight

7/27/21 1:47pm

Unless she goes out their severely injures herself and now her teammates have to

BYUFootballisBack

7/27/21 1:52pm

they don't drop the lowest score - they just make the 4th team member compete

The Shazad

7/27/21 1:52pm

I am pretty sure this is inaccurate.

violetjazz

7/27/21 1:55pm

Yep - no one is talking about her teammates who competed, it's all about her

BYU Fan

7/27/21 1:57pm

Media darlings has a whole new meaning now

stoils

7/27/21 2:12pm

Why does the sexual orientation of the soccer players matter?

violetjazz

7/27/21 2:21pm

It matters because it gets clicks

stoils

7/27/21 2:28pm

Really? Who is the most famous female soccer player right now?

violetjazz

7/27/21 2:39pm

The only one on the news is Megan Rapinoe

stoils

7/27/21 2:44pm

That’s the wrong answer, try again. Objectively it is someone else.

violetjazz

7/27/21 2:45pm

I haven’t seen another US women’s soccer player on a tv in a couple years

stoils

7/27/21 2:48pm

RE: I haven’t seen another US women’s soccer player on a tv in a couple years

violetjazz

7/27/21 3:19pm

Pretty sure I was taking about “media darlings” not fame

stoils

7/27/21 3:26pm

You said clicks.

violetjazz

7/27/21 3:40pm

I thought it was pretty clear

stoils

7/27/21 4:12pm

How many headlines about Rapinoe mention she is a lesbian?

violetjazz

7/27/21 4:14pm

Once you push your agenda far enough, everyone knows at some point

stoils

7/27/21 4:30pm

You didn’t answer the question.

violetjazz

7/27/21 4:44pm

Did you expect an actual number? The answer is a lot. And in interviews

stoils

7/27/21 4:47pm

I expected you to look it up and realize it’s very few.

violetjazz

7/27/21 4:53pm

Hot take: I just googled Ellen Degeneres

stoils

7/27/21 5:19pm

*only break your neck in the team competition, not the individual.

Thrill

7/27/21 1:42pm

Would Kerri Strug have been a hero if she refused her last vault?

Dan

7/27/21 1:43pm

It’s not before my time. But if she had refused, she shouldn’t be judged as Biles has here.

Sandstone Cougar

7/27/21 1:44pm

I agree

Dan

7/27/21 1:49pm

Not to mention the fact of the gymnast from Russia, who tore his achilles 3 mon

Adwight

7/27/21 1:52pm

Delete

Dan

7/27/21 1:54pm

she is still doing the individual stuff. Just bailed on team stuff

fulano

7/27/21 1:52pm

If that is the case, it makes Biles look worse IMO

Dan

7/27/21 1:56pm

I would be interested to know the age of everyone responding to this thread.

Falco

7/27/21 1:58pm

Older

Sandstone Cougar

7/27/21 2:05pm

That’s a shame

Falco

7/27/21 2:10pm

I am sorry your faculties have diminished in your advancing years 🙂

Sandstone Cougar

7/27/21 2:11pm

Burn. Hey I get it. Some of us were raised different from others.

Falco

7/27/21 2:20pm

Well over that age for me

Dan

7/27/21 2:10pm

Under 30. You don't quit

reddead

7/27/21 3:59pm

You can break your neck in football or wrestling or cheerleading or x, y, z

reddead

7/27/21 3:59pm

Why don’t you ask her teammates what they think? Their answer is going to be different from yours. Perspective.

Posting on CougarBoard