Sure, 2019 Tyler Huntley probably played better than 2019 Zach Wilson.

But that doesn't make Huntley the better QB. 2017 JT Barrett was much better than 2017 Joe Burrow, which was the last time we could compare their NCAA performance. But that doesn't mean we ignore what Burrow did in the years afterwards.
It's a flawed argument from Yergensen.

That said, icecougar also has flaws. Jason Campbell was drafted in the first round in 2005, compared to Jason White who wasn't drafted at all, despite winning the Heisman. Doesn't mean White didn't have the superior college career.

Or to use an example from closer to home, Ziggy Ansah, Marcus Hunt and Terror Armstead were all highly drafted in 2013 despite limited collegiate production. Sometimes draft picks don't correspond to who was the best in college (not saying it's the case here, but touting where the guy was picked isn't an open/shut argument)