I'd be fine with it if we weren't given a warning. The offense did nothing wrong

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 16, 2021
4:06:08pm

Magathis SCOREBOARD

I'd be fine with it if we weren't given a warning. The offense did nothing wrong

Report problem with this ad

Magathis

Previous username: kakapo
Bio page: Magathis
Joined: Sep 2, 2018
Last login: May 21, 2024
Total posts: 22,657 (9,181 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Officials got the defense sub warning against BYU wrong. It is pretty basic.

9/16/21 4:01pm

The official standing over the ball that moved got it wrong.

fldnstrm

9/16/21 4:02pm

He should have warned himself

g$

9/16/21 4:03pm

Exactly, if anyone should have received a warning, it should have been that ref.

9/16/21 4:05pm

This is what I was thinking. How can the offense know they're not supposed to snap it if

IdahoCoug

9/16/21 4:06pm

Or he got it right and moved after the defense had plenty of time to substitute.

byubyu

9/16/21 4:15pm

If that's the case, they should have called a penalty on Utah, not a warning on BYU.

IdahoCoug

9/16/21 4:57pm

but that would've been out of character with the tone of the officiating up to..

icecougar

9/16/21 7:33pm

Plus, I believe the ref standing over the ball backed off to let the offense go.

bluecheese

9/16/21 4:03pm

That is the biggest issue. Ref screwed up by leaving the ball. Only way BYU

9/16/21 4:04pm

I assumed the reason it was a warning and not a penalty was due to...

Eddie

9/17/21 3:35pm

I was okay with it. The point is to give the defense an opportunity to get their matchup.

Endocoug

9/16/21 4:04pm

They had time, they just slow jogged it one at a time

El Jefe

9/16/21 4:05pm

I'd be fine with it if we weren't given a warning. The offense did nothing wrong

Magathis

9/16/21 4:06pm

Nope, the point is they get 10 seconds to adjust. The officials mussed it up

9/16/21 4:07pm

The rule is written objectively. Follow it as written.

cougfanblue

9/16/21 4:27pm

They clearly took way too much time, there's no way that was our fault

El Jefe

9/16/21 4:04pm

El jefe has spoken

Powerbait DPM

9/16/21 8:00pm

It was Utah's fault for not getting their player off the field. The player got on just fine.

kimdaddy35

9/16/21 4:05pm

there is no 10 second limit - it's up to the official to decide if they've had enough time

molodyets

9/16/21 4:05pm

I think you are right... the official decides how much is enough. PAC12 rule is

9/16/21 4:14pm

The only 10 second substitution rule I could find

BigPepeFan

9/16/21 4:10pm

Didn't BYU stub another player with less than 10 seconds to go?

MrClark

9/16/21 4:11pm

not that I could see on the replay.

9/16/21 4:15pm

I just found it. BYU was jogging off the field too. I don't see anything wrong.

MrClark

9/16/21 4:20pm

I don’t think you know how this works.

9/17/21 5:48am

Haha. They should send 20 offensive players onto the field until 15 seconds left

FromCAtoUT

9/16/21 4:17pm

Too many men in the huddle.

tmurphey44

9/16/21 4:37pm

I didn’t say they would huddle. It would be more of the amoeba approach. Lol

FromCAtoUT

9/16/21 4:56pm

RE: Officials got the defense sub warning against BYU wrong. It is pretty

LUVBYU

9/16/21 5:13pm

The actual rule and what I saw….

trueblueinarizona

9/16/21 5:58pm

Meant for the main thread

trueblueinarizona

9/16/21 5:58pm

The umpire messed up for leaving standing the ball

stev

9/16/21 5:27pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad