My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 16, 2021
4:57
:40
pm
IdahoCoug
A.I. Expert
If that's the case, they should have called a penalty on Utah, not a warning on BYU.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
IdahoCoug
Bio page
IdahoCoug
Joined
Mar 14, 2001
Last login
Apr 30, 2024
Total posts
13,101 (503 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Officials got the defense sub warning against BYU wrong. It is pretty basic.
RealityCheck
9/16/21 4:01pm
The official standing over the ball that moved got it wrong.
fldnstrm
9/16/21 4:02pm
He should have warned himself
g$
9/16/21 4:03pm
Exactly, if anyone should have received a warning, it should have been that ref.
westsidecoug
9/16/21 4:05pm
This is what I was thinking. How can the offense know they're not supposed to snap it if
IdahoCoug
9/16/21 4:06pm
Or he got it right and moved after the defense had plenty of time to substitute.
byubyu
9/16/21 4:15pm
If that's the case, they should have called a penalty on Utah, not a warning on BYU.
IdahoCoug
9/16/21 4:57pm
but that would've been out of character with the tone of the officiating up to..
icecougar
9/16/21 7:33pm
Plus, I believe the ref standing over the ball backed off to let the offense go.
bluecheese
9/16/21 4:03pm
That is the biggest issue. Ref screwed up by leaving the ball. Only way BYU
westsidecoug
9/16/21 4:04pm
I assumed the reason it was a warning and not a penalty was due to...
Eddie
9/17/21 3:35pm
I was okay with it. The point is to give the defense an opportunity to get their matchup.
Endocoug
9/16/21 4:04pm
They had time, they just slow jogged it one at a time
El Jefe
9/16/21 4:05pm
I'd be fine with it if we weren't given a warning. The offense did nothing wrong
Magathis
9/16/21 4:06pm
Nope, the point is they get 10 seconds to adjust. The officials mussed it up
RealityCheck
9/16/21 4:07pm
The rule is written objectively. Follow it as written.
cougfanblue
9/16/21 4:27pm
They clearly took way too much time, there's no way that was our fault
El Jefe
9/16/21 4:04pm
El jefe has spoken
Powerbait DPM
9/16/21 8:00pm
It was Utah's fault for not getting their player off the field. The player got on just fine.
kimdaddy35
9/16/21 4:05pm
there is no 10 second limit - it's up to the official to decide if they've had enough time
molodyets
9/16/21 4:05pm
I think you are right... the official decides how much is enough. PAC12 rule is
RealityCheck
9/16/21 4:14pm
The only 10 second substitution rule I could find
BigPepeFan
9/16/21 4:10pm
Didn't BYU stub another player with less than 10 seconds to go?
MrClark
9/16/21 4:11pm
not that I could see on the replay.
RealityCheck
9/16/21 4:15pm
I just found it. BYU was jogging off the field too. I don't see anything wrong.
MrClark
9/16/21 4:20pm
I don’t think you know how this works.
RealityCheck
9/17/21 5:48am
Haha. They should send 20 offensive players onto the field until 15 seconds left
FromCAtoUT
9/16/21 4:17pm
Too many men in the huddle.
tmurphey44
9/16/21 4:37pm
I didn’t say they would huddle. It would be more of the amoeba approach. Lol
FromCAtoUT
9/16/21 4:56pm
RE: Officials got the defense sub warning against BYU wrong. It is pretty
LUVBYU
9/16/21 5:13pm
The actual rule and what I saw….
trueblueinarizona
9/16/21 5:58pm
Meant for the main thread
trueblueinarizona
9/16/21 5:58pm
The umpire messed up for leaving standing the ball
stev
9/16/21 5:27pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
