No question. But so will Baylor.

Report problem with this ad

Sep 21, 2021
9:06:41am

BlueSteel2021 Walk-on

In other words, I view Baylor and Hall as largely interchangeable right now.

Report problem with this ad

BlueSteel2021

Bio page: BlueSteel2021
Joined: Apr 27, 2021
Last login: Feb 20, 2024
Total posts: 146 (39 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Unpopular opinion about Hall...

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:04am

Hall is a sophomore. He'll improve.

m0resn0w

9/21/21 9:05am

No question. But so will Baylor.

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:06am

The coaches don't agree. It's seems pretty clear that Jaren's ceiling is higher

Schultz is back

9/21/21 9:08am

To be fair, it took the coaches a long time to decide after seeing them daily

Lifer

9/21/21 9:22am

That’s what they said publicly anyway.

NWCoug

9/21/21 9:32am

So, backup QB is better. A typical BYU fan sentiment.

Archaea

9/21/21 9:15am

No, not better. Interchangeable, at least at this point in the season.

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:35am

Not interchangeable, I don't think we beat Utah without Jaren avoiding the rush

GlutealGuy

9/21/21 10:50am

Alright Sister Romney, we'll try to get Baylor the 2nd half against USF

GlutealGuy

9/21/21 9:07am

Here we go, QB2 is the most popular guy almost every yr. Come on man. Hall has

Cougar TD

9/21/21 9:09am

I agree, I think it would be a net positive or very little change overall.

The_Cuss

9/21/21 9:10am

Completely disagree, part of the reason why Hall isn't being sacked

Covid-19

9/21/21 9:10am

But, Baylor arguably goes thru his progressions more quickly, gets the ball out

basman

9/21/21 9:12am

Agree. Having a run threat at QB has a domino effect. Look how we played Daniels

kotacoug

9/21/21 9:14am

Think of all the explosive plays BYU has had this year

Big12Yfan

9/21/21 9:11am

I think with a more natural passer, you'd offset those big plays with others

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:36am

What do you mean by “a more natural passer”?

Big12Yfan

9/21/21 9:40am

From what I've seen of Romney, he's better with his read progressions and has

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:42am

Hall can hit throws that Romney can't though. (Note: I'm not an "arm strength"

rcbyufan

9/21/21 9:45am

I'm not going to question the QB who a) has led us to three straight wins over

Dangerous

9/21/21 9:11am

Yep, and I do not want to bad mouth a player who didn't play. But it is possible

Cougar TD

9/21/21 9:13am

That was the smoke coming out of camp. Conover threw a lot of picks and TDs

Kajdin

9/21/21 9:15am

Going forward we should ALWAYS have a run threat at the QB position. It just

kotacoug

9/21/21 9:16am

My argument isn't to bench Hall. He's certainly earned his place and BYU is

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:37am

Hall has also made some excellent throws. He’s not ZW, but neither is Romney

4thand19

9/21/21 9:11am

Maybe you don't understand what his legs do for the passing game.

The Y's Insider

9/21/21 9:11am

One thing about Jaren is that he seems to have total trust that his hogs and

Bluedomination

9/21/21 9:17am

I don't think that's an unfair take, but it's impossible to know if you're right

byujacob

9/21/21 9:14am

To me it seems like the biggest thing he can improve on is seeing the field

jreid191

9/21/21 9:17am

It seems like that has more to do with the speed of the game. Even though he is

Cougar TD

9/21/21 9:19am

I agree. He's only a sophomore so I'm confident that will come with time.

jreid191

9/21/21 9:24am

This seems to be answer/encompass the situation.

basman

9/21/21 9:24am

I'd agree with all this.

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:38am

I think the key is a higher ceiling...passing game will improve

Lifer

9/21/21 9:20am

I think that's part of it. The other part may be nerves.

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 9:40am

I like it.

JohnnyComeLately

9/21/21 9:25am

It's unpopular because it really isn't true. Accuracy hasn't really been an

Incentivize

9/21/21 9:56am

There are bad takes on CB and there there is this garbage. Hall just did what

cougarbob137

9/21/21 10:14am

Dual threat (with crazy speed) opens up so much. Just beat 3 P5s. Who else has

RWaters

9/21/21 10:18am

<< Deleted >>

AZbronco

9/21/21 10:47am

I kind of agree. His passing leaves much to be desired.

oldrugger

9/21/21 10:49am

We are so fortunate to have a 2nd string QB that is so good.

ditch

9/21/21 10:59am

He's at 60% accuracy with a passer rating 137.91. Those are perfectly fine numbers at this point.

Spiff

9/21/21 11:02am

Let him lose a game this year before you cast the first stone.

buckeyecougarguy

9/21/21 11:04am

Who is casting a stone?

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 11:39am

RE: Who is casting a stone?

buckeyecougarguy

9/21/21 12:24pm

How is saying performance wouldn’t drop off if Romney plays casting stones???

The_Cuss

9/21/21 1:26pm

Nuance on this board is dead. All buckeye heard is "Hall sucks."

BlueSteel2021

9/21/21 1:36pm

You started with "unpopular opinion about Hall" and then proceeded to critique

rcbyufan

9/21/21 1:45pm

This is dumb take

shakarocks

9/21/21 11:16am

Excellent points. Especially true about the passing game.

bleedsblue

9/21/21 11:18am

Just to be clear, everyone that has see all the games/practices, knows Jaren is

rcbyufan

9/21/21 11:26am

You've talked to all of them about this?

dazcoug

9/21/21 6:08pm

I COULDN'T DISAGREE MORE, HERES WHY.

YaHerdWithPerd

9/21/21 12:07pm

Dude. 3-0. I don’t care if he has a walker. 3-0. Some people never happy

Swishfromdeep3

9/21/21 1:42pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad