It was the wrong choice. The downside risk outweighed the upside. If

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 11, 2021
4:02:49pm

OlanchoCoug All-American

It was the wrong choice. The downside risk outweighed the upside. If

we missed that 4th down then we were inviting Boise to take an easy 14 point lead into halftime as well as getting the ball to start the 3rd. We could have easily found ourselves down 21 real fast. We were totally flat with no momentum following the disastrous back to back fumbles. The team needed to punt it away, regroup at half, and come out in the 2nd half with the chance to quickly even out the score.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Oct 11, 2021 at 4:02:49pm

Message modified by OlanchoCoug on Oct 11, 2021 at 4:27:19pm

Report problem with this ad

OlanchoCoug

Bio page: OlanchoCoug
Joined: Jul 26, 2014
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 2,504 (257 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I know people are on Kalani for going for it on 4th & 2 in 2nd half. But we only

rcbyufan

10/11/21 2:53pm

They both are use to playing "slow". But I 100% agree you would think they would both have more of a sense

kimdaddy35

10/11/21 2:55pm

I liked the aggressiveness, just not the play call. A slow developing sweep wasn't good.

DiamondDog

10/11/21 2:56pm

Plus the play had no options in case the first choice was covered.

Hinta

10/11/21 2:59pm

That would have been a good time to have Hall keep it and at worst it is a one on one with lots of field for Hall to get

kimdaddy35

10/11/21 2:59pm

The lineman that tackled TA wasn't blocked well at all. Horrible blocking

SUAVO

10/11/21 3:07pm

It was the play call that was suspect

Kilgruman

10/11/21 6:08pm

BYU took up 11:22 on 2 drives which consumed 24 plays (28.5 secs/play) and yielded 0 points

Indy Coug

10/11/21 3:00pm

It was weird to watch. At one point, I was wondering if the coaches even knew

rcbyufan

10/11/21 3:10pm

I thought the exact same thing. No urgency down 2 scores in the second half. It

'69chevy

10/11/21 6:40pm

The lack of time urgency on the final drives was maddening.

mudpupper

10/11/21 3:04pm

This. I was, and still am truly puzzled at their approach

RockyBalboa

10/11/21 3:20pm

People in the NFL and NCAA are going for it on 4th down more than ever. The analytics are clear. It was the right call.

HarlemCoug

10/11/21 3:07pm

I don't care about the analytics. I didn't like that call. If we punt, odds are

gwalker

10/11/21 3:15pm

If you don't care about the analytics then you want to win fewer games

Gente_Boa

10/11/21 3:27pm

It was the wrong choice. The downside risk outweighed the upside. If

OlanchoCoug

10/11/21 4:02pm

the math is clear. on 4th and 2 go for it when you're beyond your own 28 yard line.

HarlemCoug

10/11/21 4:06pm

If you live in a statistical world where you can repeat that trial indefinitely,

OlanchoCoug

10/11/21 4:31pm

That's a really good point

krindorr

10/11/21 6:15pm

even I agree in your dice example the risk of ruin far outweighs the potential

Gente_Boa

10/11/21 8:17pm

I wasn't applying that to a specific situation, so much as saying situations exist where more than EV matters

krindorr

10/11/21 8:43pm

You completely disregard other factors that played against us there. We were

OlanchoCoug

10/11/21 8:45pm

I'm not disregarding them, I'm saying the marginal value of the expected points

Gente_Boa

10/12/21 10:38am

The math is an average and it doesn’t account for things like the emotional

gwalker

10/11/21 5:11pm

I don’t trust the accuracy of the analytics in the specific case we faced Sat.

gwalker

10/11/21 5:09pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad