Some CBers have such bad bball takes that a few days ago some was trying to

Report problem with this ad

Jan 20, 2022
2:38:32pm

Plato Intervention Needed

convince me that Anson Winder and Halford were better PGs than Kyle Freaking Collinsworth

Report problem with this ad

Plato

Bio page: Plato
Joined: Mar 21, 2017
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 19,793 (473 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Has there been another player who rewrote their own narrative so thoroughly?

Mr. Rumsfield

1/20/22 2:32pm

Many on CB were stupid.

kccougar

1/20/22 2:33pm

Thankfully I wasn’t on CB at the time😉

Mr. Rumsfield

1/20/22 2:44pm

were?

Pangare

1/20/22 3:17pm

Some of us saw it all along. But Tyler was great.

Plato

1/20/22 2:34pm

I was with this category of always having his back

Tuskaloosa Cougar

1/20/22 5:40pm

He was really good for 3 out of 4 years

JoeExotic

1/20/22 2:34pm

And if we are being honest he would have been good 4 out of 4 years

JoeExotic

1/20/22 2:38pm

I think you're the one rewriting history--most loved TJ long before his senior

Incentivize

1/20/22 2:36pm

I will try to find receipts. I could be wrong but I don’t remember this being

Mr. Rumsfield

1/20/22 2:46pm

He was very impressive as a Jr as well. Even better than his Sr yr, stat wise

wickedgame71

1/20/22 2:37pm

Noah Hartsock is one that comes to mind.

Kavorka

1/20/22 2:37pm

Another thing I don't recall. Loved Hartsock.

Plato

1/20/22 2:41pm

People didn't like Hartsock?

kimdaddy35

1/20/22 2:47pm

He was the whipping boy earlier in his BYU career. The guy CB loved to hate

bluelands

1/20/22 2:58pm

Are you sure about this?

Zoobieman

1/20/22 3:05pm

Positive. He vastly improved as a player

bluelands

1/20/22 3:34pm

As a Sophomore he was the highest FG% shooter on the team

Zoobieman

1/20/22 4:06pm

I don't recall this. . . I remember James Anderson though during the same time.

Zoobieman

1/20/22 3:04pm

CB is well known for exaggerating/fabricating shortcomings of players

Indy Coug

1/20/22 2:38pm

Some CBers have such bad bball takes that a few days ago some was trying to

Plato

1/20/22 2:38pm

If some on CB were to have their way...we would finish the season with 4 players

BYUheaven

1/20/22 2:42pm

Seljaas and Nixon

LeonMarek

1/20/22 2:45pm

I loved TJ, but I would take Tyler all day long over him.

kimdaddy35

1/20/22 2:45pm

That is what I’m saying. Even with Tyler being the all-time leading

Mr. Rumsfield

1/20/22 2:48pm

Tyler didn't "take over" as you said because he always had to "take over" for that

kimdaddy35

1/20/22 3:01pm

Fair points. Good old recency bias for the win haha.

Mr. Rumsfield

1/20/22 3:17pm

Yeah, Tyler was the better of the 2 but I’d take either one any year

Bluforever

1/20/22 5:29pm

Of course, I wasn't trying to disparage TJ. Great BYU player.

kimdaddy35

1/20/22 5:30pm

You’re good. I was agreeing with you; but written poorly.

Bluforever

1/20/22 5:33pm

Jimmer?

byujdmba

1/20/22 2:47pm

Skye Povey in Football

Zoobieman

1/20/22 2:47pm

Jonathan Tavernari.

YSMACK

1/20/22 3:11pm

I have a close connection and see him every so often. I love JT.

Mr. Rumsfield

1/20/22 3:16pm

JT is a great, but I do remember comments "Pass to Jimmer".

Zoobieman

1/20/22 3:29pm

Brock Zylstra and Logan Magnusson had the worst fg% in 09/10

YSMACK

1/20/22 3:42pm

Weak argument - Zylstra/Magnusson avg 1.3 shots per game combined.

Zoobieman

1/20/22 4:26pm

P.S. He was a sophomore scoring 30 against Louisville, he was a backup Sr Year

Zoobieman

1/20/22 3:33pm

Senior TJ was excellent. He solved his propensity for TOs that plagued him in

Forzaitalia

1/20/22 3:35pm

His numbers were better his junior year. It was his sophomore year that was rough

Odysseus

1/20/22 3:38pm

<< Deleted >>

HarlemCoug

1/20/22 4:27pm

Jake Toolson

Posting on CougarBoard