Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up
Sep 28, 2022
7:58:30am
Endocoug All-American
RE: BYU vs Wyoming Film Review - Bonus Officiating edition.
Do you have officiating experience? Doesn’t seem like it. You seem like a casual fan.

1) I disagree … ball hiked as the players moved. That’s not a penalty any day of the week.
2) I disagree … didn’t cross 3 yard line, the players seemed to actually stop short of the line. Plus, zero impact on the play. Good no-call.
3) I disagree … marginal argument at best. You said it was “a great swim move.” No it wasn’t! Lol! You also said, “clear as day” to the second angle but you can’t actually see the arm/hand that you claim is holding the player. Very little impact on the play as the defender wasn’t getting the the QB regardless. You also said there was an official on the side who “should have seen it.” However, I not sure it’s that official’s area to cover and, again, I’m pretty sure he wouldn’t have been able to see it as the claimed holding occurred behind a body so he couldn’t see it. There is also a difference between grabbing and an actual holding penalty.
4) Fair point … but it wasn’t blown dead and so that’s a penalty, by rule. Unfortunate but also correct call.
5) Should not get the spot wrong … likely they convert the 3&1. But the spots weren’t off “routinely” the entire game. Come on! Lets be a little fair!

You seem like a casual fan and not an experienced and trained official. Complaining about the officiating is generally lame. They do a very good job and the “next man up” isn’t going to be any better!
Endocoug
Previous username
berkleycoug
Bio page
Endocoug
Joined
Jul 17, 2005
Last login
May 1, 2024
Total posts
10,700 (197 FO)
Messages
Author
Time
9/28/22 11:22am

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.