RE: Not a fumble, and it wasn't a dead ball because refs didn't whistle it dead.

Sep 28, 2022
11:11:35am

Endocoug All-American

After not blowing the whistle they should have ruled on the field as an interception

Why should they rule it an interception when they clearly were able to determine it was an incomplete pass?!? I mean, talk about incompetence!

Report problem with this ad

Endocoug

Previous username: berkleycoug
Bio page: Endocoug
Joined: Jul 17, 2005
Last login: May 1, 2024
Total posts: 10,700 (197 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU vs Wyoming Film Review - Bonus Officiating edition.

Zoobieman

9/28/22 7:36am

RE: BYU vs Wyoming Film Review - Bonus Officiating edition.

shoganai

9/28/22 7:45am

On a low block. I am guessing it shouldn’t be a penalty if you try to execute a

Trent

9/28/22 7:51am

Solid point!

Zoobieman

9/28/22 7:55am

“Intent to commit a penalty”?

Cougarclaw

9/28/22 7:55am

Right? I guess it’s like Intent to Deceive. We get the really rare penalties 😉

Trent

9/28/22 7:57am

Disagree. If you make someone jump aside or over you on an illegal block, they

RobAdams

9/28/22 8:23am

So you are saying by rule no contact is needed for a low block? Are you sure?

Trent

9/28/22 8:46am

I've got a better idea. Stop attempting illegal blocks and they won't get called

Corn Pop

9/28/22 8:51am

Fair. But I still want to know if a whiff attempted penalty is a penalty and I

Trent

9/28/22 9:00am

RE: Disagree. If you make someone jump aside or over you on an illegal block,

imdocrob

9/28/22 10:14am

So should defenses stop faking the blitz? It makes the offense jump.

travelcoug

9/28/22 2:35pm

I'm thinking all fakes of any kind should be intent to deceive penalties. 😉

Trent

9/28/22 3:31pm

How about quarterback draws and option please. They are all based on deception

travelcoug

9/28/22 3:38pm

We should probably just tell the other side what we plan on doing and just pit

Trent

9/28/22 3:47pm

RE: BYU vs Wyoming Film Review - Bonus Officiating edition.

Endocoug

9/28/22 7:58am

Was one of the refs your brother or something? To your points:

Corn Pop

9/28/22 8:32am

RE: Was one of the refs your brother or something? To your points:

Zoobieman

9/28/22 9:04am

I can understand what you were thinking, but if you're going to put a video out

Corn Pop

9/28/22 10:55am

I like you! You can definitely help me improve my videos.

Zoobieman

9/28/22 8:38am

It’s difficult to credibly critique the officiating

Endocoug

9/28/22 9:17am

You don’t need to be a ref to understand that the officiating was not up to par with the national standard

Rat

9/28/22 10:21am

That's true. Just like you don't need to be a police officer to know what bad

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 11:00am

There is a difference between "criticizing" and "critiquing".

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:32pm

This doesn't make sense, so I guess you can say if someone hasn't coached they

byublue42

9/28/22 11:03am

RE: This doesn't make sense, so I guess you can say if someone hasn't coached

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:43am

Nice, you obviously know so much about it that’s great

byublue42

9/28/22 11:00pm

oh good gosh, so that's what all these anxiety laden posts are about?

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 11:27am

Dude. Relax!

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:41am

yes, I'm the one who needs to relax, not the guy who posted 20 times in this

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 12:00pm

This is a garbage take. You can be a fan and criticize the officiating because all a fan needs to know are the rules.

TheLoneCougar

9/28/22 3:32pm

I would like to see the frame by frame on the false start.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 9:10am

RE: I would like to see the frame by frame on the false start.

Endocoug

9/28/22 9:27am

Also, it’s fair to criticize the no whistle on the incomplete pass

Endocoug

9/28/22 9:31am

I agree that the players need to adjust and stop blocking low.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 9:51am

Yes, could have handled that call differently.

Endocoug

9/28/22 10:02am

Not a fumble, and it wasn't a dead ball because refs didn't whistle it dead.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 10:42am

RE: Not a fumble, and it wasn't a dead ball because refs didn't whistle it dead.

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:10am

RE: Not a fumble, and it wasn't a dead ball because refs didn't whistle it dead.

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:11am

It's okay to admit your fellow refs made a bad no call.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 11:52am

RE: It's okay to admit your fellow refs made a bad no call.

Endocoug

9/28/22 12:01pm

board name absolutely checks out. Try laying off the endo and re-watching game

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 12:48pm

This statement shows one area where you are not familiar with the rules and

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:47pm

Fair enough, the ball hitting the turf after being batted made it a dead ball.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 2:14pm

An inadvertent whistle is one of the most embarrassing and humiliating mistakes

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 11:50pm

Blow it dead as soon as the ball hit the ground. There was never a question as

Corn Pop

9/28/22 10:48am

RE: Blow it dead as soon as the ball hit the ground. There was never a question

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:13am

You're arguing they were incompetent. Just sayin'.

Corn Pop

9/28/22 11:22am

No. I think you are just failing to comprehend!

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:39am

There were 3 refs all with a clear view. You're claiming they were all too

Corn Pop

9/28/22 11:47am

Your reply suggests you don’t have officiating experience and that

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:54am

LOL, your reply says you have no argument. Thanks!

Corn Pop

9/28/22 12:02pm

The R probably could not see where the ball landed because there were several

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:50pm

2:20:40 mark for the live play but the replay shows a better view.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 10:46am

No way no how is that a penalty!!!

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:18am

Agreed, Pay had a text book block.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 11:56am

I agree with you endo, That should not have been called.

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:52pm

The ref was watching it all the way. He was always going to call it

travelcoug

9/28/22 2:36pm

On #4 and #5

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 11:22am

It's over. At this point, I don't care about the officiating. BEAT Utah St.!

rockyrd

9/28/22 3:45pm

Nice video. Thanks for making it and sharing

Bee Chunder

9/28/22 3:47pm

On the ineligible down field. It was missed because of poor official mechanics

Powerbait DPM

9/28/22 5:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad