RE: Disagree. If you make someone jump aside or over you on an illegal block,

Report problem with this ad

Sep 28, 2022
10:14:41am

imdocrob Contributor

Thats crap!! There is no contact made so no illegal block has been thrown.

Report problem with this ad

imdocrob

Bio page: imdocrob
Joined: Jun 6, 2011
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 1,540 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU vs Wyoming Film Review - Bonus Officiating edition.

Zoobieman

9/28/22 7:36am

RE: BYU vs Wyoming Film Review - Bonus Officiating edition.

shoganai

9/28/22 7:45am

On a low block. I am guessing it shouldn’t be a penalty if you try to execute a

Trent

9/28/22 7:51am

Solid point!

Zoobieman

9/28/22 7:55am

“Intent to commit a penalty”?

Cougarclaw

9/28/22 7:55am

Right? I guess it’s like Intent to Deceive. We get the really rare penalties 😉

Trent

9/28/22 7:57am

Disagree. If you make someone jump aside or over you on an illegal block, they

RobAdams

9/28/22 8:23am

So you are saying by rule no contact is needed for a low block? Are you sure?

Trent

9/28/22 8:46am

I've got a better idea. Stop attempting illegal blocks and they won't get called

Corn Pop

9/28/22 8:51am

Fair. But I still want to know if a whiff attempted penalty is a penalty and I

Trent

9/28/22 9:00am

RE: Disagree. If you make someone jump aside or over you on an illegal block,

imdocrob

9/28/22 10:14am

So should defenses stop faking the blitz? It makes the offense jump.

travelcoug

9/28/22 2:35pm

I'm thinking all fakes of any kind should be intent to deceive penalties. 😉

Trent

9/28/22 3:31pm

How about quarterback draws and option please. They are all based on deception

travelcoug

9/28/22 3:38pm

We should probably just tell the other side what we plan on doing and just pit

Trent

9/28/22 3:47pm

RE: BYU vs Wyoming Film Review - Bonus Officiating edition.

Endocoug

9/28/22 7:58am

Was one of the refs your brother or something? To your points:

Corn Pop

9/28/22 8:32am

RE: Was one of the refs your brother or something? To your points:

Zoobieman

9/28/22 9:04am

I can understand what you were thinking, but if you're going to put a video out

Corn Pop

9/28/22 10:55am

I like you! You can definitely help me improve my videos.

Zoobieman

9/28/22 8:38am

It’s difficult to credibly critique the officiating

Endocoug

9/28/22 9:17am

You don’t need to be a ref to understand that the officiating was not up to par with the national standard

Rat

9/28/22 10:21am

That's true. Just like you don't need to be a police officer to know what bad

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 11:00am

There is a difference between "criticizing" and "critiquing".

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:32pm

This doesn't make sense, so I guess you can say if someone hasn't coached they

byublue42

9/28/22 11:03am

RE: This doesn't make sense, so I guess you can say if someone hasn't coached

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:43am

Nice, you obviously know so much about it that’s great

byublue42

9/28/22 11:00pm

oh good gosh, so that's what all these anxiety laden posts are about?

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 11:27am

Dude. Relax!

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:41am

yes, I'm the one who needs to relax, not the guy who posted 20 times in this

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 12:00pm

This is a garbage take. You can be a fan and criticize the officiating because all a fan needs to know are the rules.

TheLoneCougar

9/28/22 3:32pm

I would like to see the frame by frame on the false start.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 9:10am

RE: I would like to see the frame by frame on the false start.

Endocoug

9/28/22 9:27am

Also, it’s fair to criticize the no whistle on the incomplete pass

Endocoug

9/28/22 9:31am

I agree that the players need to adjust and stop blocking low.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 9:51am

Yes, could have handled that call differently.

Endocoug

9/28/22 10:02am

Not a fumble, and it wasn't a dead ball because refs didn't whistle it dead.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 10:42am

RE: Not a fumble, and it wasn't a dead ball because refs didn't whistle it dead.

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:10am

RE: Not a fumble, and it wasn't a dead ball because refs didn't whistle it dead.

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:11am

It's okay to admit your fellow refs made a bad no call.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 11:52am

RE: It's okay to admit your fellow refs made a bad no call.

Endocoug

9/28/22 12:01pm

board name absolutely checks out. Try laying off the endo and re-watching game

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 12:48pm

This statement shows one area where you are not familiar with the rules and

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:47pm

Fair enough, the ball hitting the turf after being batted made it a dead ball.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 2:14pm

An inadvertent whistle is one of the most embarrassing and humiliating mistakes

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 11:50pm

Blow it dead as soon as the ball hit the ground. There was never a question as

Corn Pop

9/28/22 10:48am

RE: Blow it dead as soon as the ball hit the ground. There was never a question

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:13am

You're arguing they were incompetent. Just sayin'.

Corn Pop

9/28/22 11:22am

No. I think you are just failing to comprehend!

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:39am

There were 3 refs all with a clear view. You're claiming they were all too

Corn Pop

9/28/22 11:47am

Your reply suggests you don’t have officiating experience and that

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:54am

LOL, your reply says you have no argument. Thanks!

Corn Pop

9/28/22 12:02pm

The R probably could not see where the ball landed because there were several

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:50pm

2:20:40 mark for the live play but the replay shows a better view.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 10:46am

No way no how is that a penalty!!!

Endocoug

9/28/22 11:18am

Agreed, Pay had a text book block.

hydrocoug

9/28/22 11:56am

I agree with you endo, That should not have been called.

DanSmith...BYU

9/28/22 1:52pm

The ref was watching it all the way. He was always going to call it

travelcoug

9/28/22 2:36pm

On #4 and #5

Digital Gangsta

9/28/22 11:22am

It's over. At this point, I don't care about the officiating. BEAT Utah St.!

rockyrd

9/28/22 3:45pm

Nice video. Thanks for making it and sharing

Bee Chunder

9/28/22 3:47pm

On the ineligible down field. It was missed because of poor official mechanics

Powerbait DPM

9/28/22 5:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad