to be passing judgement.
As a long time recruiting junkie, I would consider myself concerned at this point, but we have 6.5 months until early signing day.
Because of the changes to recruiting rules and transfer portal windows, HS kids are taking OV's earlier, and are committing earlier, currently 38% of all 4/5*'s on 247 are committed (167/431) that is significantly higher that previous years at around this same time.

Having said that, BYU hasn't had very many big whiffs yet this class, which I would define as prime targets that should be strong BYU leans, so far you probably only have the Gatlin Bair, Isaac Wilson & Luke Moga commit/snubs that sort of fit that definition but aren't total whiffs, and we are still in the running for most other top prime targets, so I am not ready to call this class a bust this early.

One encouraging note about this class, we are swinging for the fences on many more highly rated long shots... especially on the defensive side compared to the past, 80% of the offers are to .85 or higher rated recruits, if we can actually land some of those, it will be a much improved class from the recent past.