I got a thumbs down for this? Good grief...

Report problem with this ad

Aug 24, 2015
4:33:50pm

Kerbouchard

Report problem with this ad

Kerbouchard

Bio page: Kerbouchard
Joined: Feb 17, 2011
Last login: Aug 24, 2023
Total posts: 24,538 (19 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Approval Rating: Dave Rose

Art Director

8/24/15 3:28pm

The severe tank we saw from BYU's defense last year is very concerning.

SandYFan

8/24/15 3:31pm

I love Coach Rose, but I don't think we have great assistant coaches.

Zaius

8/24/15 3:33pm

If you're a BYU fan and honestly answered "Strongly Disapprove"

Indy Coug

8/24/15 3:34pm

I didn't answer Strongly Disapprove, but I do find it interesting how different

workindev

8/24/15 3:37pm

No, the results are not similar.

Gentleman Stan

8/24/15 4:05pm

How is the S16 = to a NY6 bowl?

ag4cougs

8/24/15 4:28pm

RE: How is the S16 = to a NY6 bowl?

Gentleman Stan

8/24/15 4:30pm

That is the most ridiculous compare ever - add 150 UNLVs in football

OC Coug

8/24/15 6:35pm

Do you really think that there are the same number of good teams in

Gentleman Stan

8/24/15 7:59pm

I disagree. There is a lot more parity in basketball than there is in Football.

workindev

8/24/15 6:25pm

Its not even close

OC Coug

8/24/15 6:36pm

You're not disagreeing with me then. That's what the facts demonstrate.

Gentleman Stan

8/24/15 8:04pm

Having one player stand out is an accomplishment as a coach?

southernfriedcougar

8/24/15 7:46pm

Is that so? You don't think Bronco having a Heisman winner would have made

Gentleman Stan

8/24/15 8:05pm

RE: Is that so? You don't think Bronco having a Heisman winner would have made

southernfriedcougar

8/24/15 11:07pm

Preach

ag4cougs

8/25/15 5:43am

This thread is about the approval of Dave Rose.

Gentleman Stan

8/25/15 9:38am

RE: This thread is about the approval of Dave Rose.

southernfriedcougar

8/25/15 5:28pm

First, Rose's peak is 2 years more recent than Bronco's. And Rose's

Gentleman Stan

8/25/15 5:54pm

You know EVERY YEAR Rose's team will choke and under perform. He is exactly

BYUtka

8/24/15 5:57pm

Dude, Worthington started for BYU last year. Just contemplate that for a minute

Big Daddy D

8/24/15 6:09pm

How many "Worthington" or worse players start in FB? If he was the best we have

BYUtka

8/24/15 6:21pm

I like Rose, but like others have stated, I find it odd he escapes the same

ag4cougs

8/24/15 6:41pm

I am not saying he isn't... I am saying that he is the same as Bronco and that I

BYUtka

8/24/15 7:34pm

preach

ag4cougs

8/24/15 6:35pm

Some perspective

wisconsincougs

8/25/15 9:41am

RE: I didn't answer Strongly Disapprove, but I do find it interesting how

southernfriedcougar

8/24/15 7:43pm

Now that's just ridiculous. Why risk damaging a perfectly good garage door???

LeftOfNormal

8/24/15 4:17pm

Seriously. Same even for "disapprove".

tony

8/24/15 5:44pm

Why all the Rose love and the hating on Bronco?

AzCoug1

8/24/15 3:38pm

Rose has one of the 10 highest winning percentages of all active coaches

Indy Coug

8/24/15 3:42pm

I have a patented hashtag that explains it all!

Goatnapper'96

8/24/15 3:44pm

Where does Bronco fall in this area ?

ManicBlue

8/24/15 3:45pm

He's only 13th amongst active coaches

Indy Coug

8/24/15 3:47pm

Wow ... horrible

ManicBlue

8/24/15 3:48pm

How's he doing vs Utah? That's what I thought...

Kerbouchard

8/24/15 3:53pm

<< Deleted >>

Art Director

8/24/15 4:01pm

How did Rose do against mighty Pepperdine last year? San Diego?

workindev

8/24/15 6:48pm

Have to be fair here. Rose has played Utah's worst teams in history and Bronco

The Dude Abides

8/24/15 7:39pm

Couldn't have said it better

southernfriedcougar

8/24/15 11:18pm

That being said, Bronco is terrible at rivalry games. BYU has been favored in

messi

8/25/15 10:05am

No doubt. Bronco has been awful in the rivalry. But it's just not fair to

The Dude Abides

8/25/15 4:40pm

That's true, but I think it is fair to say that Rose does a much better job at

messi

8/25/15 4:57pm

<< Deleted >>

gmj81

8/25/15 5:59pm

Terrible: He's only 26th.

Skipshot

8/24/15 3:47pm

Getting to the Sweet Sixteen is light years beyond what Bronco has

SandYFan

8/24/15 3:45pm

and football's post-season is setup completely differently too

ManicBlue

8/24/15 3:47pm

Easier to make a bowl than make it into the Round of 64.

SandYFan

8/24/15 3:49pm

maybe ...

ManicBlue

8/24/15 4:04pm

You only have to be 6-6 to go to a bowl. Some teams hoops teams don't make the

BearsandBulls

8/24/15 4:03pm

If that was so easy, wouldn't more teams be doing it every year ?

ManicBlue

8/24/15 4:14pm

There are 39 bowl games including the semi-finals and national championship game

BearsandBulls

8/24/15 4:42pm

One more time ...

ManicBlue

8/24/15 5:02pm

I think most P5 programs would have gone to bowl games as consistently as

BearsandBulls

8/24/15 5:16pm

I guess we'll just have to go with what you 'think' rather than any actual facts

ManicBlue

8/24/15 6:11pm

He provided several mathematical facts and you side-stepped them.

swingcat

8/24/15 6:18pm

If you'll note ...

ManicBlue

8/24/15 6:23pm

Actually Bronco has finished in the top 16 three times

PolarisPrime

8/24/15 4:01pm

There aren't a similar number of competitive teams in

Gentleman Stan

8/24/15 4:27pm

Some of what you say has merrit

PolarisPrime

8/24/15 5:52pm

Please explain how being one of the Top 12 teams

Gentleman Stan

8/24/15 8:09pm

Curious ..

ManicBlue

8/24/15 8:49pm

Those numbers aren't accurate.

PolarisPrime

8/25/15 12:17am

It depends on what you consider "resources." In any event, it's clear that

Gentleman Stan

8/25/15 9:16am

Thats why I said "similar" numbers

PolarisPrime

8/25/15 2:07pm

Umm... actually, BYU has finished top 16 three times under Bronco

wiscougarfan

8/24/15 4:09pm

Jimmer, Sweet 16, Utah, he's not weird, etc...

Walter Bellhaven

8/24/15 3:50pm

Because Rose is not owned by Yewtah, for starters.

Kerbouchard

8/24/15 3:52pm

the last two years beg to differ

gmj81

8/24/15 5:12pm

Rose has arguably faced easier Utah teams than Bronco.

southernfriedcougar

8/25/15 12:53am

Really?

Gerald-DeGroot

8/24/15 3:59pm

Approve. Strongly Approve is not warranted until NCAA tourney win % increases.

Kerbouchard

8/24/15 3:54pm

^^^ I approve this message ^^^

AzCoug1

8/24/15 4:04pm

I got a thumbs down for this? Good grief...

Kerbouchard

8/24/15 4:33pm

amen. I'm happy with both coaches but certainly each have weaknesses

gmj81

8/24/15 5:14pm

Needs some conference hardware, too.

ag4cougs

8/24/15 6:47pm

yep. His post season play doesn't warrant strongly approve.

southernfriedcougar

8/24/15 7:48pm

Arguably our best coach ever

SonsOfAlvin

8/24/15 8:38pm

come on

AzCoug1

8/24/15 9:28pm

Make an argument for anyone else.

SonsOfAlvin

8/25/15 12:54pm

Stan Watts

AzCoug1

8/25/15 2:00pm

Watts was also at BYU for much longer. 22 seasons I believe.

Gentleman Stan

8/25/15 2:39pm

Coaching Tree...

gmj81

8/25/15 6:00pm

2 D1 head coaches in 10 years is a solid coaching tree. Who has flamed out?

wisconsincougs

8/25/15 6:32pm

Rooese and Rice were the two that I was thinking of.

gmj81

8/25/15 7:01pm

I see where you're coming from. To answer the Rice question, he spent 6 yrs

wisconsincougs

8/25/15 7:13pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad