My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 29, 2015
5:09
:13
pm
Shimmy
Yeah. It was dumb. Riley may have been good to go, still dumb
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Shimmy
Previous username
AFCoug83
Bio page
Shimmy
Joined
Jan 15, 2008
Last login
May 14, 2024
Total posts
117,455 (37,065 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
The only player I've bashed in all my years on cougarboard is Riley Nelson
dixdog
8/29/15 12:18pm
RE: The only player I've bashed in all my years on cougarboard is Riley Nelson
Bravescoug
8/29/15 12:20pm
He told them. Coaches knew about it. They just blew it in identifying
Shimmy
8/29/15 12:24pm
RE: He told them. Coaches knew about it. They just blew it in identifying
Bravescoug
8/29/15 12:46pm
I've rarely seen a player so obviously drugged up to play -- he would have been
cougfromcali
8/29/15 7:45pm
If Riley was hurt and didn't tell coaches, then whose fault was it...?
BabyOx
8/29/15 12:50pm
Coaches knew the injury, and it is an injury you can play through. Bryce Petty
Shimmy
8/29/15 12:57pm
But in lead up to the first game he played w/ the injury he didn't practice
SpiffCoug
8/29/15 1:22pm
And it was Bronco overuling Doman. Doman wanted Lark.
byubyu
8/29/15 1:45pm
Do you think that does anything other than prove my point?
Shimmy
8/29/15 4:45pm
Right, but if Riley didn't practice in the lead up to the game, how could
SpiffCoug
8/29/15 4:49pm
If he didn't practice because of the pain, then he shouldn't play.
Shimmy
8/29/15 4:56pm
Which is what I think the case was. Riley didn't practice all week.
SpiffCoug
8/29/15 5:04pm
Yeah. It was dumb. Riley may have been good to go, still dumb
Shimmy
8/29/15 5:09pm
RE: If Riley was hurt and didn't tell coaches, then whose fault was it...?
Bravescoug
8/29/15 12:57pm
Riley was ineffective even when healthy. And you didn't answer my question.
BabyOx
8/29/15 1:24pm
What statistic can you point to that shows Nelson was ineffective when healthy?
CMuehle
8/29/15 1:30pm
Sr. Year he fumbled 9 times (9 times? 9 times...) threw as many Int's as TD's
BabyOx
8/29/15 1:39pm
I'll repeat, what statistic can you point to that shows Nelson was
CMuehle
8/29/15 1:47pm
A healthy Nelson gives BYU a great chance to win
byubyu
8/29/15 2:21pm
I agree with that.
CMuehle
8/29/15 2:35pm
He was healthy his sophomore year, and his QB efficiency rating was even lower
BabyOx
8/29/15 2:26pm
No, he wasn't healthy his sophomore year.
CMuehle
8/29/15 2:32pm
Can you show me a stat that shows he was effective? He was adequate at best,
BabyOx
8/29/15 2:35pm
Here's some stats.
CMuehle
8/29/15 2:40pm
Wow, 9-1 against powerhouses like Hawaii, Idaho, NMSU, Idaho State and SJSU. And
BabyOx
8/29/15 2:49pm
9-1 is 9-1.
CMuehle
8/29/15 3:04pm
I agree. Whose job is it to not play someone when they are ineffective?
Bravescoug
8/29/15 2:03pm
Bronco carried blame just like Riley, two clueless peas in a pod.
BabyOx
8/29/15 2:13pm
RE: Bronco carried blame just like Riley, two clueless peas in a pod.
Bravescoug
8/29/15 2:26pm
the coaches knew he was hurt
macaroni
8/29/15 2:23pm
When Riley was healthy, he was actually a good qb
idcougarfan
8/29/15 3:11pm
It's not his fault because others have done it too? Not following you.
Real Men Wear Blue
8/29/15 7:08pm
The bottom line is the coaches decide who plays.
Bravescoug
8/29/15 8:38pm
Was it really bashing ...or just stating the truth.
WJCougar
8/29/15 12:22pm
It was definitely bashing. I was part of it, and it went too far IMHO with the
Shimmy
8/29/15 12:24pm
I've bashed other players but I regret it. As long as they hustle, they don't
Shimmy
8/29/15 12:23pm
Welp, I've done my fair share of bashing. I will definitely work on tbat
Mathew
8/29/15 12:26pm
RE: Welp, I've done my fair share of bashing. I will definitely work on tbat
Shimmy
8/29/15 12:28pm
"as long as they hustle" Good to know I was okay to bash Chambers.
BabyOx
8/29/15 12:52pm
I'll disagree on a few different fronts - first, players all the time in many
BYUfan92
8/29/15 12:36pm
Yeah, Warner played most the year with a broken hand
Dr T-bone
8/29/15 12:40pm
A couple of things.
CMuehle
8/29/15 1:02pm
even if we presume riley "lied" to coaches RE his health that doesn't change
nashty
8/29/15 1:31pm
You're wrong. The coaches and team doctors knew 100 percent
byubyu
8/29/15 1:34pm
It wasn't Riley's job to take himself out; that's the coaches' job.
HawkCat
8/29/15 1:47pm
We've never had this discussion on here before
HendyCoug
8/29/15 1:52pm
ha ha. Yep. I should just delete my post. No new ground to discuss.
dixdog
8/29/15 1:58pm
Great idea! Glad you thought of it.
HawkCat
8/29/15 2:04pm
The whole Rileygate episode took a toll on TNT's committment to BYU football
TNT
8/29/15 2:18pm
He wasn't hiding that his back was broke
NorthBayCoug
8/29/15 2:30pm
The BYU D was to Riley what Taysom is to the BYU D now. It masked how truly bad
BabyOx
8/29/15 2:45pm
Heaps played against Ole Miss, not Riley. Try again.
HawkCat
8/29/15 2:50pm
I'm aware of that, the Ole Miss game was cited as an example of the D winning
BabyOx
8/29/15 3:05pm
Nice edit to throw Heaps name in there. Sure you did buddy. Sure you did.
HawkCat
8/29/15 3:11pm
Nonsense. What are trainers and coaches for?
HighHorse
8/29/15 3:59pm
Everyone knew Riley shouldn't have played the last three games that he did.
mantis mutu
8/29/15 4:11pm
It is not Riley's position to take himself out of the game. He thought he could
pappabear246
8/29/15 4:07pm
It's amazing you're dumb enough to think
shakarocks
8/29/15 4:43pm
They should've. But they didn't.
mantis mutu
8/29/15 4:48pm
Oh yes they did
shakarocks
8/29/15 4:52pm
You don't let guys play with a broken back vertebrae. No way do I believe this.
mantis mutu
8/29/15 4:56pm
Then you're as dumb as the original poster
shakarocks
8/29/15 5:05pm
Way to make it personal
Bgash
8/29/15 5:46pm
I personally hate it when people lie
shakarocks
8/29/15 5:57pm
I know for a fact the coaches knew. Which is why
byubyu
8/29/15 6:19pm
Yup
shakarocks
8/29/15 6:35pm
Signed, Tony Romo and the Dallas Cowboys. you can play with a broken back.
macaroni
8/29/15 6:57pm
Bryce Petty had the same injury last year. Played just fine.
Shimmy
8/30/15 10:29am
No, only Riley and every other fan knew it. He hid it from coaches, trainers and
pappabear246
8/29/15 5:03pm
Does CB really have to rehash this every other week?
Bgash
8/29/15 5:20pm
Yes
TNT
8/29/15 6:50pm
If TNT says so, then its fine w/ me. You may proceed.
Bgash
8/29/15 9:27pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
