Tanner has his faults. This throw was not one of them. It was fine and should have been a catch. The end.

Report problem with this ad

Sep 23, 2018
6:49:38pm

LiveCoug All-American

Report problem with this ad

LiveCoug

Bio page: LiveCoug
Joined: Aug 26, 2001
Last login: Jun 8, 2024
Total posts: 112,639 (11,688 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Incomplete passes for Tanner yesterday.

cougaman

9/23/18 6:05pm

This really only tells part of the story though

cougarmanguy

9/23/18 6:08pm

He had a lot of shorter passes yesterday, but many of them seem to be more by

cougaman

9/23/18 6:13pm

Great post!

Cnation

9/23/18 6:14pm

Once thing I would add on the positive side is that he avoids pressure well.

WizeGuise

9/23/18 6:27pm

Yes he does

cougarmanguy

9/23/18 6:30pm

He'll throw the ball away instead of trying to make a late throw into coverage

Y-Zag

9/23/18 6:33pm

kind of reminds me of Heaps, he never seems comfortable in the pocket and ...

icecougar

9/23/18 7:05pm

Agreed

cougaman

9/23/18 7:26pm

like the pass he threw away in the 4th Q of the Wisconsin game to avoid the sack

icecougar

9/23/18 7:14pm

This is the more accurate assessment - a lot of the sacks he's "avoiding" are

jaba166

9/24/18 2:40am

Very true, good post.

pilot17

9/24/18 5:26am

nice breakdown

franklyvulgar

9/23/18 6:14pm

I thought tanner had a very good day. Other players struggled.

Y-Zag

9/23/18 6:19pm

that pass to MLP at the goalline was not a good pass. He threw it way too close

Goliath

9/23/18 6:19pm

Broken up by the defender but should have been caught why? Tanner underthrew

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:27pm

Please stop. Every team in the country needs their WRs to come up with that

coug10278

9/23/18 6:30pm

Average receiver has a hard time coming down with a pass at defender gets a hand

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:32pm

He didn't get his hand on the ball, and I don't think that Romney really had

cougaman

9/23/18 6:35pm

If he keeps running at the same speed the pass lands behind him.

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:37pm

Have you watched the replay? He had to come back for it and defender hit is arm.

Cnation

9/23/18 6:37pm

Come back for it? He turns his body. Surprisingly, he doesn't keep full speed

cougaman

9/23/18 7:00pm

You must not watch a lot of football if you don’tthink that wasn’t underthrown.

Cnation

9/23/18 7:07pm

Your saying this to the guy who just rewatched and broke

GSwarriorcoug

9/23/18 7:33pm

Watching it live it looked well under thrown.

StalwartBraveTrue

9/23/18 7:23pm

Watching the replay, out doesn't look like Romney slows down at all until he

cougaman

9/23/18 7:32pm

The tv replay doesn’t show the route until the end.

StalwartBraveTrue

9/23/18 7:36pm

3 yards? No. Maybe half a yard. He did have the inside track and if the ball was

cougaman

9/23/18 7:56pm

Agree to disagree.

StalwartBraveTrue

9/23/18 8:47pm

I would love to see any evidence to show me otherwise.

cougaman

9/23/18 8:54pm

That’s just it. Had to be there. Only 53k were so we will let it rest.

StalwartBraveTrue

9/23/18 10:48pm

I'm sure your memory is 100 % perfect and you saw everything perfectly from

cougaman

9/23/18 11:01pm

Here's what I see on video. Tanner Mangum throws the ball and you can see to the

cougaman

9/23/18 11:12pm

I’m not throwing Tanner under the bus nor am I one of those fans.

StalwartBraveTrue

9/23/18 11:18pm

Like I said in my other thread, it was slightly behind. But 2-3 feet on a 45

cougaman

9/23/18 11:23pm

And are we sure their CB doesn't just have closing speed to make up some of that

cougaman

9/23/18 11:24pm

Exactly. Thanks for understanding. 👍🏻

StalwartBraveTrue

9/23/18 11:15pm

Just watched it. Very catchable. That’s not on Tanner

cajuncoug

9/23/18 8:21pm

Offensive player had both hands on the ball for enough time to secure the ball.

cougaman

9/23/18 6:32pm

It was more than a touch. Romney had to slow down to adjust to the ball

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:34pm

This is a really good point. If it's not a perfect pass, then the WR shouldn't be expected to come up with it.

SpiffCoug

9/23/18 6:35pm

As long as you realize the pass was underthown I'm fine.

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:38pm

Several yesterday referred to it as “perfect” catchable yes but not easy catch

Osteotome

9/23/18 7:09pm

Especially if you are on scholarship- just make a play

acougfan

9/23/18 11:57pm

It was a fine throw. That's a long ball. He should have caught it.

LiveCoug

9/23/18 6:37pm

Why?

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:38pm

Because he got two hands on it

webster242

9/23/18 6:44pm

Defender knocked it with his hand. All bets are off at that point.

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:46pm

Maybe you should focus more on the play of the defender then instead of fishing

coug10278

9/23/18 6:51pm

I've watched it about a dozen times. I don't see a WR slowing down for an

cougaman

9/23/18 6:38pm

He turns, and gives the defender a clue the ball is coming. He keeps running and

cougaman

9/23/18 6:40pm

He slows down and he still has to turn around to catch it. If he keeps his speed

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:46pm

Tanner has his faults. This throw was not one of them. It was fine and should have been a catch. The end.

LiveCoug

9/23/18 6:49pm

Stating your opinion over and over isn't very convincing.

SandYFan

9/23/18 6:56pm

Saying he had to come back for the pass is completely void of truth

coug10278

9/23/18 7:01pm

You can see what you want.

SandYFan

9/23/18 7:04pm

Yeah what actually happened. Any speed he lost is because he turned & jumped

coug10278

9/23/18 7:13pm

SO HE SLOWED DOWN AND STILL HAD TO TURN TO CATCH THE BALL.

SandYFan

9/23/18 7:33pm

Oh totally changed my mind because of the all CAPS

coug10278

9/23/18 8:14pm

Way to ignore the substance. I'll take that as you saying you're wrong.

SandYFan

9/23/18 8:41pm

What substance...the CAPS...bravo.

coug10278

9/23/18 8:52pm

You're 100% correct, Romney had 2/3 steps on the db and had to slow because the

blackshirts

9/23/18 10:22pm

Holy unreal expectations.

cougaman

9/23/18 10:26pm

Finally saw the Romney pass. Yeah, that definitely should have been caught

LiveCoug

9/23/18 6:33pm

Anyone else notice that after every game this year the company line is:

Gerald-DeGroot

9/23/18 6:47pm

To be fair it makes me think of posters not to be named

coug10278

9/23/18 6:54pm

Anyone notice that every time anything goes wrong with the offense people are

cougaman

9/23/18 6:55pm

His WR’s aren’t helping him out. That’s for sure.

Gerald-DeGroot

9/23/18 7:02pm

it could be his Heisman slogan

icecougar

9/23/18 7:18pm

Spot on Gerald! Because if he really “wasn't that bad,” we’d be something like

dreamlvr

9/23/18 7:19pm

Wut?

Gerald-DeGroot

9/23/18 9:11pm

Really good post! Mangum played well.

joesemenoff

9/23/18 7:03pm

I thought 1 was well under thrown and 6 was PI

StalwartBraveTrue

9/23/18 7:10pm

This is CB...where anything goes. Now it was well underthrown.

coug10278

9/23/18 7:15pm

4.6 ypa against a fcs team.

youngbuck

9/23/18 7:18pm

Is That Tanners fault or a Grimes?

cougaman

9/23/18 7:29pm

How did it compare to last year? You tell me?

youngbuck

9/23/18 8:34pm

Yeah. That would have been much worse than losing the game

cougaman

9/23/18 8:53pm

TM fault, he doesn't go through progressions...he check #1 panics and dumps

blackshirts

9/23/18 10:32pm

I think you think you sound smart saying this, but I doubt you can actually see

dreamlvr

9/23/18 11:17pm

Romney's dropped pass would have changed it. So is it a receiver problem?

Y-Zag

9/23/18 7:55pm

Tanner threw a mediocre ball that allowed the defender to get a hand on it.

SandYFan

9/23/18 8:42pm

Now you're trolling.

coug10278

9/23/18 8:53pm

The Romney pass was underthrown about 5'. Should have ben caught. Receiver wai

oldrugger

9/23/18 8:03pm

5 feet on a 50 yard pass is an underthrow? First, I don't even think it was 5

Posting on CougarBoard