He means in terms of a all-time great. Honestly, without Steve Young's NFL

Apr 21, 2021
4:50:15pm

SinkingQuffa 3rd String

success, he probably wouldn't make the BYU greats list either. Only started two seasons for us. And if Sark had gone another year he might be on it.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Apr 21, 2021 at 4:50:15pm

Message modified by SinkingQuffa on Apr 21, 2021 at 4:51:04pm

Report problem with this ad

SinkingQuffa

Previous username: 5thNephi
Bio page: SinkingQuffa
Joined: Apr 29, 2020
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 33,237 (46 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Hey look, the BYU QB Mt Rushmore

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 12:47pm

So who did Zach replace on Rushmore?

The Dark Knight

4/21/21 12:50pm

Max Hall

supertux

4/21/21 12:51pm

Zach can't replace Max. Max is is the winningest QB in BYU history. They'll need

BlooCoog

4/21/21 3:02pm

Bosco

Florwood

4/21/21 12:52pm

No one. We got a bigger mountain

travelcoug

4/21/21 12:52pm

Well, there is a guy with 2 super bowl rings that isn't in there

NOCAL_YFAN

4/21/21 12:53pm

Yep, as far as BYU career, Zach is not the Best Wilson QB

tarmstrong

4/21/21 1:11pm

I see your point, but should NFL success be a factor in the BYU career?

OldFogey

4/21/21 2:54pm

Wow. That's beautiful.

goodcleanfun

4/21/21 12:57pm

Jim’s shorts - LOL

rivercitycoug

4/21/21 12:59pm

I was thinking — Geesh, he's gettin tame with age!

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 1:30pm

Thats amazing. Great picture.

Backcountry

4/21/21 12:59pm

RE: Hey look, the BYU QB Mt Rushmore

Icecat

4/21/21 1:20pm

Umm, yeah. Bosco still up there.

zerome4sooners

4/21/21 1:43pm

Where are their masks? TIC

AF_Puma

4/21/21 2:18pm

Love this pic!

BlooCoog

4/21/21 3:01pm

Wow

'92Coug

4/21/21 3:25pm

Nope. Not yet. The jury is still out in regard to Zach Wilson.

Wingnut

4/21/21 3:46pm

No it's not, his time at BYU is over he is on the BYU Mt rushmore.

IceCreamButt

4/21/21 3:49pm

I concur, and I don't often concur on Wednesdays

OldFogey

4/21/21 4:28pm

Wrong. With as many BYU records as he broke, he deserves to be up there regardless of what he does in the NFL.

Rise Against

4/21/21 3:50pm

Seriously, how many BYU records did he break? He did have a good year

Wingnut

4/21/21 3:54pm

Take the blinders off, man. Seriously.

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 3:55pm

It was a sincere question. How many BYU records did he really break? I'll give him props he had a great year.

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:00pm

Single season passing efficiency, career passing efficiency, single season

arizonacougarfan

4/21/21 4:26pm

Those seem pretty relevant

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 4:27pm

Obviously, being a top-3 NFL Draft pick as a QB the jury was still out on his QB play while at BYU.

Turnpike Lane

4/21/21 4:00pm

The NFL scouts just can't see what Wingnut sees.

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:11pm

Completion percentage for one. Broke Steve Young's almost 40 year old record.

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:02pm

What's going on RA? Are you moving the goalposts on me?

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:06pm

Moving goal posts? No. I deleted that because I posted it in the wrong spot. I reposted it word for word.

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:08pm

Completion % and TD/INT ratio absolutely need to be era and opponent adjusted

krindorr

4/21/21 5:23pm

<< Deleted >>

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:02pm

Yeah that was pretty good for one season. Now let's go through all the records that Jim McMahon and Ty Detmer broke

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:03pm

That was pretty cool of you to delete your post and then do an eye roll

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:05pm

Why would we go over the records they broke? They are already on mt. rushmore.

IceCreamButt

4/21/21 4:24pm

I respect your opinion and I can disagree

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:29pm

Super Bowl Champs and a Heisman winner

AF Cougar

4/21/21 5:16pm

I forgot, he’s not a Bronco Mendenhall product, so he sucks.

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 3:53pm

Why are you changing the subject. You're better than that.

Wingnut

4/21/21 3:55pm

I’m making fun of you and your gosh awful take.

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 3:57pm

So you were going to say something about my take but instead you made a mistake and brought up Bronco Mendenhall?

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:01pm

How could the jury be out? His BYU career is over.

Jeffacka

4/21/21 4:07pm

I want to see some more from him. We only got to see one really good year and I don't want to put him with those other

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:09pm

If NFL production matters, then why is Ty Detmer on here? Get out of here. Zach is a Top 5 all-time BYU QB

molodyets

4/21/21 4:16pm

I'm as confused as anyone.

Jeffacka

4/21/21 4:16pm

Zach Wilson had one good year at BYU. I want to see what he does in the NFL.

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:20pm

How Zach does in the NFL is irrelevant to this discussion. He's a BYU great. Jimmer did not succeed in the NBA, yet he

Cru Jones

4/21/21 5:08pm

I respect your opinion and I can disagree

Wingnut

4/21/21 5:32pm

RE: Nope. Not yet. The jury is still out in regard to Zach Wilson.

JohnnyComeLately

4/21/21 4:25pm

He means in terms of a all-time great. Honestly, without Steve Young's NFL

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 4:50pm

Nah. Robbie, Marc, Gifford, Max all deserve to be on BYU's Mt. Rushmore B.Z.

(Private)

4/21/21 3:56pm

If you're going by games played, by all means take Steve Young off too. Right???

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 4:35pm

Nah. Steve had great wins. Great career and finished strong 2d in Heisman.

(Private)

4/21/21 5:03pm

How would Steve's best BYU win honestly have compared to Zach's win over USC?

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 5:20pm

It's a testament to BYU's history that I don't think Zach makes QB Rushmore

krindorr

4/21/21 4:36pm

"against 3rd rate competition" Lolololololololol if you call his victories against 3rd rate teams but give McMahon and

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:43pm

We also need to stop ignoring era for stats

krindorr

4/21/21 5:19pm

^This^

Oceanographer

4/21/21 6:18pm

Beating Utah should be a requirement for being on the Mt. Rushmore.

lilpenny

4/21/21 5:38pm

Not all that realistic. Also, the 80s version of Utah sucked. Utah is irrelevant

Backcountry

4/21/21 5:55pm

Zach did beat the yewts. Too many others got in the way of the final score.

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 6:58pm

Elephant in the room...Ty needs a more supportive bra

chochera

4/21/21 6:10pm

Wow, Steve Young looks noticeably older and thinner than I pictured him.

BleedCougarBlue2

4/21/21 9:05pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad