So you were going to say something about my take but instead you made a mistake and brought up Bronco Mendenhall?

Report problem with this ad

Apr 21, 2021
4:01:30pm

Wingnut Equal Opportunity Jack-Yewt

Report problem with this ad

Wingnut

Previous username: AFwingnut
Bio page: Wingnut
Joined: Aug 14, 2010
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 46,355 (29,125 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Hey look, the BYU QB Mt Rushmore

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 12:47pm

So who did Zach replace on Rushmore?

The Dark Knight

4/21/21 12:50pm

Max Hall

supertux

4/21/21 12:51pm

Zach can't replace Max. Max is is the winningest QB in BYU history. They'll need

BlooCoog

4/21/21 3:02pm

Bosco

Florwood

4/21/21 12:52pm

No one. We got a bigger mountain

travelcoug

4/21/21 12:52pm

Well, there is a guy with 2 super bowl rings that isn't in there

NOCAL_YFAN

4/21/21 12:53pm

Yep, as far as BYU career, Zach is not the Best Wilson QB

tarmstrong

4/21/21 1:11pm

I see your point, but should NFL success be a factor in the BYU career?

OldFogey

4/21/21 2:54pm

Wow. That's beautiful.

goodcleanfun

4/21/21 12:57pm

Jim’s shorts - LOL

rivercitycoug

4/21/21 12:59pm

I was thinking — Geesh, he's gettin tame with age!

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 1:30pm

Thats amazing. Great picture.

Backcountry

4/21/21 12:59pm

RE: Hey look, the BYU QB Mt Rushmore

Icecat

4/21/21 1:20pm

Umm, yeah. Bosco still up there.

zerome4sooners

4/21/21 1:43pm

Where are their masks? TIC

AF_Puma

4/21/21 2:18pm

Love this pic!

BlooCoog

4/21/21 3:01pm

Wow

'92Coug

4/21/21 3:25pm

Nope. Not yet. The jury is still out in regard to Zach Wilson.

Wingnut

4/21/21 3:46pm

No it's not, his time at BYU is over he is on the BYU Mt rushmore.

IceCreamButt

4/21/21 3:49pm

I concur, and I don't often concur on Wednesdays

OldFogey

4/21/21 4:28pm

Wrong. With as many BYU records as he broke, he deserves to be up there regardless of what he does in the NFL.

Rise Against

4/21/21 3:50pm

Seriously, how many BYU records did he break? He did have a good year

Wingnut

4/21/21 3:54pm

Take the blinders off, man. Seriously.

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 3:55pm

It was a sincere question. How many BYU records did he really break? I'll give him props he had a great year.

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:00pm

Single season passing efficiency, career passing efficiency, single season

arizonacougarfan

4/21/21 4:26pm

Those seem pretty relevant

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 4:27pm

Obviously, being a top-3 NFL Draft pick as a QB the jury was still out on his QB play while at BYU.

Turnpike Lane

4/21/21 4:00pm

The NFL scouts just can't see what Wingnut sees.

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:11pm

Completion percentage for one. Broke Steve Young's almost 40 year old record.

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:02pm

What's going on RA? Are you moving the goalposts on me?

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:06pm

Moving goal posts? No. I deleted that because I posted it in the wrong spot. I reposted it word for word.

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:08pm

Completion % and TD/INT ratio absolutely need to be era and opponent adjusted

krindorr

4/21/21 5:23pm

<< Deleted >>

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:02pm

Yeah that was pretty good for one season. Now let's go through all the records that Jim McMahon and Ty Detmer broke

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:03pm

That was pretty cool of you to delete your post and then do an eye roll

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:05pm

Why would we go over the records they broke? They are already on mt. rushmore.

IceCreamButt

4/21/21 4:24pm

I respect your opinion and I can disagree

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:29pm

Super Bowl Champs and a Heisman winner

AF Cougar

4/21/21 5:16pm

I forgot, he’s not a Bronco Mendenhall product, so he sucks.

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 3:53pm

Why are you changing the subject. You're better than that.

Wingnut

4/21/21 3:55pm

I’m making fun of you and your gosh awful take.

LaVellIfIKnow

4/21/21 3:57pm

So you were going to say something about my take but instead you made a mistake and brought up Bronco Mendenhall?

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:01pm

How could the jury be out? His BYU career is over.

Jeffacka

4/21/21 4:07pm

I want to see some more from him. We only got to see one really good year and I don't want to put him with those other

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:09pm

If NFL production matters, then why is Ty Detmer on here? Get out of here. Zach is a Top 5 all-time BYU QB

molodyets

4/21/21 4:16pm

I'm as confused as anyone.

Jeffacka

4/21/21 4:16pm

Zach Wilson had one good year at BYU. I want to see what he does in the NFL.

Wingnut

4/21/21 4:20pm

How Zach does in the NFL is irrelevant to this discussion. He's a BYU great. Jimmer did not succeed in the NBA, yet he

Cru Jones

4/21/21 5:08pm

I respect your opinion and I can disagree

Wingnut

4/21/21 5:32pm

RE: Nope. Not yet. The jury is still out in regard to Zach Wilson.

JohnnyComeLately

4/21/21 4:25pm

He means in terms of a all-time great. Honestly, without Steve Young's NFL

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 4:50pm

Nah. Robbie, Marc, Gifford, Max all deserve to be on BYU's Mt. Rushmore B.Z.

(Private)

4/21/21 3:56pm

If you're going by games played, by all means take Steve Young off too. Right???

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 4:35pm

Nah. Steve had great wins. Great career and finished strong 2d in Heisman.

(Private)

4/21/21 5:03pm

How would Steve's best BYU win honestly have compared to Zach's win over USC?

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 5:20pm

It's a testament to BYU's history that I don't think Zach makes QB Rushmore

krindorr

4/21/21 4:36pm

"against 3rd rate competition" Lolololololololol if you call his victories against 3rd rate teams but give McMahon and

Rise Against

4/21/21 4:43pm

We also need to stop ignoring era for stats

krindorr

4/21/21 5:19pm

^This^

Oceanographer

4/21/21 6:18pm

Beating Utah should be a requirement for being on the Mt. Rushmore.

lilpenny

4/21/21 5:38pm

Not all that realistic. Also, the 80s version of Utah sucked. Utah is irrelevant

Backcountry

4/21/21 5:55pm

Zach did beat the yewts. Too many others got in the way of the final score.

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 6:58pm

Elephant in the room...Ty needs a more supportive bra

chochera

4/21/21 6:10pm

Wow, Steve Young looks noticeably older and thinner than I pictured him.

BleedCougarBlue2

4/21/21 9:05pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad