My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Mar 14, 2013
1:35
:42
pm
touchdownbyu
the real question is why do they always use a car and two goats in this question
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
touchdownbyu
Previous username
kyro
Bio page
touchdownbyu
Joined
Aug 20, 2009
Last login
Jun 2, 2024
Total posts
4,489 (373 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
The Monty "Max" Hall problem - Anyone else take issue with it besides the Utes?
MightyFreakingCougar
3/14/13 12:44pm
Ugh I hate this thing. I firmly believe it doesn't matter if you swap or not.
SandYFan
3/14/13 12:47pm
but if you actually simulate it yourself hundreds of times
COUGALICIOUS
3/14/13 12:50pm
but the odds end up being exactly the same
Belboz
3/14/13 12:55pm
No, you choose one and there's a 2/3 chance it is behind 2 OR 3
gustav88
3/14/13 1:00pm
and then there are 2 remaining doors.
Belboz
3/14/13 1:02pm
No because the information revealed to you depends on which door you pick
cheezedawg
3/14/13 1:38pm
I agree that the additional information negates the original odds.
61_Shasta
3/14/13 1:05pm
The fallacy is thinking new info was revealed. It was not.
dilbert
3/14/13 1:20pm
Perhaps new information has not been revealed but the game has still changed
61_Shasta
3/14/13 1:42pm
I don't know why we are debating this, but new information is revealed
cheezedawg
3/14/13 1:44pm
Whether that's what you believe or not
The Shazad
3/14/13 2:13pm
No, it is not intuitive, but I don't take issue with it because it is right.
workindev
3/14/13 12:50pm
I don't understand how this relates to Max Hall
chodakus
3/14/13 12:50pm
We've been through it enough already.
Belboz
3/14/13 12:51pm
I must have missed those elusive conversations. Science has this one wrong!
MightyFreakingCougar
3/14/13 1:05pm
You should always change -- now a 2/3 chance of other door
gustav88
3/14/13 12:53pm
Who is that in your Sig, cause that's awesome
RaggaeCoug
3/14/13 12:58pm
Marshall Henderson. Yeah, he's awesome.
Belboz
3/14/13 1:03pm
Wait is that Marsha from Utah?
RaggaeCoug
3/14/13 1:05pm
yes.
Belboz
3/14/13 1:07pm
Always change, it is the right choice
mpfunk
3/14/13 12:59pm
Linked explanation
gustav88
3/14/13 1:01pm
It took reading that to convince me.
Tricky
3/14/13 2:50pm
Yeah, thanks for that btw. Really helped. Funny all the crap she got.
MightyFreakingCougar
3/14/13 4:12pm
the real question is why do they always use a car and two goats in this question
touchdownbyu
3/14/13 1:35pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
