My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
May 20, 2015
4:20
:46
pm
Bleeding Blue
Ty - Part of it was being the right guy at the right time but still- DOMINATED!
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Bleeding Blue
Bio page
Bleeding Blue
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Last login
May 22, 2024
Total posts
12,324 (694 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Who is the best player in Cougar history, regardless of position?
PapaBill
5/20/15 10:19am
Steve Young
brj8
5/20/15 10:21am
Rob Morris is up there too, along with Jason Buck & Luke Staley.
Japan Coug
5/20/15 10:21am
And none of those guys are happy with the program
LonePeakCoug
5/21/15 1:18am
You have to cater to your stars
capo
5/29/15 1:49pm
Luke
stonecougar
5/20/15 10:22am
Jim McMahon - never saw anyone pick apart a defense like that.
Cosmo's Kid
5/20/15 10:24am
You should change your boardname to PapaCollie
Hank Rearden
5/20/15 10:29am
No love for the best pass catcher in school history, eh?
PapaBill
5/20/15 10:34am
Saying someone is top 15 should be an enourmous compliment
Hank Rearden
5/20/15 10:39am
I wouldn't count his time with Tom Brady...6 receptions with the Pats.
PharmD
5/20/15 10:47am
Good point
Hank Rearden
5/20/15 5:38pm
Jamal Willis should be high on the list
BYUBandfan
5/20/15 10:30am
Shane Hunter
ToasterChive
5/20/15 10:36am
Ty
Anae4Anae
5/20/15 10:40am
Ty only one with a Heisman on his shelf and to beat a #1 team.
Jacob
5/20/15 10:52am
Ty is only one, and tell me this is not true, down to his last game
CROSBYU
5/20/15 12:36pm
Not true, at least as far as his last game (1991 Holiday Bowl) was concerned
BeardedSpock
5/20/15 12:56pm
And so you proved my point, He had them in the game until the very end
CROSBYU
5/20/15 1:03pm
And so you proved my point, He had them in the game until the very end
CROSBYU
5/20/15 1:07pm
Yep I had his Indiana Jones Heisman Poster hanging on my wall for years!
Cougz19
5/20/15 1:36pm
If Healthy--Luuuuke Staley
lbmango
5/20/15 10:36pm
Taysom Hill: Can play QB, RB, Saftety, Punter, Kicker, Returner
boiseman92
5/20/15 10:50am
^^ is 15 years old and hasnt seen much BYU football.
BlueFrog
5/20/15 10:58am
au contraire: Notice the "regardless of position" wording in the op.
boiseman92
5/20/15 11:03am
I do not think that phrase means what you think it means.
Tricky
5/20/15 12:27pm
Based on other responses, I guess you're right....oops
boiseman92
5/21/15 6:56am
Who is Bluefrog.
bushy7
5/20/15 11:37am
He is supposed to be Turkish. Some say his father was German.
BlueFrog
5/20/15 1:36pm
RE: Who is the best player in Cougar history, regardless of position?
Marl kalone
5/20/15 11:18am
Well how can you argue; Harline is still open. And has been for years
HasRo24
5/20/15 11:51am
I think it depends on your definition of "best player"
mogelijk
5/20/15 12:03pm
How about this definition?
Tricky
5/20/15 12:32pm
Steve Young without a doubt
shakarocks
5/20/15 12:05pm
Matt Payne
wiscougarfan
5/20/15 12:09pm
Mike Hague played for 8 years. He must be the best player in history.
MajorZeus
5/20/15 12:19pm
No love for Luuuuuukkke Staley? Only RB to win the Doak Walker award at BYU and
Yunit
5/20/15 12:20pm
Luke had a great Junior season.
autonomous
5/20/15 1:12pm
I'm not considering his career just him as a player during his peak
Yunit
5/20/15 2:42pm
Exciting yes, but not the best ever.
autonomous
5/20/15 3:09pm
Exciting and best ever. This is my opinion. What is yours? You haven't stated
Yunit
5/20/15 4:42pm
Absolutely no hate. That's just a silly comment.
autonomous
5/20/15 7:26pm
Not silly. Luke is a legit best ever contender.
skardem
5/20/15 11:00pm
Not silly thinking Luke was great. Silly for saying I'm hating on Luke.
autonomous
5/20/15 11:25pm
RE: Cougar history, not NFL, has to be Ty. Steve Young on porntial and realizati
Cricker
5/20/15 12:32pm
Luke and Ty - are superior to the others
HarlemCoug
5/20/15 12:42pm
While he is not number 1, I don't see any other mention of KVN here
gww687
5/20/15 1:00pm
I am rather young but my top three are: Staley, Collie, and Harline.
Mr. Accountant
5/20/15 1:22pm
Staley, he is #1, this is irrefutable. Nobody can make any other argument.
Jericho
5/20/15 1:23pm
Luke Staley
reddead
5/20/15 1:23pm
RE: Who is the best player in Cougar history, regardless of position?
Bullrider
5/20/15 1:49pm
My top 5 ranking regardless of position
deckard667
5/20/15 1:51pm
It's Jimmy Mac. He "walks on water" on CB because he's the Greatest of All Time
pistol12
5/20/15 1:56pm
For the record, Staley is 2nd on my list.
PapaBill
5/20/15 2:00pm
Best athlete may be Ziggy. Best BYU career TY. Best player
Coogar2
5/20/15 2:36pm
Fun Question but is often answered differently with each generation's hearts
Cougarpride
5/20/15 2:37pm
Much like AC above, I love KVN but He wasnt even a top 3 LBer at BYU
Hank Rearden
5/20/15 3:07pm
I'd take KVN over any of the LBs you mentioned
jsjohnson1278
5/20/15 7:02pm
And I'd take Kurt Gouveia over any mentioned. I loved KVN
Hank Rearden
5/20/15 9:21pm
come on Steve Young
gstodd
5/20/15 3:02pm
Ty was incredible as was McMahon, hard for me to choose between the two
kimdaddy35
5/20/15 3:05pm
You must be relatively young.
2ndTrombone
5/20/15 3:42pm
Ute's opinion: Ty, McMahon, Staley, then Ziggy - No one else even comes close.
sheriffcreg
5/20/15 3:51pm
Ty - Part of it was being the right guy at the right time but still- DOMINATED!
Bleeding Blue
5/20/15 4:20pm
Kyle Morrell - hear me out
WallyWorld
5/20/15 4:28pm
So, he wins for "best play" in BYU history (in your book) Not the best player
volleyjiver
5/20/15 5:24pm
I was mainly kidding - just threw a name out for arguments sake
WallyWorld
5/20/15 5:38pm
regardless, how many All America DBs has BYU had?
Belboz
5/20/15 7:16pm
the question is "best player" not "best play"
RupertPupkin
5/20/15 9:31pm
Best player while at BYU - McMahon no question. Best nfl -
BlueTooth
5/20/15 5:02pm
Did your spell check change Heisman to Helaman? Impressive..
Anae4Anae
5/20/15 5:23pm
RE: Did your spell check change Heisman to Helaman? Impressive..
BlueTooth
5/20/15 9:06pm
Definitely Jim McMahon
boiseman92
5/21/15 6:57am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
