But they don't ask the general population for a review of their ruling either.

Oct 17, 2017
2:03:29pm

jdub Unofficial CB Pollyanna

Sure, the people can vote them out, but that analogy is getting really bad, isn't it?
https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=18663734

Report problem with this ad

jdub

Bio page: jdub
Joined: May 13, 2004
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 76,560 (17,184 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Feature Request: Give those who receive penalties the option to make their

Epileptic Beagle

10/17/17 12:41pm

And give them an option to have their name appear on a list of those

garyfan

10/17/17 12:43pm

RE: Feature Request: Give those who receive penalties the option to make their

Referee

10/17/17 12:43pm

new subscriber group: court room audience

BlueFrog

10/17/17 12:44pm

Or at least have foof do courtroom sketches.

benny1982

10/17/17 12:45pm

RE: Feature Request: Give those who receive penalties the option to make their

cougfanblue

10/17/17 12:45pm

TNT doesn't like this attitude. Reported!

TNT

10/17/17 12:47pm

I'd love to see this appeal thread!

BYUtka

10/17/17 1:18pm

I'd stop working toward not getting suspended immediately.

Belboz

10/17/17 12:51pm

Might have to add context, especially early on (if it becomes a thing)

Referee

10/17/17 12:55pm

Peeping? Is the referee a Tom?

TNT

10/17/17 12:57pm

I support that. It works both ways. People can see successful/unsuccessful

Epileptic Beagle

10/17/17 1:00pm

I'm good with that.

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 1:01pm

Well, look who’s suddenly all about fairness and context...

garyfan

10/17/17 1:20pm

I would be totally in favor of that.

Belboz

10/17/17 2:50pm

If your GenPop post sucked, why do you think we'll like seeing you whine about it?

jdub

10/17/17 1:00pm

Does not compute. All of my genpop posts are amazing

Epileptic Beagle

10/17/17 1:03pm

RE: Does not compute. All of my genpop posts are amazing

jdub

10/17/17 1:06pm

I support this 100%

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 1:00pm

Why this is a good idea:

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 1:05pm

This sounds an awfully lot like the appeal function, complete with moderators, super mods, and El Jefe.

cougfanblue

10/17/17 1:44pm

minus the accountability

garyfan

10/17/17 1:55pm

this isn't a Democracy, or even a Democratic Republic

jdub

10/17/17 2:01pm

All I’m saying is that it’s not the same as an appeals thread because the

garyfan

10/17/17 2:16pm

We're quite aware of that.

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 2:38pm

Huh, to read your post suggesting it should operate like a Democracy would lead one to believe you weren't aware.

jdub

10/17/17 2:47pm

The judges don't hand pick the judges who review them.

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 1:57pm

#NOTMYMODS

benny1982

10/17/17 2:01pm

But they don't ask the general population for a review of their ruling either.

jdub

10/17/17 2:03pm

So the internet message board you post on isn't an exact replica of the United States Judicial System - you're correct.

cougfanblue

10/17/17 2:06pm

Who appointed those "separate judges"?

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 2:37pm

Jefe did. Didn't you just say you were aware this wasn't a democracy?

jdub

10/17/17 2:48pm

Quite. I've never argued for a democracy here. Just fairness.

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 3:26pm

We're just talking, SoCal. Not defensive.

cougfanblue

10/17/17 2:49pm

I don't need your drama

Indy Coug

10/17/17 1:05pm

I'm sure you could turn off the feature.

SoCalCoug

10/17/17 1:06pm

You only think that cause you haven’t seen my drama

Epileptic Beagle

10/17/17 1:19pm

Is that some kind of perverse proposition?

Indy Coug

10/17/17 1:21pm

Just make it known which way each mod voter for your appeal

kotacoug

10/17/17 2:13pm

I like this, mods should be transparent in their voting

JOPE

10/17/17 4:49pm

Oh please no! Having a down football year is bad enough. I wouldn't want to

RebelScum

10/18/17 12:35am

Why not simply act like a decent human being when posting and you will have nothing to appeal.

Rhino84

10/18/17 9:48am

That's not always true.

thebruce

10/18/17 9:55am

I used to think this. Then it happened to me. The salt in the wound: a few days later the Stake Sunday School Pres said,

Smack'sWife

10/18/17 8:46pm

I've had things flagged a time or two for words that were not he best choices and I have no problem with them being

Posting on CougarBoard