You are comparing apples to crocodiles here.

Huntley is in a different offense and faced a different defense. QB head to head comparisons rarely work for that very reason. If you play a second game and have the two QB's swap places, then you may be able to make an argument. But a simple head to head rarely works.

On the other hand - if you want to compare season stats, great! And comparing season stats, I'm guessing Huntley comes out ahead.