There is peer review and then there is Wikipedia. The former is performed by

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 18, 2018
11:50:35am

UNHuskerCoug Redshirt Freshman

There is peer review and then there is Wikipedia. The former is performed by

learned women and men who have a clue. The latter is performed by any swingin' Rick.

Report problem with this ad

UNHuskerCoug

Previous username: UNHuskerCoug311
Bio page: UNHuskerCoug
Joined: Feb 10, 2018
Last login: Dec 7, 2019
Total posts: 1,704 (14 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

So I think some yewt edited the wikipedia page on the Holy War

Zoobieman

6/17/18 4:58pm

What's wrong with that?

Wingnut

6/17/18 5:01pm

Should be BYU-Utah to be consistent with BYU-Hawaii and BYU-Idaho

Dread Pirate Westley

6/17/18 5:07pm

Seriously.

Bert609

6/17/18 6:01pm

I never considered that before. Makes sense. I guess I could get used to that

bluelands

6/17/18 8:30pm

but there's also a BYU-SL center

warp

6/18/18 11:52am

Isn't that a part of BYU-Utah?

Dread Pirate Westley

6/18/18 11:55am

I'm guessing you are a troll?

Zoobieman

6/17/18 5:08pm

I think I was able to undo all of the changes. Let me know if you see any more.

Ute in DC

6/17/18 5:09pm

Can anyone really just go in and make changes?

CougarWildcat

6/17/18 6:03pm

That's what Wikipedia is.

Zman

6/17/18 6:16pm

That's why professors hate Wikipedia and will penalize any student

eddog

6/17/18 6:31pm

That is probably why they are professors and not in a high paying profession

6/17/18 7:54pm

When Wikipedia lists sources it can be a really good cheat

Cashmeousside

6/17/18 8:03pm

That's what I frequently did when I was in school.

eddog

6/17/18 8:14pm

Academia can be very out of touch at a time.

TheWanderer

6/17/18 8:08pm

I agree. I love wikipedia.

eddog

6/17/18 8:18pm

Thanks for the knock on my career. I will absolutely penalize any student

TailgateU

6/18/18 8:52am

How or other publications more "verified"?

CosmoK

6/18/18 1:57pm

I'm not just worried about verifiability. For my class, students can use company

TailgateU

6/18/18 3:37pm

Are you serious? So let's have our professors allow information that is not peer

UNHuskerCoug

6/18/18 9:31am

Isn't the entire Wikipedia model, excessive peer review?

Juncker

6/18/18 10:24am

Academic peer review is an organized process. Wikipedia is not.

TailgateU

6/18/18 11:47am

There is peer review and then there is Wikipedia. The former is performed by

UNHuskerCoug

6/18/18 11:50am

And yet, if you went through most Wikipedia articles you'd find just as few

Juncker

6/18/18 12:39pm

Not all of us are anti

6/17/18 8:54pm

which is exactly why I'd go to wikipedia, use the information in it and then

powerbait

6/18/18 8:54am

Wrong. That's not why.

yakkamole

6/18/18 12:03pm

Yes, it's low hanging fruit. But then again, there's nothing new under the sun.

Juncker

6/18/18 12:43pm

College assignments, yes, actual research, no.

yakkamole

6/18/18 1:52pm

Fair enough. Scientific fields would be the exception here. That's a valid point

Juncker

6/18/18 6:24pm

If nothing new is found, then we waste a lot of money doing research around the

TailgateU

6/19/18 7:10am

Michael Scott said it best.

davidmj10

6/17/18 9:43pm

I doubt it was a UTah fan the would have changed it from BYU to TDS

kolt7

6/17/18 9:53pm

It's kind of ironic that fans of a school with more opening than demand are

vagabonder

6/17/18 5:12pm

oh yes. that is very ironic.

BlueFrog

6/17/18 5:17pm

There is Utah-Ogden, Utah-Logan, and Utah-Orem, though.

CosmoK

6/18/18 1:58pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad