My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jan 20, 2019
6:22
:12
pm
AD4
All-American
The question is: how does a ref miss that call? That’s the issue.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
AD4
Previous username
AndyDwyer
Bio page
AD4
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Last login
Mar 16, 2020
Total posts
48,674 (28,060 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
In regards to the missed call in the Saints game. What are you guys wanting to
777
1/20/19 6:17pm
Taysom could have used that $200k bonus. Goodell needs to make Tayson whole.
WDaddy
1/20/19 6:18pm
Flag for PI. Next question please.
All-American
1/20/19 6:18pm
How? They missed it. Do you want to stop every play and review?
777
1/20/19 6:19pm
The question is: how does a ref miss that call? That’s the issue.
AD4
1/20/19 6:22pm
I get it. Human error. How did that ball go under Buckners legs, how did
777
1/20/19 6:24pm
Human error is one thing. That was egregious.
AD4
1/20/19 6:31pm
And there was more than one "human" involved. If not call the PI, why not the helmet to helmet either? They
CLCougar
1/20/19 6:58pm
They shouldn’t have missed it. Next question.
All-American
1/20/19 6:27pm
You’re not answering his question. Once the call has been missed, what do you
Costanza
1/20/19 6:29pm
That’s what is wrong with his question. Shouldn’t have come to that.
All-American
1/20/19 6:37pm
But it did. Refs are going to miss calls, even obvious ones. So how should the
Costanza
1/20/19 7:21pm
Not make obvious errors.
All-American
1/20/19 7:34pm
Fine. Don’t answer the question. Just be obtuse.
Costanza
1/20/19 7:37pm
The question is what should they do. The answer is call the penalty.
All-American
1/20/19 7:52pm
Not every play, but there is already an official reviewing replay.
WhiteKnight
1/20/19 6:42pm
It's not too much to ask for those type of calls to be made.
byubyu
1/20/19 6:19pm
In reality nothing can be done. You can't go to replay for every missed call.
mudpupper
1/20/19 6:21pm
why not? Why not allow the review official to decide if there is a need for a review. This play it was clear contact
ChinaFan
1/20/19 6:26pm
A review ref could find holding on about every single down.
mudpupper
1/20/19 6:29pm
So true. And offensive and defensive PI.
777
1/20/19 6:31pm
I think they would be able to manage their holding calls like on field refs do, but there
ChinaFan
1/20/19 6:31pm
Add a challenge flag or two for calls.
Adrielle
1/20/19 6:21pm
Let it be challenged. If it stands the challenging team loses a TO.
Albuq_Coug
1/20/19 6:21pm
Oops, what Adrielle said.
Albuq_Coug
1/20/19 6:22pm
Make the right call. It was an obvious call. Make it.
LifeLongLakerFan
1/20/19 6:22pm
In my opinion, the same officials that review plays should be watching, and if a 'missed' or "no call" happens, they
ChinaFan
1/20/19 6:22pm
In this game one “call” or non-call DID in fact decide the game
RockyBalboa
1/20/19 6:27pm
Every call decided that game. If a call goes against you in the first quarter it
777
1/20/19 6:30pm
But the context matters. You can't pretend all calls affect the game the same.
WhiteKnight
1/20/19 6:48pm
Explain. They all matter. I don't understand this logic. It's just the last
777
1/20/19 7:00pm
It has been explained, and you’re right that you don’t understand it
RockyBalboa
1/20/19 7:17pm
It has not. Explain. How does a end game missed call impact more than
777
1/20/19 7:32pm
Because you have fewer chances following a blown call at the end if the game than at the start. It's pretty simple.
SpiffCoug
1/20/19 9:02pm
Didn't the Saints win the OT coin flip and throw an INT? Seems like
777
1/20/19 10:04pm
Right. They had a chance. Singular. Not chances, like they would have had the call been in the 1st qtr.
SpiffCoug
1/20/19 10:06pm
This is how to troll people. Well done.
RockyBalboa
1/20/19 9:19pm
Maybe we are talking about two different things. What I'm saying is that all
777
1/20/19 10:00pm
Either you're obtuse or trolling. Either way God Bless you.
RockyBalboa
1/21/19 8:32am
No, you are just being condescending. I don't think you know the
777
1/21/19 2:13pm
Ok, so it's just obtuse then, not trolling. Got it.
RockyBalboa
1/21/19 2:41pm
You win my friend.
777
1/21/19 3:24pm
Same reason why failure on the first exam is different from failure on the final
WhiteKnight
1/21/19 5:48am
But coaches look at the game as 60 minutes, so if you haven't separated yourself
777
1/21/19 2:21pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
