I think they would be able to manage their holding calls like on field refs do, but there

Jan 20, 2019
6:31:33pm

ChinaFan All-American

are calls that need to be made. And this is one that clearly a challenge rule should allow for. Everyone in the stadium could see it.

Report problem with this ad

ChinaFan

Bio page: ChinaFan
Joined: Oct 29, 2003
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 17,246 (276 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

In regards to the missed call in the Saints game. What are you guys wanting to

777

1/20/19 6:17pm

Taysom could have used that $200k bonus. Goodell needs to make Tayson whole.

WDaddy

1/20/19 6:18pm

Flag for PI. Next question please.

All-American

1/20/19 6:18pm

How? They missed it. Do you want to stop every play and review?

777

1/20/19 6:19pm

The question is: how does a ref miss that call? That’s the issue.

AD4

1/20/19 6:22pm

I get it. Human error. How did that ball go under Buckners legs, how did

777

1/20/19 6:24pm

Human error is one thing. That was egregious.

AD4

1/20/19 6:31pm

And there was more than one "human" involved. If not call the PI, why not the helmet to helmet either? They

CLCougar

1/20/19 6:58pm

They shouldn’t have missed it. Next question.

All-American

1/20/19 6:27pm

You’re not answering his question. Once the call has been missed, what do you

Costanza

1/20/19 6:29pm

That’s what is wrong with his question. Shouldn’t have come to that.

All-American

1/20/19 6:37pm

But it did. Refs are going to miss calls, even obvious ones. So how should the

Costanza

1/20/19 7:21pm

Not make obvious errors.

All-American

1/20/19 7:34pm

Fine. Don’t answer the question. Just be obtuse.

Costanza

1/20/19 7:37pm

The question is what should they do. The answer is call the penalty.

All-American

1/20/19 7:52pm

Not every play, but there is already an official reviewing replay.

WhiteKnight

1/20/19 6:42pm

It's not too much to ask for those type of calls to be made.

byubyu

1/20/19 6:19pm

In reality nothing can be done. You can't go to replay for every missed call.

mudpupper

1/20/19 6:21pm

why not? Why not allow the review official to decide if there is a need for a review. This play it was clear contact

ChinaFan

1/20/19 6:26pm

A review ref could find holding on about every single down.

mudpupper

1/20/19 6:29pm

So true. And offensive and defensive PI.

777

1/20/19 6:31pm

I think they would be able to manage their holding calls like on field refs do, but there

ChinaFan

1/20/19 6:31pm

Add a challenge flag or two for calls.

Adrielle

1/20/19 6:21pm

Let it be challenged. If it stands the challenging team loses a TO.

Albuq_Coug

1/20/19 6:21pm

Oops, what Adrielle said.

Albuq_Coug

1/20/19 6:22pm

Make the right call. It was an obvious call. Make it.

LifeLongLakerFan

1/20/19 6:22pm

In my opinion, the same officials that review plays should be watching, and if a 'missed' or "no call" happens, they

ChinaFan

1/20/19 6:22pm

In this game one “call” or non-call DID in fact decide the game

RockyBalboa

1/20/19 6:27pm

Every call decided that game. If a call goes against you in the first quarter it

777

1/20/19 6:30pm

But the context matters. You can't pretend all calls affect the game the same.

WhiteKnight

1/20/19 6:48pm

Explain. They all matter. I don't understand this logic. It's just the last

777

1/20/19 7:00pm

It has been explained, and you’re right that you don’t understand it

RockyBalboa

1/20/19 7:17pm

It has not. Explain. How does a end game missed call impact more than

777

1/20/19 7:32pm

Because you have fewer chances following a blown call at the end if the game than at the start. It's pretty simple.

SpiffCoug

1/20/19 9:02pm

Didn't the Saints win the OT coin flip and throw an INT? Seems like

777

1/20/19 10:04pm

Right. They had a chance. Singular. Not chances, like they would have had the call been in the 1st qtr.

SpiffCoug

1/20/19 10:06pm

This is how to troll people. Well done.

RockyBalboa

1/20/19 9:19pm

Maybe we are talking about two different things. What I'm saying is that all

777

1/20/19 10:00pm

Either you're obtuse or trolling. Either way God Bless you.

RockyBalboa

1/21/19 8:32am

No, you are just being condescending. I don't think you know the

777

1/21/19 2:13pm

Ok, so it's just obtuse then, not trolling. Got it.

RockyBalboa

1/21/19 2:41pm

You win my friend.

777

1/21/19 3:24pm

Same reason why failure on the first exam is different from failure on the final

WhiteKnight

1/21/19 5:48am

But coaches look at the game as 60 minutes, so if you haven't separated yourself

Posting on CougarBoard