Then you have a very strange way of arguing a point/responding to a post

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 6, 2019
12:10:20pm

Goliath All-American

Then you have a very strange way of arguing a point/responding to a post

Report problem with this ad

Goliath

Previous username: Koolio
Bio page: Goliath
Joined: May 25, 2005
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 30,504 (1,775 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

D-Day gets all the attention but don't forget:

CougieMcCougFace

6/6/19 9:57am

As a former member of 8th Air Force, I'll add that Airmen in that org

Goliath

6/6/19 10:06am

The marines have always been a smaller organization.

CougieMcCougFace

6/6/19 10:17am

They were not smaller than Eighth Air Force. They were larger, and had about

Goliath

6/6/19 10:36am

Yes the Marines have a smaller force. But the PERCENTAGE of deaths. Look at

JmThms

6/6/19 10:24am

7% of Airmen in 8th Air Force were killed. I think 3% of Marines were killed in

Goliath

6/6/19 10:29am

This is an absurd comparison.

CougieMcCougFace

6/6/19 11:09am

Please explain what's "absurd" about it. So far all you've shown is ignorance

Goliath

6/6/19 11:16am

I went out of my way to acknowledge important things occured tht I didnt mention

CougieMcCougFace

6/6/19 11:40am

Read my first post. Nowhere did it say the Marines role was unimportant. In

Goliath

6/6/19 11:46am

I never said you did. You made the numbers comparison.

CougieMcCougFace

6/6/19 12:05pm

Then you have a very strange way of arguing a point/responding to a post

Goliath

6/6/19 12:10pm

Statistics varied with different commands. The 1st Marine Division lost nearly

JmThms

6/6/19 11:31am

Many bomber groups suffered greater than 50% mortality rates as well.

Goliath

6/6/19 11:49am

Yes my point exactly.

JmThms

6/6/19 1:20pm

Goliath is right on this, the 8th Air Force had higher mortality rates than the Marines

2FarGone

6/6/19 12:05pm

Depends on what units! This is not real hard. That's like saying the BYU Cougars

JmThms

6/6/19 1:35pm

OK, let me be clear: the US 8th AF suffered more losses than the entire US Marine Corps

2FarGone

6/6/19 1:45pm

Marine Corps be a relatively small group of men. Few but proud.

JmThms

6/6/19 1:56pm

8th AF was an even smaller group of men.

Goliath

6/6/19 3:20pm

1st Marine Division my friend. You are indeed making this WAY more difficult

JmThms

6/6/19 3:27pm

??? So the 1st Marine Div had more deaths than the entire Air Force?

Goliath

6/6/19 3:37pm

And if you respond to 2Fargone's point by saying

Goliath

6/6/19 3:49pm

The total casualty amount including wounded is about equal

CougieMcCougFace

6/6/19 2:47pm

You're conflating issues and making this harder than you need to

Goliath

6/6/19 3:16pm

I already posted stats on the 1st Marine Division. There is apples to apples and

JmThms

6/6/19 3:19pm

Not at all. Show me a unit of comparable

Goliath

6/6/19 3:43pm

There are so many battles that helped determine the war's outcome. In the Pacific- Midway was the sea

thaws

6/6/19 10:10am

Five days later US marines landed at Saipan - the invasion force was equal sized

Taullis

6/6/19 10:22am

My grandfather was a replacement officer with the South Saskatchewan Regiment.

CanuckUte

6/6/19 10:39am

Your grandfather was probably excited to get out of Saskatchewan in sept

kotacoug

6/6/19 11:00am

He was from Edmonton but yes the point stands haha. His final letter written the

CanuckUte

6/6/19 11:13am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad