This is kind of a stupid discussion (& that's okay). There's not a single BYU

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Aug 16, 2019
4:40:28pm

rcbyufan All-American

This is kind of a stupid discussion (& that's okay). There's not a single BYU

fan, coach, or player that would trade Wilson for Huntley. NOBODY would make that trade. Not in a billion years. I think it's reasonable to state that Huntley would start at Utah over Wilson. Huntley WOULD NOT START at BYU. Not a chance.

Moving on to receivers, neither team has anything to brag about. Maybe you'd take every single Utah receiver but let's not act like that means anything.

TE's Bushman would be useless at Utah because they need their TE to be a great blocker. But Bushman receiving is awesome.

Oline-this is a tough one but it's mostly a wash. Both teams have some MAJOR questions at the new spots.

Report problem with this ad

rcbyufan

Bio page: rcbyufan
Joined: Aug 18, 2010
Last login: Apr 30, 2024
Total posts: 31,675 (1,086 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Which BYU players would be starting for Utah?

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:05pm

Wilson as a true freshman had better ratings than Huntley as a junior,

8/16/19 4:06pm

I doubt Wilson would be starting this season for them. He's good but experience

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:08pm

What has Huntley done to cement himself as the starter?

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:12pm

SEE: October 2018

Et Lux in Domino

8/16/19 6:18pm

I can see how beating up on bad teams that couldn't even get bowl eligible would be very impressive.

slatecoug

8/19/19 11:59pm

Of course you would, it's why you guys love Wilson so much.

8/20/19 7:26am

yes because it is so easy to go 18 for 18 in any game

slatecoug

8/20/19 1:52pm

Against the #111 team in ESPN defensive efficiency?

8/20/19 2:05pm

The only reason I'm not certain Wilson would be the "unquestioned starter" next year is

Et Lux in Domino

8/17/19 12:09am

Idk if Wilson would start, but he’ll prove he’s clearly the better QB this year

Odysseus

8/16/19 4:11pm

Here's what I'd guess

8/16/19 4:12pm

Taking experience over talent is something I've never really believed in,

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:15pm

I like SR Huntley more than SO Wilson.

8/16/19 4:16pm

Yeah. I guess we'll see how they each perform this season.

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:17pm

I understand that thinking prior to the start of the season...

icecougar

8/16/19 6:16pm

I agree with that for the most part. Tonga would start on your DL though.

The Dude Abides

8/16/19 4:19pm

No he wouldn't. Penisini and Fotu are both NFL draft picks.

8/16/19 4:20pm

Tonga is too. Not sure how high though

Backcountry

8/16/19 4:21pm

I like Tonga, I think he's a very good DL.

8/16/19 4:25pm

Thats fair

Backcountry

8/16/19 4:28pm

Tonga will be leaving early to the NFL. He’s at least the same level talent as Penisini and Fotu.

The Dude Abides

8/16/19 4:28pm

He might be. That puts him #3 at Utah.

8/16/19 4:48pm

Based on what other than bias? If they were flipped you'd still choose your own

8/16/19 5:53pm

Tonga would start. He may not be better than Fotu, but he is better than Penisini.

8/16/19 8:30pm

Starting is for high school

lilpenny

8/16/19 5:10pm

Don’t be surprised to see Tonga at DE in some passing situations vs Utah...

icecougar

8/16/19 6:19pm

I assumed Dayan at safety, should have said that before.

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:20pm

I think Utah's OL is more talented than BYU's except for Empey.

8/16/19 4:22pm

I don’t —

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:30pm

This is going to embarrassing if you guys lose. Choke job of epic proportions.

rcbyufan

8/16/19 4:31pm

It will be embarassing. Utah should be the better team, we're favored by 5.

8/16/19 4:50pm

This is almost as bad of a take as the guy who said "Utah puts WRs in the NFL"

8/16/19 6:01pm

Because Wilson and Bushman have the potential to be the two biggest stars in the

puntersarepeople

8/17/19 7:37am

Hoge would start at Utah. No doubt.

LifeLongLakerFan

8/17/19 7:57am

Are you just saying that since Emory was a Ute before his mission? Hoge would be

Cosmo4life

8/17/19 12:00pm

What do you think the score would be?

CMuehle

8/16/19 4:32pm

Well except Whitt likes to slow the game down and just do barely enough

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:33pm

It's the Utah-BYU game, so I'll say 24-15. It's going to be close, it always is.

8/16/19 4:51pm

That's close? That's a bigger margin than most of the recent rivalry games.

Benfica1

8/16/19 5:44pm

I'm surprised you think Utah will only score 15. No faith in Ludwig, huh?

LiveCoug

8/16/19 5:55pm

I think you underestimate how good guys like Hoge and Brady Christensen are.

8/16/19 8:37pm

And how much better they might be

puntersarepeople

8/16/19 11:30pm

Bushman. Maybe an O-lineman. 2 max.

Backcountry

8/16/19 4:15pm

Glad to see the Utah fan that tries to act like he is a BYU fan has chimed in.

8/16/19 8:40pm

Hey Bengal. Thanks for your contribution to this thread.

Backcountry

8/16/19 8:51pm

Just doing my part.

8/16/19 8:55pm

This thread seems to have exposed a lot of those.

Nuke

8/16/19 10:59pm

This is kind of a stupid discussion (& that's okay). There's not a single BYU

rcbyufan

8/16/19 4:40pm

BYU actually has far fewer question marks at open spots than Utah does.

8/16/19 9:33pm

You were doing really well until the OL part

slatecoug

8/16/19 11:33pm

What's wrong with the line part? Just curious. I'm not too knowledgeable about

rcbyufan

8/17/19 9:20am

LG is an interesting one

puntersarepeople

8/17/19 9:42am

Both guys were good enough to get starts last year.

slatecoug

8/18/19 2:37am

However you look at it, BYU returns 4, not 3, and RT isn't as big of a

8/17/19 9:49am

I hope you're right.

rcbyufan

8/17/19 10:09am

People focus way too much on the individual players on the OL.

slatecoug

8/18/19 2:36am

What have uu receivers done that you think it isn't close. Covey, yes....

Benfica1

8/16/19 4:42pm

From what Ive heard, their kickers are struggling at 35 yards, so 2 of our kickers could start there.

cowbellcoug

8/16/19 5:34pm

All of them

8/16/19 5:58pm

Utah has a freshman RB who would be the clear #1 at BYU

CallingDingo

8/16/19 6:23pm

I’d be good with that

I'mBatman

8/16/19 7:13pm

He didn't flip really did he?

ReggaeCoug

8/16/19 10:04pm

They didn’t move away from him. Graham Harrell went hard after him after he was

Scratch

8/16/19 10:13pm

BYU landed a four star from USC too

puntersarepeople

8/16/19 11:32pm

I suspect you could have done a similar exercise with Utah and USC

lilpenny

8/16/19 7:32pm

This. Individual players can be huge but playing as a cohesive

CougarTales

8/17/19 1:26am

Scheme is also involved

puntersarepeople

8/17/19 7:39am

Only those that run a sub 4.3 forty. So none.

Bostonblue

8/16/19 9:50pm

None. Offers aren't commitable.

Phred84044

8/17/19 8:26am

How many of Utah’s players would have even made it in to BYU or been willing to live by the HC? I don’t think their

Nuke

8/17/19 10:26am

Now you're just trolling. Covey, Dixon, Enis, Simpkins, Thompson, Nacua, Perriman, and Vickers are clearly better than

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 5:47pm

PS. I'm pretty sure Elders Hansen and Covey would have had no problem getting in, or obeying the HC. And they're both

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 5:56pm

Romney will be better than most, possibly all of those

puntersarepeople

8/18/19 7:58pm

Cool.

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 8:46pm

Okay . . .

puntersarepeople

8/18/19 9:23pm

Uh, sure. Whatever.

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 10:27pm

Ok. You were the one that accused someone of trolling when they weren’t

puntersarepeople

8/18/19 10:50pm

Romney wasn't the best HS receiver in Arizona his SR year.

8/19/19 10:46am

I never explicitly said all

puntersarepeople

8/19/19 12:20pm

So if both groups of receivers live up to the hype, Romney would be

8/19/19 12:22pm

“Even close to the hype”

puntersarepeople

8/19/19 12:29pm

Enis was overrated in high school according to the Arizona evaluators, they were overruled by the national guys

slatecoug

8/20/19 12:03am

They were also "overruled" by college coaches. Here are the P5 offers for both

Scratch

8/20/19 10:37am

Jake Heaps had more P5 offers than Enis. Is that what we should use as the ultimate litmus test?

slatecoug

8/20/19 1:55pm

LOL, we were talking about "potential" and "hype," and then

Scratch

8/20/19 2:02pm

No message

Scratch

8/20/19 2:01pm

The evaluators on the ground thought Romney was better but were overruled by the national guys

slatecoug

8/20/19 12:01am

RE: The evaluators on the ground thought Romney was better but were overruled by

8/20/19 10:39am

Jake Heaps had more P5 offers than Enis. Is that what we should use as the ultimate litmus test?

slatecoug

8/20/19 1:55pm

RE: Jake Heaps had more P5 offers than Enis. Is that what we should use as the

8/20/19 2:06pm

This is the thread that won’t die

8/19/19 12:32pm

ITs been days now, why do people still reply?

MikeDitka'sStache

8/19/19 12:36pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad