This thread seems to have exposed a lot of those.

Report problem with this ad

Aug 16, 2019
10:59:24pm

Nuke Starter

Report problem with this ad

Nuke

Previous username: Bleedblue84
Bio page: Nuke
Joined: Aug 9, 2017
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 9,554 (218 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Which BYU players would be starting for Utah?

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:05pm

Wilson as a true freshman had better ratings than Huntley as a junior,

Rise Against

8/16/19 4:06pm

I doubt Wilson would be starting this season for them. He's good but experience

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:08pm

What has Huntley done to cement himself as the starter?

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:12pm

SEE: October 2018

Et Lux in Domino

8/16/19 6:18pm

I can see how beating up on bad teams that couldn't even get bowl eligible would be very impressive.

slatecoug

8/19/19 11:59pm

Of course you would, it's why you guys love Wilson so much.

displacedute

8/20/19 7:26am

yes because it is so easy to go 18 for 18 in any game

slatecoug

8/20/19 1:52pm

Against the #111 team in ESPN defensive efficiency?

displacedute

8/20/19 2:05pm

The only reason I'm not certain Wilson would be the "unquestioned starter" next year is

Et Lux in Domino

8/17/19 12:09am

Idk if Wilson would start, but he’ll prove he’s clearly the better QB this year

Odysseus

8/16/19 4:11pm

Here's what I'd guess

displacedute

8/16/19 4:12pm

Taking experience over talent is something I've never really believed in,

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:15pm

I like SR Huntley more than SO Wilson.

displacedute

8/16/19 4:16pm

Yeah. I guess we'll see how they each perform this season.

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:17pm

I understand that thinking prior to the start of the season...

icecougar

8/16/19 6:16pm

I agree with that for the most part. Tonga would start on your DL though.

The Dude Abides

8/16/19 4:19pm

No he wouldn't. Penisini and Fotu are both NFL draft picks.

displacedute

8/16/19 4:20pm

Tonga is too. Not sure how high though

Backcountry

8/16/19 4:21pm

I like Tonga, I think he's a very good DL.

displacedute

8/16/19 4:25pm

Thats fair

Backcountry

8/16/19 4:28pm

Tonga will be leaving early to the NFL. He’s at least the same level talent as Penisini and Fotu.

The Dude Abides

8/16/19 4:28pm

He might be. That puts him #3 at Utah.

displacedute

8/16/19 4:48pm

Based on what other than bias? If they were flipped you'd still choose your own

Lip Gallagher

8/16/19 5:53pm

Tonga would start. He may not be better than Fotu, but he is better than Penisini.

BengalCougar

8/16/19 8:30pm

Starting is for high school

lilpenny

8/16/19 5:10pm

Don’t be surprised to see Tonga at DE in some passing situations vs Utah...

icecougar

8/16/19 6:19pm

I assumed Dayan at safety, should have said that before.

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:20pm

I think Utah's OL is more talented than BYU's except for Empey.

displacedute

8/16/19 4:22pm

I don’t —

MikeDitka'sStache

8/16/19 4:30pm

This is going to embarrassing if you guys lose. Choke job of epic proportions.

rcbyufan

8/16/19 4:31pm

It will be embarassing. Utah should be the better team, we're favored by 5.

displacedute

8/16/19 4:50pm

This is almost as bad of a take as the guy who said "Utah puts WRs in the NFL"

Lip Gallagher

8/16/19 6:01pm

Because Wilson and Bushman have the potential to be the two biggest stars in the

puntersarepeople

8/17/19 7:37am

Hoge would start at Utah. No doubt.

LifeLongLakerFan

8/17/19 7:57am

Are you just saying that since Emory was a Ute before his mission? Hoge would be

Cosmo4life

8/17/19 12:00pm

What do you think the score would be?

CMuehle

8/16/19 4:32pm

Well except Whitt likes to slow the game down and just do barely enough

SandYFan

8/16/19 4:33pm

It's the Utah-BYU game, so I'll say 24-15. It's going to be close, it always is.

displacedute

8/16/19 4:51pm

That's close? That's a bigger margin than most of the recent rivalry games.

Benfica1

8/16/19 5:44pm

I'm surprised you think Utah will only score 15. No faith in Ludwig, huh?

LiveCoug

8/16/19 5:55pm

I think you underestimate how good guys like Hoge and Brady Christensen are.

BengalCougar

8/16/19 8:37pm

And how much better they might be

puntersarepeople

8/16/19 11:30pm

Bushman. Maybe an O-lineman. 2 max.

Backcountry

8/16/19 4:15pm

Glad to see the Utah fan that tries to act like he is a BYU fan has chimed in.

BengalCougar

8/16/19 8:40pm

Hey Bengal. Thanks for your contribution to this thread.

Backcountry

8/16/19 8:51pm

Just doing my part.

BengalCougar

8/16/19 8:55pm

This thread seems to have exposed a lot of those.

Nuke

8/16/19 10:59pm

This is kind of a stupid discussion (& that's okay). There's not a single BYU

rcbyufan

8/16/19 4:40pm

BYU actually has far fewer question marks at open spots than Utah does.

Lip Gallagher

8/16/19 9:33pm

You were doing really well until the OL part

slatecoug

8/16/19 11:33pm

What's wrong with the line part? Just curious. I'm not too knowledgeable about

rcbyufan

8/17/19 9:20am

LG is an interesting one

puntersarepeople

8/17/19 9:42am

Both guys were good enough to get starts last year.

slatecoug

8/18/19 2:37am

However you look at it, BYU returns 4, not 3, and RT isn't as big of a

Lip Gallagher

8/17/19 9:49am

I hope you're right.

rcbyufan

8/17/19 10:09am

People focus way too much on the individual players on the OL.

slatecoug

8/18/19 2:36am

What have uu receivers done that you think it isn't close. Covey, yes....

Benfica1

8/16/19 4:42pm

From what Ive heard, their kickers are struggling at 35 yards, so 2 of our kickers could start there.

cowbellcoug

8/16/19 5:34pm

All of them

YIsForBrigham

8/16/19 5:58pm

Utah has a freshman RB who would be the clear #1 at BYU

CallingDingo

8/16/19 6:23pm

I’d be good with that

I'mBatman

8/16/19 7:13pm

He didn't flip really did he?

ReggaeCoug

8/16/19 10:04pm

They didn’t move away from him. Graham Harrell went hard after him after he was

Scratch

8/16/19 10:13pm

BYU landed a four star from USC too

puntersarepeople

8/16/19 11:32pm

I suspect you could have done a similar exercise with Utah and USC

lilpenny

8/16/19 7:32pm

This. Individual players can be huge but playing as a cohesive

CougarTales

8/17/19 1:26am

Scheme is also involved

puntersarepeople

8/17/19 7:39am

Only those that run a sub 4.3 forty. So none.

Bostonblue

8/16/19 9:50pm

None. Offers aren't commitable.

Phred84044

8/17/19 8:26am

How many of Utah’s players would have even made it in to BYU or been willing to live by the HC? I don’t think their

Nuke

8/17/19 10:26am

Now you're just trolling. Covey, Dixon, Enis, Simpkins, Thompson, Nacua, Perriman, and Vickers are clearly better than

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 5:47pm

PS. I'm pretty sure Elders Hansen and Covey would have had no problem getting in, or obeying the HC. And they're both

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 5:56pm

Romney will be better than most, possibly all of those

puntersarepeople

8/18/19 7:58pm

Cool.

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 8:46pm

Okay . . .

puntersarepeople

8/18/19 9:23pm

Uh, sure. Whatever.

Et Lux in Domino

8/18/19 10:27pm

Ok. You were the one that accused someone of trolling when they weren’t

puntersarepeople

8/18/19 10:50pm

Romney wasn't the best HS receiver in Arizona his SR year.

displacedute

8/19/19 10:46am

I never explicitly said all

puntersarepeople

8/19/19 12:20pm

So if both groups of receivers live up to the hype, Romney would be

displacedute

8/19/19 12:22pm

“Even close to the hype”

puntersarepeople

8/19/19 12:29pm

Enis was overrated in high school according to the Arizona evaluators, they were overruled by the national guys

slatecoug

8/20/19 12:03am

They were also "overruled" by college coaches. Here are the P5 offers for both

Scratch

8/20/19 10:37am

Jake Heaps had more P5 offers than Enis. Is that what we should use as the ultimate litmus test?

slatecoug

8/20/19 1:55pm

LOL, we were talking about "potential" and "hype," and then

Scratch

8/20/19 2:02pm

No message

Scratch

8/20/19 2:01pm

The evaluators on the ground thought Romney was better but were overruled by the national guys

slatecoug

8/20/19 12:01am

RE: The evaluators on the ground thought Romney was better but were overruled by

displacedute

8/20/19 10:39am

Jake Heaps had more P5 offers than Enis. Is that what we should use as the ultimate litmus test?

slatecoug

8/20/19 1:55pm

RE: Jake Heaps had more P5 offers than Enis. Is that what we should use as the

displacedute

8/20/19 2:06pm

This is the thread that won’t die

Posting on CougarBoard