The worst review was for the 4th and 1 where the line judge came in and insisted

Sep 17, 2019
11:07:30am

StarMan All-American

on placing the ball when there was just a mass of humanity lying on the ground between him and the ball carrier when the back judge had a clear view of the location of the ball when the player was down.

Report problem with this ad

StarMan

Previous username: ByuMba90
Bio page: StarMan
Joined: Jan 15, 2001
Last login: May 6, 2024
Total posts: 90,812 (5,663 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

USC game officiating. Comment & Question

Borg

9/17/19 10:57am

they also missed a play where Slovis was across the line when he threw

Mr Bassman

9/17/19 10:58am

He was about 2 yards beyond the LOS. It was pretty bad.

Rise Against

9/17/19 10:59am

Any part of the body can be at the LOS and it's not a penalty. Looked pretty

cougaman

9/17/19 11:04am

you can see the actual marker and the ref standing at said marker

Mr Bassman

9/17/19 11:14am

Jared Lloyd wrote a decent article about bouncing back from

stevebyu8

9/17/19 2:36pm

The fan behind me disagreed with every call . . every call. Needed to shut up

RealSimsShadY

9/17/19 11:00am

That's annoying to be around

mncstr

9/17/19 12:53pm

I had the same question about the hit on Micah Simon

frontrowcougar

9/17/19 11:00am

rewatched it. It was not a crown of the helmet hit

Croweater

9/17/19 12:59pm

There were poor spots for both teams...

PortlandCoug

9/17/19 11:04am

The worst review was for the 4th and 1 where the line judge came in and insisted

StarMan

9/17/19 11:07am

Honestly I think that is what ticked off Sitake....not only was the call

westsidecoug

9/17/19 11:05am

I think they had determined to do that during the timeout and then forgot until

RyneK

9/17/19 11:08am

If that is the case, I have even less confidence in the refs than I already did.

westsidecoug

9/17/19 11:14am

We should have counted ourselves lucky to get a second try as Dayan's first

Corn Pop

9/17/19 11:05am

or a bigger player. Dayan got lit up on his play.

RealSimsShadY

9/17/19 11:10am

Exactly. USC blew up the play and then BYU lined up and ran it exactly

Str8CashCougar

9/17/19 12:35pm

Seriously, can't believe they ran the same exact play twice when it didn't work

therock

9/17/19 1:00pm

Well, if USC thought as you did, it would be brilliant to run the same play

basman

9/17/19 1:38pm

Barry Switzer, is that you?

Corn Pop

9/17/19 1:47pm

Who knows. Play was blown dead before that. Who knows which players stopped and

cougaman

9/17/19 12:45pm

One thing I noticed about redoing the scrum play. The second time it

JuicyJam

9/17/19 11:08am

One ref was on the plus side, the other on the negative

Borg

9/17/19 12:03pm

I don't think I explained myself well.

JuicyJam

9/17/19 2:23pm

ha, thats really funny.

robin

9/17/19 2:39pm

Time to retire the scrum formation. Not fooling anybody anymore

Str8CashCougar

9/17/19 12:42pm

Answers

ike

9/17/19 11:09am

When the refs hold up play so the D can sub, they shouldn't be able

mcnasty

9/17/19 11:56am

When can the refs hold the ball when there is no substitution?

cube3_cougar

9/17/19 1:15pm

I think he's saying there was a substitution. BYU brought on a new group.

BYUHawk

9/17/19 1:28pm

That's not the way I read it, but you could be right

cube3_cougar

9/17/19 1:56pm

were you would be wrong on #3 is Romney would be considered a defenseless

byublue42

9/17/19 1:50pm

Spots seemed bad. I was curious about the 2 targets, but I don't know the rules.

Benfica1

9/17/19 11:48am

If you are talking about Wilson's run in the 4th, it was a little unfair spot,

cougaman

9/17/19 12:05pm

Targeting is helmet to helmet I believe.

andrewg3

9/17/19 11:57am

Targeting doesn't have to be helmet to helmet.

bluesloth

9/17/19 12:04pm

About the throw to Gunner Romney

Heinz57

9/17/19 12:41pm

Slovis on one play got up like he was concussed and was allowed to continue.

dodgersjazzcougs

9/17/19 12:51pm

Probably when he got poked in the eye, he was looking rather dazed after that,

basman

9/17/19 1:40pm

That dazed, wild eyed look, made sense after I heard about eye poke

MatthiasPhunkHausen

9/17/19 2:38pm

He was really wobbly. Should have made him come out of the game for at

dodgersjazzcougs

9/17/19 3:57pm

<< Deleted >>

MatthiasPhunkHausen

9/25/19 6:47pm

I have a question on one play

baldcoug74

9/17/19 2:43pm

Y'all suck. I was once a ref and both sides were convinced I had a secret

A Man in Full

9/17/19 4:06pm

Booooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

westsidecoug

9/17/19 4:12pm

Well played, my friend.

A Man in Full

9/17/19 4:26pm

Well were you cheering for one side? or bribed?

RealSimsShadY

9/17/19 4:48pm

Welcome to Cougarboard! "Ya'all suck", might not have been the best first post

EFM_Coug

9/17/19 4:59pm

I know whereof I speak

A Man in Full

9/18/19 10:26pm

Targeting seems like what happened on the Dayan run

EFM_Coug

9/17/19 5:03pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad