Yeah, the 2 wins over rivals outweighs the 2 poor road losses.

Nov 11, 2019
11:24:56am

Doogal McCougar Walk-on

And, don't forget that we have wins over both Tennessee and USC this year. Those four wins pretty much sill the dill. The only thing that could prevent an extension is if we lose to either Idaho State or UMass.

Report problem with this ad

Doogal McCougar

Previous username: boscatar
Bio page: Doogal McCougar
Joined: Jun 14, 2012
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 15,554 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Just when we though Sitake had turned the corner with the wins vs. Boise and USU

Hinta

11/11/19 11:17am

Yup. That Liberty win was probably our worst loss of the year.

Blueto

11/11/19 11:19am

Winning by 7 against a team like Liberty does not show "improvement". Sorry.

BleedCougarBlue2

11/11/19 1:06pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

11/12/19 1:57pm

38-24 would have been acceptable, IMO. Or 31-14.

Doogal McCougar

11/12/19 2:08pm

Note, we'd finish regular season 8-4, not 8-5.

durandal

11/11/19 11:19am

Thanks

Hinta

11/11/19 11:23am

I really do believe we will see changes among the defensive coaches

Backcountry

11/11/19 11:21am

I am not counting on it. KS doesn't have the courage to fire a BFF.

BleedCougarBlue2

11/11/19 1:25pm

He will after this year

Backcountry

11/11/19 1:28pm

Disagree. If Sitake truly sees the need, why not do it now? If he sees the....

BleedCougarBlue2

11/11/19 1:44pm

You expect him to can his coordinator mid season?

Backcountry

11/11/19 1:45pm

Bronco did mid-season and guess what? The D improved, quickly.

BleedCougarBlue2

11/11/19 11:21pm

He waited until season end to fire Detmer. He will wait to fire Tuiaki.

Lance71

11/11/19 2:24pm

Any insider knowledge of this or is this just your gut feeling?

Bluesangue

11/11/19 3:08pm

I hope so, but worried he doesn't make a change. If he was going to fire Tuiaki

cougaman

11/11/19 3:03pm

I dont see how there cant be a shuffle at seasons end

Backcountry

11/11/19 3:07pm

There definitely should be...

cougaman

11/11/19 3:13pm

They won. They're 5-4. They're highly likely to be 7-4 going into SDSU

Adrielle

11/11/19 11:22am

Yeah, the 2 wins over rivals outweighs the 2 poor road losses.

Doogal McCougar

11/11/19 11:24am

Man, that schedule could be a coach-killer.

displacedute

11/11/19 11:22am

BYU could easily be favored against MSU and Missouri

BYU '80

11/11/19 5:59pm

So did Sitake take over the defense or not? If he did, then isn't this on him?

Indy Coug

11/11/19 11:24am

Just watching him on the sidelines it doesn't look like he is calling plays

Hinta

11/11/19 11:25am

So he magically takes over when they "do well" and magically stops when they don't?

Indy Coug

11/11/19 11:28am

I'm as mystified as you are

Hinta

11/11/19 11:29am

I wondered if he was trying to give Tuiaki another shot against an easier opp

BYU Fan

11/11/19 11:38am

Against a QB who was 10th nationally in pass efficiency and the #1 WR in receiving yards nationally?

Indy Coug

11/11/19 11:39am

CB was pretty convinced that Liberty was a garbage team last week

BYU Fan

11/11/19 11:41am

When did the defense really do well?

Oldcougfan

11/11/19 11:41am

During a blizzard against Boise's back up QB

BYU Fan

11/11/19 11:42am

I'm just parroting the CB conventional wisdom narrative here.

Indy Coug

11/11/19 11:47am

Tuiaki said today on coord corner that early

BYU '80

11/11/19 6:01pm

I think when Kalani hits win #6 and is bowl eligible, he gets extended.

Eddie

11/11/19 11:28am

If BYU goes from 4-9, to 7-6,

BYURider

11/11/19 11:29am

If BYU fires anyone for going 9-4, they deserve whatever bad karma they get

Indy Coug

11/11/19 11:32am

It's not just the 9-4, it's the inconsistency and the lack of learning as HC.

BleedCougarBlue2

11/11/19 11:26pm

Wins are the bottom line. If BYU goes 9-4, with a harder schedule

BYURider

11/12/19 4:57am

Even 8-5, with wins over Boise, USU, USC, and Tennessee....that's improvement

Doogal McCougar

11/11/19 11:32am

win out 9-4 (including bowl game) to not extend Sitake especially considering

franklyvulgar

11/11/19 11:32am

Maybe Starting the 3rd String QB and RB and others Finally Caught Up to Us

Chicago Cougar

11/11/19 11:38am

We've already tried the thing where TH dictates who the coordinators can and

kolob32

11/11/19 12:05pm

If BYU wins out, I vote for a 1 or 2 yr extension

Reedme

11/11/19 12:38pm

From aggressive D vs BSU to zero aggressive D vs LU. Why???

Coug Dude

11/11/19 1:16pm

All of a sudden that Minnesota game looks a lot tougher

Bill

11/11/19 1:48pm

Can't hear you through the bag.

Lip Gallagher

11/11/19 3:08pm

So we're in the "BYU is trash" part of the CB sentiment roller coaster. Nice

Machiavelli

11/11/19 3:32pm

Two steps forward, one step back.

Eddie

11/11/19 3:45pm

We won. Our offense is better. Our D scheme still sucks.

Posting on CougarBoard