My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 26, 2019
6:13
:54
pm
ataylor
All-American
Playoffs need to move to home field advantage for everything but championship.
Maybe semifinals if you have 12–16 teams.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
ataylor
Bio page
ataylor
Joined
Apr 20, 2009
Last login
May 16, 2020
Total posts
33,802 (2,404 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
My proposal for an 8 team playoff:
DieHarder
Maclunkey
11/26/19 6:07pm
Playoffs need to move to home field advantage for everything but championship.
ataylor
11/26/19 6:13pm
While I agree, I don't think that will happen. Too much power and money in the bowls.
durandal
11/26/19 6:24pm
Allow teams who lose in earlier rounds to play in a bowl game then.
jreid191
11/26/19 6:32pm
I think P5 teams would happily pocket gate revenues.
ataylor
11/26/19 6:34pm
As for G5 #3, sometimes the team can't control that themselves. Why would a p5
cougaman
11/26/19 6:16pm
That is one of the biggest flaws with my idea I agree. I’m not sure how you fix that
DieHarder
11/26/19 6:17pm
Take off that criteria. If they go undefeated, they have to be ranked a certain
cougaman
11/26/19 6:18pm
I guess that works if you’re using the computer ranking system. We know a committee would leave them out
DieHarder
11/26/19 6:21pm
I think a G5 should have a guaranteed spot, as long as they are ranked top 12,
cougaman
11/26/19 6:26pm
I like some of your ideas, but why must the P5 teams have 10 wins, but G5s don't
Cougar TD
11/26/19 6:17pm
G5 would have to have 13 wins, presuming they have a CCG.
cougaman
11/26/19 6:19pm
G5s must go undefeated
DieHarder
11/26/19 6:21pm
I suck at reading
Cougar TD
11/26/19 6:27pm
Just take the top 8 teams. Forget all the qualifiers, conferences, etc.
CopperLix
11/26/19 6:24pm
I like the CCG as a play in type game.
cougaman
11/26/19 6:26pm
If you want to have restrictions for conference champs, why not just say
jreid191
11/26/19 6:36pm
What if 2 G5’s meet the criteria? Also, I’d say 11 wins for the P5 champ,
bluecougar1985
11/26/19 6:41pm
So, auto bids
1984coug
11/26/19 7:21pm
95% of the time, yes. But remember the unranked Big East teams that played NY6 Bowls? That’s what I’m trying to avoid
DieHarder
11/26/19 7:29pm
Um, NO. Any 8-team playoff that doesn't guarantee a spot for the P5 champions
TrueBlue67
11/26/19 8:01pm
Pretty much every P5 champ the last 10 years would get an auto bid. The idea is to eliminate fluke 9 win conf. champs
DieHarder
11/26/19 8:10pm
I like it.
IronPotato
11/26/19 8:21pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad