G5 would have to have 13 wins, presuming they have a CCG.

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 26, 2019
6:19:24pm

cougaman All-American

G5 would have to have 13 wins, presuming they have a CCG.

Report problem with this ad

cougaman

Bio page: cougaman
Joined: Mar 11, 2006
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 68,655 (4,449 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

My proposal for an 8 team playoff:

DieHarder Maclunkey

11/26/19 6:07pm

Playoffs need to move to home field advantage for everything but championship.

ataylor

11/26/19 6:13pm

While I agree, I don't think that will happen. Too much power and money in the bowls.

durandal

11/26/19 6:24pm

Allow teams who lose in earlier rounds to play in a bowl game then.

jreid191

11/26/19 6:32pm

I think P5 teams would happily pocket gate revenues.

ataylor

11/26/19 6:34pm

As for G5 #3, sometimes the team can't control that themselves. Why would a p5

cougaman

11/26/19 6:16pm

That is one of the biggest flaws with my idea I agree. I’m not sure how you fix that

DieHarder

11/26/19 6:17pm

Take off that criteria. If they go undefeated, they have to be ranked a certain

cougaman

11/26/19 6:18pm

I guess that works if you’re using the computer ranking system. We know a committee would leave them out

DieHarder

11/26/19 6:21pm

I think a G5 should have a guaranteed spot, as long as they are ranked top 12,

cougaman

11/26/19 6:26pm

I like some of your ideas, but why must the P5 teams have 10 wins, but G5s don't

Cougar TD

11/26/19 6:17pm

G5 would have to have 13 wins, presuming they have a CCG.

cougaman

11/26/19 6:19pm

G5s must go undefeated

DieHarder

11/26/19 6:21pm

I suck at reading

Cougar TD

11/26/19 6:27pm

Just take the top 8 teams. Forget all the qualifiers, conferences, etc.

CopperLix

11/26/19 6:24pm

I like the CCG as a play in type game.

cougaman

11/26/19 6:26pm

If you want to have restrictions for conference champs, why not just say

jreid191

11/26/19 6:36pm

What if 2 G5’s meet the criteria? Also, I’d say 11 wins for the P5 champ,

11/26/19 6:41pm

So, auto bids

1984coug

11/26/19 7:21pm

95% of the time, yes. But remember the unranked Big East teams that played NY6 Bowls? That’s what I’m trying to avoid

DieHarder

11/26/19 7:29pm

Um, NO. Any 8-team playoff that doesn't guarantee a spot for the P5 champions

TrueBlue67

11/26/19 8:01pm

Pretty much every P5 champ the last 10 years would get an auto bid. The idea is to eliminate fluke 9 win conf. champs

DieHarder

11/26/19 8:10pm

I like it.

IronPotato

11/26/19 8:21pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad