That's the point I'm trying to make. Oklahoma could very well be the more

Dec 4, 2019
3:12:54pm

Duke Silver All-American

deserving team in the end. This weekend will hopefully make it clear one way or the other. But to suggest the OU should leapfrog Utah simply due to them being a bigger school and nothing else, I can't get behind that.

Report problem with this ad

Duke Silver

Previous username: Marshmallow Matey
Bio page: Duke Silver
Joined: Feb 23, 2008
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 24,031 (323 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Honestly Finebaum’s comments about Utah and the playoff are making me hope they

Duke Silver

12/4/19 2:46pm

Well you are about as wrong as you can be on this. Utah should not be in. It is that simple.

Baron

12/4/19 2:48pm

Yep, Oklahoma has the better resume

-C9-

12/4/19 2:54pm

Your vote doesn’t count. Neither does mine. Utah’s next in line in the polls.

canofpicante

12/4/19 8:02pm

No they won't. Big 12 champ will be in. And Utah will lose to Oregon

Baron

12/5/19 5:33am

Good call.

canofpicante

12/16/19 9:29pm

The soundbite doesn't capture the part where he accurately points out that the

a priori

12/4/19 2:48pm

No one cares about brand or ratings, its because Oklahoma's resume is better

MikeDitka'sStache

12/4/19 2:49pm

I'd actually argue they do care about brand and ratings. But in this case,

777

12/4/19 2:52pm

Finebaum clearly cares about brand and school names.

Pistol Shrimp

12/4/19 2:52pm

Luckily, he has no impact at all on the committee though

MikeDitka'sStache

12/4/19 2:54pm

Every G5 and most of P5 should be rooting for Utah to get in. BYU, Okie and Baylor fans have exemptions from that.

BlueFrog

12/4/19 2:49pm

If Cal or something was in Utah's position right now I would definitely want

JuicyJam

12/4/19 2:50pm

<< Deleted >>

cougfan03

12/4/19 2:59pm

If both utah and Oklahoma win, utah should be left out because they have fewer

chilango

12/4/19 2:50pm

Did you feel this way when BYU got screwed in 1996?

ReyOso

12/4/19 3:06pm

I’ll answer for him.

DocPimp

12/4/19 3:10pm

How did BYU get screwed that year?

chilango

12/4/19 3:19pm

They had a great team. Should have had a higher stakes bowl game.

ReyOso

12/4/19 4:48pm

Hmm...the way the Committee counts it, Utah has more quality wins

TFL

12/4/19 5:46pm

I'm ok with them being left out. They are part of the entitled system. I'm fine if they are treated like crap.

Ragnar Danneskjold

12/4/19 2:50pm

Live by the sword, die by the sword.

cracka

12/4/19 2:52pm

RE: Honestly Finebaum’s comments about Utah and the playoff are making me

LiveCoug

12/4/19 2:51pm

It makes me want to cheer for Oregon, Baylor, and LSU

Doogal McCougar

12/4/19 2:53pm

No way. I don't give a crap about some really good P5 team sticking it to some other P5 team.

cougfanblue

12/4/19 2:53pm

Utah has beaten zero ranked teams, lost to the only ranked team they played, and

Dangerous

12/4/19 2:54pm

Right or wrong (not for me to decide)...

DocPimp

12/4/19 3:01pm

Sure, but they've also pummeled almost every team they've played. Oklahoma has

Duke Silver

12/4/19 3:11pm

When has politics NOT been involved in anything regarding college football

IdahoCoug

12/4/19 3:18pm

Finebaum's take is ridiculous. He's beclowning himself. I don't root for the Utes, and I don't know whether they

CalGTR

12/4/19 2:56pm

Did you watch the whole segment, or just one small clip? Have you ever listened

IdahoCoug

12/4/19 2:59pm

I'm addressing a specific line of argument he's putting forth, not everything he's ever said on the subject. I think

CalGTR

12/4/19 3:06pm

It's always okay to ridicule Utah.

IdahoCoug

12/4/19 3:10pm

That's the point I'm trying to make. Oklahoma could very well be the more

Duke Silver

12/4/19 3:12pm

Oklahoma's a better team, with a better schedule. Sucks for the Utes, but true.

IdahoCoug

12/4/19 2:57pm

If it was BYU, I'd be appalled. But it is Utah so I like it.

Turnpike Lane

12/4/19 3:09pm

This is why we can't have nice things.

Coug

12/4/19 3:12pm

I'd love for the whole system to collapse. TV ratings and strength of schedule

Colorado

12/4/19 3:19pm

You have a point but I still HATE the Pukes so screw em'! Go DUCKS!!!!

CT98

12/4/19 3:28pm

I can't see how it negatively effects BYU.

godawgs

12/4/19 3:42pm

Biggest thing is still going undefeated.

IdahoCoug

12/4/19 3:50pm

Not sure I agree with this argument.

Colorado

12/4/19 4:07pm

I want to believe this, but the Finebaum's of the world would REALLY be

IdahoCoug

12/4/19 4:24pm

"Will it negatively affect BYU? [definitely]" FIFY

Resurgens

12/4/19 7:02pm

I have to agree with your premise. This kind of legacy logic

StalwartBraveTrue

12/4/19 7:39pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad