My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Feb 18, 2020
8:19
:46
am
memento
All-American
So the punishment should be lighter
Because their scheme wasn’t as successful as they wanted it to be?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
memento
Bio page
memento
Joined
Nov 26, 2010
Last login
May 3, 2024
Total posts
5,604 (375 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Imagine trying to hit one of these pitches without knowing what was coming
Medute
2/18/20 7:21am
But everybody steals signs. Did the Astros go too far? Yes. But to think that
rggee
2/18/20 7:23am
So the Astros went too far and cheated to win a WS
Medute
2/18/20 7:26am
Correct. The Red Sox also cheated and are being investigated.
TCuz
2/18/20 7:29am
I guarantee the Yankees did too. Just ask Carlos Beltran.
rggee
2/18/20 7:33am
"The report noted that the Yankees had been using their video replay room to
rggee
2/18/20 7:37am
Fan of cheating team tries to sling dirt at others to downplay cheating. Nah.
TCuz
2/18/20 7:38am
To think this was isolated to 1 or 2 teams is simply naive. I'm sure at least
rggee
2/18/20 7:40am
I’m sure all the fans of cheating teams will tell themselves that.
TCuz
2/18/20 7:46am
That's a really bad attempt at justification, and your guarantee isn't worth anything
jdub
2/18/20 7:48am
I'm not justifying it. It crossed the line 100% and needs to stop.
rggee
2/18/20 8:20am
RE: To think this was isolated to 1 or 2 teams is simply naive. I'm sure at
COACHdrn
2/18/20 8:33am
You can "thumbs down" me all you want. That doesn't change the fact that it's...
COACHdrn
2/18/20 8:58am
Astros are the only ones who
memento
2/18/20 7:41am
Have you seen the reaction of just about every other team about the ...
COACHdrn
2/18/20 8:10am
If everyone is doing it, how are the Astros the only team to go from worst
AZ Coug
2/18/20 10:40pm
The same crappy lineup? Huh?
Scratch
2/18/20 10:54pm
Blind Hate
GulfCoastcoug
2/19/20 7:57am
Yep. So the cheating didn't help them, right?
AZ Coug
2/19/20 5:32pm
Where are you getting this 3 years concept
GulfCoastcoug
2/20/20 10:58pm
There are obvious reason to believe it's been 3 years (or more) and frankly,...
COACHdrn
2/21/20 12:23am
So be it
GulfCoastcoug
2/21/20 7:21am
Do the stats support your claim?
Baron
2/18/20 7:24am
5 players' postseason stats from 2017
Medute
2/18/20 7:30am
And? What are their historical splits? Other teams splits?
Baron
2/18/20 7:31am
They were doing it at home and on the road. Sample sizes that small are almost
Scratch
2/18/20 7:46am
Not being provocative, really! What pitch is each of those supposed to depict?
StarMan
2/18/20 7:34am
WOW, I just came up with a good punishment for the Astros batters....
StarMan
2/18/20 7:36am
Not sure how or why anyone couldn’t easily understand how big of a deal and
Gerald-DeGroot
2/18/20 7:37am
Come on- for professionals it’s a huge deal. For 95% of us we could know 100%
SouthernBlueBlood
2/18/20 7:44am
Now imagine trying to hit one of those pitches when you’re pretty sure a
Scratch
2/18/20 7:52am
Other than helping them win the WS you mean.
jdub
2/18/20 8:00am
Except we don’t actually know if it helped them win the WS. We know that they
Scratch
2/18/20 8:05am
So the punishment should be lighter
memento
2/18/20 8:19am
Nope, never said that. I'm only addressing the argument that it provided some
Scratch
2/18/20 8:35am
If it didn’t provide a benefit they would have stopped
memento
2/18/20 9:03am
They did stop. And the evidence shows that it did not really help.
Scratch
2/18/20 9:11am
Except they used it in the playoffs, so clearly they thought
memento
2/18/20 10:21am
READ MY POSTS, I NEVER SAID IT WASN'T BAD. I SAID IT WAS BAD AND THEY SHOULD BE
Scratch
2/18/20 10:24am
YELLING WORKS!
memento
2/18/20 10:45am
Not yelling wasn’t working. The efficacy of the cheating should have no bearing
Scratch
2/18/20 10:47am
But P.S. the opposite is also true; people can’t argue that the punishment
Scratch
2/18/20 10:52am
The punishment is light no matter what.
memento
2/18/20 1:26pm
And P.S., at the time of the 2017 playiffs they obviously believed it was worth
Scratch
2/18/20 10:25am
You have evidence they stopped?
Colorado
2/18/20 11:13am
Yep. That's what everyone said and that MLB's investigation agreed.
Scratch
2/18/20 11:24am
MLB only said they didn't find evidence. It may be conspiratorial, but the
Colorado
2/18/20 2:16pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
