The umpire can call it dead if he wants. Hence the manager decision to go out and challenge.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 21, 2020
9:37:22pm

jholling All-American

The umpire can call it dead if he wants. Hence the manager decision to go out and challenge.

Good fielders can take advantage of umpires not calling it how they should.

Report problem with this ad

jholling

New username: FromCAtoUT
Bio page: jholling
Joined: Feb 23, 2007
Last login: Aug 24, 2021
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Interesting!

Endocoug

10/21/20 7:58pm

I stand corrected.

SlantRoute

10/21/20 8:01pm

Late to this discussion but the MLB umps definitely had it right there

10/21/20 8:10pm

You’re not making sense.

Endocoug

10/21/20 8:19pm

The defense has no unfair advantage if the batter is exerting any effort

10/21/20 8:23pm

I disagree

Endocoug

10/21/20 8:28pm

This is correct and there is a rule to protect runners in exactly this case.

jholling

10/21/20 8:41pm

Um ... did you watch the video?

Endocoug

10/21/20 9:24pm

The umpire can call it dead if he wants. Hence the manager decision to go out and challenge.

jholling

10/21/20 9:37pm

I’m aware of that rule. But you said there is a rule to protect

Endocoug

10/21/20 9:43pm

There is. The umpire just blew it and didn’t use that rule. I have seen it many times

jholling

10/21/20 9:59pm

Apparently they disagree with you.

Endocoug

10/22/20 5:26am

It’s called the “Intentional drop rule”. Rule 5.09(a)(12)

jholling

10/21/20 9:40pm

I have done this exact thing many times at shortstop on line drives and turned 2 (sometimes 3).There is actually a rule

jholling

10/21/20 8:40pm

He tagged the runner first. Since the force was on, first was not a safe bag for the runner. If he would have stepped on

scootsy

10/22/20 6:03am

Yes. See related thread for the whole discussion.

Endocoug

10/22/20 6:12am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad