That's why my comments are based on my opinion, not evidence

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 12, 2020
10:32:46am

jhingman All-American

That's why my comments are based on my opinion, not evidence

I think our offense is likely good enough to hang with almost every CFB defense out there, but our defense isn't. A good offensive team will be able to move up and down the field against us unfortunately. Doesn't mean we can't still win a big game, but our defense takes us completely out of the playoff discussion, if not the NY6.

Report problem with this ad

jhingman

Bio page: jhingman
Joined: Nov 3, 2008
Last login: Mar 11, 2024
Total posts: 2,423 (12 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I listened to this national pundit talk about BYU. He confirmed my thoughts.

The Y's Insider

11/12/20 9:05am

Seems like a reasonable take.

gangbusters

11/12/20 9:08am

I disagree. Too many buy into this "P5" crap

CaughtForaTouchdown

11/12/20 2:01pm

Accurate.

kccougar

11/12/20 9:08am

My thoughts exactly

StantonMac

11/12/20 9:09am

Yup, and it's so frustrating.

Squeegee

11/12/20 9:12am

Exact reason why playing cincinnati in a NY6 bowl would be a tradegy.

jaredm

11/12/20 9:14am

The video about your dad in your sig is awesome

11/12/20 10:32am

I have to agree. Maybe we should just keep the schedule as is.

zerigke

11/12/20 9:11am

Optics count: 12-0 looks a lot better than 3-1

2FarGone

11/12/20 9:13am

I'm still of the position to schedule at least 1 more game - any game.

11/12/20 9:40am

He nailed it. Similarly, one thing BYU has going is the eye test. Herbstreit keeps talking about how BYU just looks

Byron McNertney

11/12/20 9:15am

I can't argue with any of that. I have felt that way this entire year. NY6 would be a great result.....

Bonoman

11/12/20 9:16am

It’s about the $$$. They won’t let BYU share in the big money.

11/12/20 9:16am

^^^^^^^^ What he said!

hdx57

11/12/20 11:19am

pretty much the hand we have been dealt. What amazes me is that you could play Rutgers and win and get more respect

ChinaFan

11/12/20 9:18am

His “Resume” formula is for a normal season and this year is anything but.

WorldBFree

11/12/20 9:38am

Meant to respond to OP

WorldBFree

11/12/20 9:39am

B1G teams don't get any bump from beating Rutgers (unless it's a blowout)

reddead

11/12/20 11:54am

Wisc shot to the top 10 after 1 game vs. #107 Illinois (worse than W. KY)

Mr. Scoobs

11/12/20 11:57am

I think Louisville is a P5 (ACC) team

robin

11/12/20 2:29pm

Pretty sure he meant to say Liberty.

Lalau

11/12/20 8:47pm

College football postseason is a terrible terrible system.

Mr. Scoobs

11/12/20 9:20am

Hard to disagree with any of that.

shoganai

11/12/20 9:21am

Yep, my thoughts exactly.

Benfica1

11/12/20 9:22am

A weak schedule means you're untested, but not that you're bad.

refunder

11/12/20 9:35am

Play the big boys but they won't play you.

BYU Grounds

11/12/20 9:39am

He kinda contradicts himself. If BYU beats Liberty they'd drop out. But so would Army.

mulletino

11/12/20 9:41am

RE: He kinda contradicts himself. If BYU beats Liberty they'd drop out. But so

The Y's Insider

11/12/20 11:03am

He does. Maybe Army has a better history or just carries more weight?

Florwood

11/12/20 11:06am

True, both Liberty and Army would drop from the rankings. Maybe he feels Army

Benfica1

11/12/20 11:10am

Or maybe he thinks Army is more beatable than Liberty but has the same rep.

The Y's Insider

11/12/20 11:14am

I totally agree with the take. We also don't know what's going to happen with

Hoss Bonaventure

11/12/20 9:41am

It's reasonable. I honestly don't think BYU is close to playoff competitive

jhingman

11/12/20 10:01am

BYU is not part of the CFP. Doesn’t have a vote and doesn’t have a promise

Nat Gas Man

11/12/20 10:10am

Not true. If we finish undefeated with a NY6 win, then run the table next year

zerigke

11/12/20 10:15am

They have no guarantee it belongs to the conferences

Nat Gas Man

11/12/20 10:16am

Zero evidence of that. BYU is #3 in SP+ resume and top 6 in the objective rating

Mr. Scoobs

11/12/20 10:11am

That's why my comments are based on my opinion, not evidence

jhingman

11/12/20 10:32am

System shouldn't eliminate undefeated teams winning 45-13 on average. BYU was

Mr. Scoobs

11/12/20 11:07am

I agree with everything he said. Which is why I think we need to add Cincy

archie

11/12/20 10:20am

Cincy won't schedule us. 99% confident.

zerigke

11/12/20 10:26am

A loss to Cincy and we are bowling in Boise

dk4

11/12/20 10:28am

This is the key- risk/reward. Cincy is about as good as we are, if we have to go on the road to play them

11/12/20 11:38am

Far under 50% chance to get into the playoff.

StantonMac

11/12/20 11:42am

Even if BYU beat Cincy, how do they break the top 4?

reddead

11/12/20 12:01pm

For something you quickly caught on the radio in passing

Sale

11/12/20 10:22am

I agree completely! I don't want to schedule more games, just win our last two

mort

11/12/20 10:40am

Pretty persuasive. Sounds like getting Army in the schedule might be worth the

Forzaitalia

11/12/20 10:41am

And we had it 🙁 (Army game at the beginning of the season)

BluebloodOR

11/12/20 10:58am

Those are exactly my thoughts...so obviously he's spot on.

11/12/20 11:24am

That is almost exactly how I view it. For CFP, we would likely beat out a 2-loss

LifeLongLakerFan

11/12/20 11:29am

It's a reasonable take, but I say, screw risk vs reward! Play games! We're...

Katewot

11/12/20 11:50am

Even good teams have bad games though.

zerigke

11/12/20 11:55am

I would hope our AD is a bit more calculating and level-headed.

The Y's Insider

11/12/20 2:55pm

If BYU doesn't get into a NY6 game this year... that will once and for all solidify Independence for what it is...

Coug

11/12/20 11:56am

Basically BYU is in the same situation as Cincinnati. If both teams win out,

Bee Chunder

11/12/20 12:06pm

If Liberty beats NC state they will be 8-0 with wins on the road against two

11/12/20 12:22pm

This is all true, but very frustrating. P5 teams aren't willing to play us

here's to hoping

11/12/20 12:27pm

Wait, the four teams that make the playoff will have played each other?!?!

COACHdrn

11/12/20 1:02pm

Not literally.

The Y's Insider

11/12/20 2:51pm

I agree mostly with his take, only I'm less optimistic than he that we've nearly

SinkingQuffa

11/12/20 1:16pm

But you don't know who the "national pundit" was. That's kind-of important...

LEDSFW

11/12/20 1:38pm

This is 100% Correct

runningryan

11/12/20 2:25pm

Your take is 100% right errrrrr I meant the “radio guys” take and questions are

11/12/20 3:18pm

Confirms? I'd say more like the call stands

Bill

11/12/20 4:20pm

Well the guy is an idiot because Georgia has zero chance at CFP this year

ordinary tri guy

11/12/20 4:39pm

You misread the post.

The Y's Insider

11/12/20 4:53pm

Even so better names to use outside Georgia.

ordinary tri guy

11/13/20 5:58am

<< Deleted >>

The Y's Insider

11/12/20 4:53pm

Wait, he thinks if undefeated #15 Marshall/ CC #16 loses to a top 10 team that they will fall out of the rankings?

11/12/20 10:33pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad