I'm fine with the underdog story. But not fine with rewarding CUSA champ just

Jan 11, 2021
10:46:42pm

LiveCoug Intervention Needed

because. That is massively rewarding G5s for no real reason.

If the CUSA champ meets a high enough criteria, sure, let em in, but to just automatically give a spot to a, say, 9-3 UTSA is ridiculous

Report problem with this ad

LiveCoug

Bio page: LiveCoug
Joined: Aug 26, 2001
Last login: May 9, 2024
Total posts: 112,460 (11,509 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I think the only way you fix college football is to expand the playoff to 16.

Duke Silver

1/11/21 10:35pm

Autobids for all G5 conferences should never and will never happen

LiveCoug

1/11/21 10:38pm

if autobids for all 10 conferences doesn't happen it continues to be a sham..

BYU Grounds

1/11/21 10:40pm

Not really buddy

cambo

1/11/21 10:42pm

This conversation has been had before. It shouldn't happen and the comparison

LiveCoug

1/11/21 10:43pm

Why? This brings more competition to college football...

BYU Grounds

1/11/21 10:46pm

Because it way overvalues G5 champions. Why should buffalo be rewarded

LiveCoug

1/11/21 10:49pm

Because they won their conference. Just like in basketball

Cougar TD

1/11/21 10:58pm

Who cares? Seriously, who cares who wins the WAC/MWC/MAC?

Alpi Gusto

1/11/21 11:55pm

Whether YOU care or not, every once in a while you get a team that can make a ru

niqmadu

1/12/21 2:44am

“Every once and awhile” shouldn’t give them the same chance as a conference

Alpi Gusto

1/12/21 9:14am

Why not?

niqmadu

1/12/21 9:17am

Because they aren’t one of the best teams

Alpi Gusto

1/12/21 9:39am

I bet a lot of people hated watching all of the upsets in march madness.

Cougar TD

1/12/21 11:10am

And that is the thinking of the P5...who cares who wins the non-P5 championships

Cougar TD

1/12/21 8:33am

Ah so you like football to be women's gymnastics. Got it.

EtTuKalante

1/11/21 10:43pm

I'm fine with the underdog story. But not fine with rewarding CUSA champ just

LiveCoug

1/11/21 10:46pm

Monopolies are monopolies specifically because they restrict competition.

EtTuKalante

1/11/21 11:09pm

Why, the rule is that you need to win your conference championship

CougarVeteran

1/11/21 11:31pm

Any undefeated G5 team would easily get an invite to a 16-team playoff.

garyfan

1/11/21 10:53pm

“Easily”? Did you not learn from BYUs rankings this year?

puntersarepeople

1/11/21 10:59pm

An undefeated BYU team would easily be in the top 16.

ManicBlue

1/11/21 11:28pm

Because they blew almost everyone out and played a few decent name brand teams

puntersarepeople

1/11/21 11:37pm

Name brand teams? Only BSU. BYU's ranking this season is consistent with

garyfan

1/12/21 12:21am

Cincinnati, CC, and Liberty (had they not lost to NC St by one point) all were

ManicBlue

1/12/21 2:32am

Then you can put a max number of losses a team can have to qualify for an

Duke Silver

1/11/21 11:27pm

or just that they have to be in the top 25 of a composite computer ranking

ManicBlue

1/11/21 11:29pm

But there’s something special about the autobid, including a ranking system

Duke Silver

1/11/21 11:32pm

Generally, it wouldn't be an issue but it could work against a P5 conference the

ManicBlue

1/12/21 11:48pm

That’s actually pretty simple

puntersarepeople

1/11/21 11:38pm

All that would do is discourage P5 teams from scheduling quality OOC games.

garyfan

1/12/21 12:22am

Meanwhile a 3 loss Iowa State makes it. Shouldn't have to be undefeated.

RUNBYU1

1/13/21 11:47am

I agree. Undefeated isn’t the requirement. My point is that I believe we have

garyfan

1/13/21 12:12pm

I think it should happen. Even if it’s some kind of play in games to get there

cougarfann888

1/11/21 10:46pm

Why? It works for basketball. G5 teams will never have a chance unless they're

ManicBlue

1/11/21 11:26pm

It works for basketball because there are significantly more at large bids

LiveCoug

1/12/21 8:10am

there are also significantly more D1 basketball programs too

ManicBlue

1/12/21 3:28pm

Yes, but the many at large spots go to good teams. There are plenty.

LiveCoug

1/12/21 3:38pm

Six at large spots in the CFB should be plenty

ManicBlue

1/12/21 4:54pm

It would be 5 and that's not enough to make up for UTSA or toledo

LiveCoug

1/12/21 5:00pm

How do you know if they don't get a chance to play? Btw, why are you using

ManicBlue

1/12/21 5:13pm

I think UTSA won it this year

puntersarepeople

1/12/21 5:42pm

Pretty sure it was UAB beating Marshall in the conf. championship

ManicBlue

1/12/21 11:55pm

Oh that’s right

puntersarepeople

1/13/21 8:20am

cambo

1/11/21 10:41pm

No way the P5 invites that many G5’s to their party. I think the best case

rivercitycoug

1/11/21 10:42pm

i know it won't happen but it should

BYU Grounds

1/11/21 10:45pm

This is the more likely scenario if expanded to 8 teams, P5s still keep most $

Sacto Cougar

1/11/21 11:00pm

You have to appease the powers that be without being too greedy...

PortlandCoug

1/11/21 10:57pm

Auto bids will never happen, which is why it MUST be 24 teams. BYU would likely

RUNBYU1

1/11/21 11:23pm

Just split the G5 back into their own division. The NCAA screwed up royally when

Nat Gas Man

1/11/21 11:31pm

Expand and limit scholarships. Both are needed

jkccoug

1/12/21 8:29am

Nil rule will help the scholarship situation

cougarfann888

1/12/21 8:36am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad